PG Music Home
Posted By: Robertkc Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/14/17 03:50 PM
Vacant Chair (with Janice)

This is an old song I wrote & thought only family would relate to.
Since getting up & running with BiaB I`ve rewritten and revived a few old songs and with a couple of simple changes, figured this one was ready for a wider audience.
Over the last year I`ve listened to Janice singing many different songs and enjoyed them all, but hadn`t heard her sing a really sad one. Listening to her beautiful interpretation of this has been a highlight of the year for me...and working with Bud, who suggested and processed the piano track and gave excellent feedback on the mix, a pleasure.
We hope you enjoy our collaboration!

Key=Bb , Tempo 90, Length (m:s)=4:37
2 bar intro, 98 bar chorus, from bar 3 to bar 100. Repeat x1 chorus
Melody has 1425 notes, Melody harmony is < no harmony >(0)
No Soloist track.
Song is saved with Volume, Pan, Reverb, Chorus, Bank0,
Song is saved with bar changes for Volume Changes,
Style is M_CPOPSL.STY (Slow Country Pop w/ Piano )
RT 1856 Cello
RT 2773 Harp
MIDI SuperTracks in style: 1887:Piano, Solo-Accompaniment CountryPopJohn Ev 085


Vacant Chair

there`s a path through the autumn woods
his footsteps turned from
a song I can almost hear
a girl had begun
in the evening I still see her
collecting stones and questions from the air
to throw into the silent pool
around a vacant chair

who is wearing all the big shoes
taken from the closet
why are wedding photographs
in a box under the bed
that man said he`s in a better place
but I saw I heard the piper`s air
walking to tree seventeen
across town from a vacant chair

sometimes I go back to the old house
to look at fading pictures
blow the dust from the shadows
chase the grey from his hair
when the RCA radio plays Waltzing Matilda
I am dancing with my daddy
and there is no vacant chair

and wallpaper swallows
still fly toward the windows
his grey hat by the door
is dripping with cold rain
in the evening I still see her
singing her song her heart to repair
as long as sweet smoke lingers
above a vacant chair

sometimes I go back to the old house
to look at fading pictures
blow the dust from the shadows
chase the grey from his hair
when the RCA radio plays Waltzing Matilda
I am dancing with my daddy
and there is no vacant chair

dancing dancing with my daddy
dancing with my daddy

© Robert Cordrey May 1995

Posted By: Greg Johnson Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/14/17 05:51 PM
Very, very pretty!! You simply CAN'T do better than Janice for a vocal, and she nailed this!! The arrangement and mix are great. Wonderful job by all of you!! Take care . Greg
Posted By: Al-David Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/14/17 08:04 PM
What a lovely composition. And Janice was flawless - isn't she always? The piano guides the music exactly as it should. The strings are such a nice touch. Not overwhelming - just enough the know they're there.

Great job by both of you! Wishing you nothing but the best.

ALan & Di
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/14/17 10:05 PM
Originally Posted By: Greg Johnson
Very, very pretty!! You simply CAN'T do better than Janice for a vocal, and she nailed this!! The arrangement and mix are great. Wonderful job by all of you!! Take care . Greg


Greg, you are so kind to say that. When Robert asked if I'd like to sing this sweet song I was happy to oblige. I loved singing to the piano accompaniment and thought about my own Daddy quite a bit. It was a pleasure to be a part of this.

Janice
Posted By: Scott C Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/14/17 10:05 PM
Beautiful song Robert. You have a wonderful way with a song and lyric. This song was perfect for Janice's voice and she performed a perfect vocal. Simply a beautiful collaboration..
Posted By: animarorecords Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/15/17 01:33 AM
Hello, Robert and Janice

Great collaboration!
Very pretty song.
As Greg said, you simply CAN'T do better than Janice for a vocal, and she nailed this!!
The chord progression at "chase the grey from his hair" is very nice.
Enjoyed my listen a lot.

Best regards.

