PG Music Home
Does anybody know what the OK button is meant to do on the Chord Options dialog?
(I'm using build 1111)

[Linked Image]

Attached picture 2024-04-14_7-52-40.jpg
Posted By: DrDan Re: What is the OK button for on - 04/13/24 10:03 PM
Appears to do nothing. Same as the "Apply" button in the Bars Settings Menu (F5). I do believe this has been discussed here in the recent past. But I tend to have stopped even noticing these foibles in BIAB. We talk and talk, but these type of items don't change.
Posted By: Matt Finley Re: What is the OK button for on - 04/14/24 12:21 AM
Yes, I reported that this didn't seem to have an effect, and the action in the dialog box happens anyway. As I recall, there are a few others like this. For example, in Bar Settings, the entry for 3 beats per measure will 'apply' without clicking on Apply (and there is no OK button anyway in this dialog box).
Posted By: AudioTrack Re: What is the OK button for on - 04/14/24 02:10 AM
There's also two 'apply' buttons in the Bar Settings dialog. I think that has been reported.
Posted By: Gordon Scott Re: What is the OK button for on - 04/14/24 10:05 AM
It's long puzzled me that Windows rarely, if ever, has the "Dismiss" button that's common on Unixen for closing the dialog with no further consequences. Both OK and Cancel have potential ambiguities.

Apply - Apply the changes and keep the dialog open.
OK - apply the changes and close the dialog.
Cancel - Abort the changes and close the dialog.
Dismiss -- Just close the dialog.
Posted By: AudioTrack Re: What is the OK button for on - 04/14/24 10:58 AM
Originally Posted by Gordon Scott
It's long puzzled me that Windows rarely, if ever, has the "Dismiss" button that's common on Unixen for closing the dialog with no further consequences. Both OK and Cancel have potential ambiguities.

Apply - Apply the changes and keep the dialog open.
OK - apply the changes and close the dialog.
Cancel - Abort the changes and close the dialog.
Dismiss -- Just close the dialog.

Yes, we took exactly that approach when programming applications for DEC VAXes and Alpha's in OpenVMS. It's not a new approach. It's simply very intuitive.
Maybe we have become a little conditioned. OK just means 'get on with it'. Not the right amount of choices can be subjective.
Posted By: Gordon Scott Re: What is the OK button for on - 04/14/24 05:17 PM
Originally Posted by AudioTrack
Originally Posted by Gordon Scott
Dismiss -- Just close the dialog.
It's not a new approach..
Indeed; far from it ... I think it predates graphical user interfaces.
Posted By: Matt Finley Re: What is the OK button for on - 04/14/24 05:52 PM
Just for educational purposes, could someone give an example why Dismiss would be needed when Cancel wouldn’t do the same thing?
© PG Music Forums