PG Music Home
Posted By: PgFantastic I Will Be Your Man - 07/04/14 10:59 PM
It's that time again folks. 5090 songwriting challenge started today. Here is the first song, hopefully of 50, all the tracks are Band in a Box, as always suggestions and comments welcome, thanks!

Bass 420
Chet Pickin Gtr 606
Acoustic Gtr 952
Drums Blues Shuffle
Resonator 585

I Will Be Your Man
Posted By: Greg Johnson Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/05/14 12:36 AM
Really cool song!! Great vocal, great arrangement! I really like returning to the soloed guitar. I hear a little Roy Orbison on the word "blue". The one thing that hits me kind of funny is when the drums come in without a fill beforehand, and stop abruptly at time. Great work! Take care. Greg
Posted By: Sundance Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/05/14 12:49 AM
I think Greg's on the something with the Roy Orbison - and that's always a good thing. In fact I could've just +1 on his comments and saved myself some typing....

This is great. I like it a lot Robert.

Oh and hats off for doing the 50/90 - one of these I'm going to have to try it.


Josie
Posted By: Charlie Fogle Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/05/14 01:39 AM
Good job Robert. Plus one from me too. I will agree that "blue' may sound a bit like Roy Orbison but to me the structure of the song and lyrics have the feel of a Paul McCartney composition. Enjoyed the song.

Charlie
Posted By: PgFantastic Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/05/14 03:41 PM
Thanks for the feedback everyone, much appreciated! thanks Greg for pointing out about the drums, when I finally have time I will put a fill in before the drums come in; During the 50/90 not much time for alterations.
Posted By: boehm Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/05/14 04:43 PM
Hi Robert,
Originally Posted By: Greg Johnson
Really cool song!! Great vocal, great arrangement!


Good luck for your 5090!

Guenter
Posted By: gruverider Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/05/14 08:33 PM
very inventive dynamics! I really like the creativity of it. The drums may need a bit of foreshadowing. ?

much enjoyed!
Posted By: RnAM Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/06/14 04:36 PM
Hi Robert,
We agree with most of the previous comments, but altogether a nice song with very nice choice of real tracks.
Regards,
R & AM
Posted By: RichMac Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/06/14 09:56 PM
Very enjoyable Robert. A great job and only 49 to go. You are amazingly inventive and prolific. Cheers.
Posted By: dani48 Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/06/14 10:01 PM
Hi, Robert !

+ 2 to what have been said !!:))
and good luck with the songwriting
competition from me too !

Cheers
Dani
Posted By: floyd jane Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/07/14 02:34 PM
Cool song, Robert! I like it. Good luck on the next 49! - floyd
Posted By: dcuny Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/07/14 03:50 PM
Heh. I was thinking it was a bit barren, and then the drums caught me by surprise.

Fun song, and ditto with the Roy Orbison vibe.
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/08/14 07:58 PM
Nice! I don't think I written 50 songs in my life smile Best to you!
Posted By: PgFantastic Re: I Will Be Your Man - 07/09/14 02:05 AM
Thanks everyone, I appreciate the feedback!
© PG Music Forums