Shigeki Adachi
Posted By: BlueAttitude Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/15/17 10:45 AM
Very nice indeed! The Instrumentation was perfect for this. And Janice has such great tone and phrasing, always a pleasure to hear her sing.
Posted By: Skyline Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/15/17 11:59 AM
Simply sublime guys. A very moving listen.

John
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/15/17 12:27 PM
Originally Posted By: Al-David
What a lovely composition. And Janice was flawless - isn't she always? The piano guides the music exactly as it should. The strings are such a nice touch. Not overwhelming - just enough the know they're there.

Great job by both of you! Wishing you nothing but the best.

ALan & Di


Alan & Di,

Thank you!
Yes, Janice could sing the phone book and make it sound great... this was one take btw.
We listened to every piano accompaniment available before settling on the Supertrack ( and I think still find it just a little busy in places). I liked the lift the cello and harp gave to the chorus.

Robert

Originally Posted By: Scott C
Beautiful song Robert. You have a wonderful way with a song and lyric. This song was perfect for Janice's voice and she performed a perfect vocal. Simply a beautiful collaboration..


Many thanks for your kind words,Scott!

Robert

Originally Posted By: animarorecords
Hello, Robert and Janice

Great collaboration!
Very pretty song.
As Greg said, you simply CAN'T do better than Janice for a vocal, and she nailed this!!
The chord progression at "chase the grey from his hair" is very nice.
Enjoyed my listen a lot.

Best regards.

Shigeki Adachi


Shigeki,

I`m glad you enjoyed our song... and of course you noticed the only place where the chords move from a standard folk progression!
Regards,

Robert
Posted By: floyd jane Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/15/17 03:45 PM
A beautiful ballad, Robert. The melody kept me guessing (where it would go next) throughout. Melancholy.

The piano/cello/Janice combination - well, that's about as good as it gets... a gorgeous vocal.

fj
Posted By: MarioD Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/15/17 03:54 PM
WOW!

Janice's vocal is top shelf. The lyrics are super. I liked the way the cello came in as well as the piano.

You two should be very proud of this one.
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/15/17 05:12 PM
Originally Posted By: Al-David
What a lovely composition. And Janice was flawless - isn't she always? The piano guides the music exactly as it should. The strings are such a nice touch. Not overwhelming - just enough the know they're there.

Great job by both of you! Wishing you nothing but the best.

ALan & Di


Thank you so much. I appreciate your support over the last few years. It means a lot to me!

Janice
Posted By: tommyad Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/15/17 05:49 PM
Robert, Nicely written and arranged. The harp and cello work well. Beautifully sung by Janice. That one part of the melody where it goes low seems difficult to sing but she made it sound easy. It adds to the song by making it unique. Great job by all. Tom
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/15/17 09:55 PM
Originally Posted By: Scott C
Beautiful song Robert. You have a wonderful way with a song and lyric. This song was perfect for Janice's voice and she performed a perfect vocal. Simply a beautiful collaboration..


Thank you Scott. You're very kind to say that!

Janice
Posted By: HiroshiK Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/15/17 10:28 PM
Robert and Janice,

Perfect! The melody, piano solo and strings, Janice's vocal, and everything. I enjoyed all.

Hiroshi
Posted By: PeterF Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/16/17 05:07 AM
Robert & Janice

Got a nice tingle down the spine listening to that one.
Very nicely written - enjoyed the lyrics and tune and a superb interpretation and performance by Janice.
Really well done to all (and I know what a pleasure it is working with Bud on the production side).

Peter
Posted By: rsdean Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/16/17 08:12 AM
Robert / Janice / Bud,

Outstanding all around... Another killer vocal by Janice. Great song as well.

Bob
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/16/17 12:45 PM
Originally Posted By: animarorecords
Hello, Robert and Janice

Great collaboration!
Very pretty song.
As Greg said, you simply CAN'T do better than Janice for a vocal, and she nailed this!!
The chord progression at "chase the grey from his hair" is very nice.
Enjoyed my listen a lot.

Best regards.

Shigeki Adachi


Thank you Shigeki. Robert certainly gave me a lovely melody to sing.
I realty appreciate you for listening and commenting.

Janice
Posted By: RnAM Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/16/17 01:20 PM
Whow!!!
This is gorgeous, I detect some Jody Mitchell influences here.
What a cool composition, and I am pretty sure that this is Janice's best vocal performance so far.

Rob
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/16/17 01:30 PM
Originally Posted By: BlueAttitude
Very nice indeed! The Instrumentation was perfect for this. And Janice has such great tone and phrasing, always a pleasure to hear her sing.


Thanks Dave, glad you liked this.
For a simple arrangement we went through a surprising number of changes to arrive at this.
The really cool thing about hearing Janice sing this song was knowing right away she felt the lyrics.

Robert

Originally Posted By: Skyline
Simply sublime guys. A very moving listen.

John


Thank you John; that`s about the best endorsement I could have hoped for from a listener.

Robert
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/16/17 01:38 PM
Originally Posted By: floyd jane
A beautiful ballad, Robert. The melody kept me guessing (where it would go next) throughout. Melancholy.

The piano/cello/Janice combination - well, that's about as good as it gets... a gorgeous vocal.

fj


Floyd,
Thank you, I couldn`t agree more about all the praise for Janice`s singing!

Robert

Originally Posted By: MarioD
WOW!

Janice's vocal is top shelf. The lyrics are super. I liked the way the cello came in as well as the piano.

You two should be very proud of this one.


That`s very kind, Mario!

Robert
Posted By: Steve Young Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/16/17 08:25 PM
What an absolutely beautiful song! I love the write, and the simple arrangement allows all the feelings and emotions to ring out in this intimately personal song. Of course, Janice is a great choice for the vocals. As usual, you nailed it, Janice.

Loved this one!

Steve
Posted By: Torrey Bliss Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/16/17 09:44 PM
Robert/Janice, great work!! Vocal is beautiful and that piano is wonderful! It makes everything work. Pretty song. Take care, Torrey
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/17/17 09:14 AM
Originally Posted By: BlueAttitude
Very nice indeed! The Instrumentation was perfect for this. And Janice has such great tone and phrasing, always a pleasure to hear her sing.


Originally Posted By: Skyline
Simply sublime guys. A very moving listen.

John


Thanks y'all. I was very touched when Robert asked me to sing a composition that was so personal to him. I'm glad you liked it!

Janice
Posted By: Sergio Guarneri Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/17/17 09:48 AM

What a beautiful song!
A great combination of talent Robert & Janice.

Iloved it a lot.

Sergio
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/17/17 01:36 PM
Originally Posted By: tommyad
Robert, Nicely written and arranged. The harp and cello work well. Beautifully sung by Janice. That one part of the melody where it goes low seems difficult to sing but she made it sound easy. It adds to the song by making it unique. Great job by all. Tom


Tom,
I was a fairly new writer when this song began and remember getting help from my guitar teacher to make that low part fit with the chords I had. I also really like the way Janice phrased those parts here.
Many thanks for your listen and comments.

Robert

Originally Posted By: HiroshiK
Robert and Janice,

Perfect! The melody, piano solo and strings, Janice's vocal, and everything. I enjoyed all.

Hiroshi


Thank you, that`s very kind Hiroshi.
Robert
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/17/17 01:41 PM
Originally Posted By: PeterF
Robert & Janice

Got a nice tingle down the spine listening to that one.
Very nicely written - enjoyed the lyrics and tune and a superb interpretation and performance by Janice.
Really well done to all (and I know what a pleasure it is working with Bud on the production side).

Peter


Peter,
That`s a really cool endorsement; I`m glad you felt our collaboration hit the mark!

Robert

Originally Posted By: rsdean
Robert / Janice / Bud,

Outstanding all around... Another killer vocal by Janice. Great song as well.

Bob


Bob,
Your listen and commentsare much appreciated!

Robert
Posted By: 44kfl Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/17/17 10:10 PM
This is a powerful write

and expressed beautifully by Janice

just great imagery, gentle nostalgia

great storytelling

Kenny
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/18/17 12:23 PM
Originally Posted By: floyd jane
A beautiful ballad, Robert. The melody kept me guessing (where it would go next) throughout. Melancholy.

The piano/cello/Janice combination - well, that's about as good as it gets... a gorgeous vocal.

fj


Thank you floyd!

Janice
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/18/17 07:38 PM
Originally Posted By: RnAM
Whow!!!
This is gorgeous, I detect some Jody Mitchell influences here.
What a cool composition, and I am pretty sure that this is Janice's best vocal performance so far.

Rob


Rob,
Thank you!
This song is probably a a departure from J&B`s Americana material - I`m biased,of course, but I also think it brought out the best in her voice.

Robert

Originally Posted By: Steve Young
What an absolutely beautiful song! I love the write, and the simple arrangement allows all the feelings and emotions to ring out in this intimately personal song. Of course, Janice is a great choice for the vocals. As usual, you nailed it, Janice.

Loved this one!

Steve


Steve,
Thank you for your listen and very kind review.

Robert
Posted By: dani48 Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/18/17 07:45 PM
Hi, Robert !

I can but congratulate
you for a absolutely
super song and Janice
for a super performance !
this leads to a super
collaboration !

I loved everything
about this !

Cheers
Dani
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/18/17 10:53 PM
Originally Posted By: MarioD
WOW!

Janice's vocal is top shelf. The lyrics are super. I liked the way the cello came in as well as the piano.

You two should be very proud of this one.



I appreciate that Mario!

Janice
Posted By: AudioTrack Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/19/17 08:38 AM
What a fantastic ballad.

The unmistakable genius of Janice's voice, and with such a perfect clean backing.

Very, very nice.
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/19/17 08:06 PM
Originally Posted By: Torrey Bliss
Robert/Janice, great work!! Vocal is beautiful and that piano is wonderful! It makes everything work. Pretty song. Take care, Torrey


Torrey,
I`m glad you enjoyed this song.It was harder than I`d thought to find the right piano track,and Bud`s tweaking really helped it sit nicely behind Janice`s vocal.

Robert

Originally Posted By: Sergio Guarneri

What a beautiful song!
A great combination of talent Robert & Janice.

Iloved it a lot.

Sergio


Thank you,Sergio!

Robert



Originally Posted By: 44kfl
This is a powerful write

and expressed beautifully by Janice

just great imagery, gentle nostalgia

great storytelling

Kenny


Kenny,

Thanks for listening and commenting.
"gentle nostalgia" sums up what I was aiming for.

Robert
Posted By: Joe -PG Music Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/19/17 08:33 PM
Hi Robert, Great work on this! Really loved the progression and beautiful lyrics about nostalgia. Janices' voice is superb on this! Well done! smile
Posted By: Charlie Fogle Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/20/17 09:03 AM
Beautiful ballad. Great performance over a simple backing track is perfect for the arrangement. Great imagery in the lyrics. Collaborating with Janice and Bud is certainly the right combination.

Standing ovation from me. Very enjoyable listen.

Charlie
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/20/17 04:49 PM
Originally Posted By: tommyad
Robert, Nicely written and arranged. The harp and cello work well. Beautifully sung by Janice. That one part of the melody where it goes low seems difficult to sing but she made it sound easy. It adds to the song by making it unique. Great job by all. Tom


Thank you very much Tom!

Janice
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/21/17 01:57 PM
Originally Posted By: dani48
Hi, Robert !

I can but congratulate
you for a absolutely
super song and Janice
for a super performance !
this leads to a super
collaboration !

I loved everything
about this !

Cheers
Dani


Dani,
Thank you very much!

Robert

Originally Posted By: VideoTrack
What a fantastic ballad.

The unmistakable genius of Janice's voice, and with such a perfect clean backing.

Very, very nice.


I`m glad you enjoyed our collaboration!

Robert

Originally Posted By: Joe -PG Music
Hi Robert, Great work on this! Really loved the progression and beautiful lyrics about nostalgia. Janices' voice is superb on this! Well done! smile


Joe,
Thank you for your listen and positive comments.

Robert


Robert
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/22/17 08:36 AM
Originally Posted By: HiroshiK
Robert and Janice,

Perfect! The melody, piano solo and strings, Janice's vocal, and everything. I enjoyed all.

Hiroshi


Thank you!

Janice


Originally Posted By: PeterF
Robert & Janice

Got a nice tingle down the spine listening to that one.
Very nicely written - enjoyed the lyrics and tune and a superb interpretation and performance by Janice.
Really well done to all (and I know what a pleasure it is working with Bud on the production side).

Peter


Thank you Peter and Bud appreciates the compliment. He put a bunch of computer magic on the piano smile

Janice
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/22/17 08:45 PM
Originally Posted By: Charlie Fogle
Beautiful ballad. Great performance over a simple backing track is perfect for the arrangement. Great imagery in the lyrics. Collaborating with Janice and Bud is certainly the right combination.

Standing ovation from me. Very enjoyable listen.

Charlie


Charlie,
Thank you! We agreed from the start about the simple arrangement
and the whole process of working with Janice & Bud was an affirmation of how good this forum is.

Robert
Posted By: gruverider Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/23/17 02:54 PM
Beautiful! Haunting!

I just love the simplicity of the production.

And what a wonderful canvas for Janice to color!

And vocal tag at the end is something special
Posted By: David Snyder Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/23/17 03:38 PM
Robert and Janice,

Wow. Now this is songwriting and singing.

This one gave me goose bumps and I will listen many more times.

Outstanding. You should be really proud of yourself on this song guys.
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/24/17 11:33 AM
Originally Posted By: rsdean
Robert / Janice / Bud,

Outstanding all around... Another killer vocal by Janice. Great song as well.

Bob


Thank you Bob!

Janice

Originally Posted By: RnAM
Whow!!!
This is gorgeous, I detect some Jody Mitchell influences here.
What a cool composition, and I am pretty sure that this is Janice's best vocal performance so far.

Rob


Wow! That is very nice of you Rob!

Janice

Originally Posted By: Steve Young
What an absolutely beautiful song! I love the write, and the simple arrangement allows all the feelings and emotions to ring out in this intimately personal song. Of course, Janice is a great choice for the vocals. As usual, you nailed it, Janice.

Loved this one!

Steve


Steve, I really appreciate your comments. I often thought of my Daddy as I learned the song.

Janice
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/24/17 10:50 PM
Originally Posted By: gruverider
Beautiful! Haunting!

I just love the simplicity of the production.

And what a wonderful canvas for Janice to color!

And vocal tag at the end is something special


Thank you for those very kind comments!

Robert

Originally Posted By: David Snyder
Robert and Janice,

Wow. Now this is songwriting and singing.

This one gave me goose bumps and I will listen many more times.

Outstanding. You should be really proud of yourself on this song guys.


David,
Many thanks for that- an endorsement I really appreciate.

Robert
Posted By: LPman Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/25/17 01:22 AM
I really like this collaboration, there's a lot's to learn from this song. Great work!
Posted By: JoanneCooper Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/25/17 07:35 AM
Robert, Janice and Bud

A really super collaboration all round. Just lovely!
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/26/17 09:03 AM
Originally Posted By: Torrey Bliss
Robert/Janice, great work!! Vocal is beautiful and that piano is wonderful! It makes everything work. Pretty song. Take care, Torrey


Thank you Torrey! Bud asked me to mention that he used a Grand Steinway sound from Logic Pro on the piano.

Janice

Originally Posted By: Sergio Guarneri

What a beautiful song!
A great combination of talent Robert & Janice.

Iloved it a lot.

Sergio


Thank yo very much Sergio!
Janice

Originally Posted By: 44kfl
This is a powerful write

and expressed beautifully by Janice

just great imagery, gentle nostalgia

great storytelling

Kenny


I very much appreciate that Kenny. I felt the same way when I first read the lyric. I'm so happy that Robert invited me to sing it.

Janice
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/27/17 11:49 AM
Originally Posted By: LPman
I really like this collaboration, there's a lot's to learn from this song. Great work!


Thank you for your listen and comments!

Robert
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/29/17 06:12 PM
Originally Posted By: dani48
Hi, Robert !

I can but congratulate
you for a absolutely
super song and Janice
for a super performance !
this leads to a super
collaboration !

I loved everything
about this !

Cheers
Dani


Thank you Dani!


Originally Posted By: VideoTrack
What a fantastic ballad.

The unmistakable genius of Janice's voice, and with such a perfect clean backing.

Very, very nice.


You are way too kind! Thanks so much.

Janice



Originally Posted By: Joe -PG Music
Hi Robert, Great work on this! Really loved the progression and beautiful lyrics about nostalgia. Janices' voice is superb on this! Well done! smile

Thank you Joe! It was a fun collaboration.

Janice


Originally Posted By: Charlie Fogle
Beautiful ballad. Great performance over a simple backing track is perfect for the arrangement. Great imagery in the lyrics. Collaborating with Janice and Bud is certainly the right combination.

Standing ovation from me. Very enjoyable listen.

Charlie


Charlie, Bud and I very much appreciate what you wrote. It was a great lyric to sing!

Janice
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 04/30/17 10:27 PM
Originally Posted By: gruverider
Beautiful! Haunting!

I just love the simplicity of the production.

And what a wonderful canvas for Janice to color!

And vocal tag at the end is something special


Thanks Lawrence. It was fun coloring that canvas!

Janice


Originally Posted By: David Snyder
Robert and Janice,

Wow. Now this is songwriting and singing.

This one gave me goose bumps and I will listen many more times.

Outstanding. You should be really proud of yourself on this song guys.


Thank you David! We so much appreciate your comments and support.

Janice


Originally Posted By: LPman
I really like this collaboration, there's a lot's to learn from this song. Great work!



Originally Posted By: JoanneCooper
Robert, Janice and Bud

A really super collaboration all round. Just lovely!


Thanks y'all!

Janice
Posted By: Noel96 Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 05/03/17 05:00 AM
Originally Posted By: floyd jane
A beautiful ballad, Robert. The melody kept me guessing (where it would go next) throughout. Melancholy.

The piano/cello/Janice combination - well, that's about as good as it gets... a gorgeous vocal.

fj


Robert,

floyd has described the journey that I too experienced and the thoughts that occurred to me so I'm +1'ing his comments. You, Janice and Bud have done a great job!

All the best,
Noel
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 05/03/17 10:29 AM
Originally Posted By: Noel96
Originally Posted By: floyd jane
A beautiful ballad, Robert. The melody kept me guessing (where it would go next) throughout. Melancholy.

The piano/cello/Janice combination - well, that's about as good as it gets... a gorgeous vocal.

fj


Robert,

floyd has described the journey that I too experienced and the thoughts that occurred to me so I'm +1'ing his comments. You, Janice and Bud have done a great job!

All the best,
Noel
Originally Posted By: Noel96
Originally Posted By: floyd jane
A beautiful ballad, Robert. The melody kept me guessing (where it would go next) throughout. Melancholy.

The piano/cello/Janice combination - well, that's about as good as it gets... a gorgeous vocal.

fj


Robert,

floyd has described the journey that I too experienced and the thoughts that occurred to me so I'm +1'ing his comments. You, Janice and Bud have done a great job!

All the best,
Noel


Thank you Noel. I always think of your great ballads when I attempt one.

Janice
Posted By: 90 dB Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 05/03/17 11:53 AM




This is good stuff! From the heart.


Regards,


Bob
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Vacant Chair (with Janice) - 05/03/17 01:42 PM
Originally Posted By: 90 dB




This is good stuff! From the heart.


Regards,

Bob


Thank you for the kind words and for the applause smile

Janice
© PG Music Forums