You need to be logged in to post on the forum
Topic Options
Index
#424156 - 08/02/17 03:53 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Tips for making a mix sound good in mono?
BlueAttitude Offline
Expert

Registered: 11/30/07
Posts: 1699
Loc: Ontario, Canada
Morning folks,
I have read many times that when working on a mix you should always check to make sure it sounds good not only in stereo but in mono.

Does anyone have any tips on how to accomplish that??
When I listen to one of my mixes in mono it always sounds dull and lifeless compared to the stereo mix, not to mention that the levels are all off. But, how to fix the levels so it sounds good in mono without breaking the stereo mix? crazy


Edited by BlueAttitude (08/02/17 05:05 AM)
Edit Reason: removed reference to iPads
_________________________
Dave

Blue Attitude: Homepage, Youtube page

Top
#424160 - 08/02/17 04:55 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
Janice & Bud Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/05/11
Posts: 6231
Loc: GA USA
I'm wondering about the mobile device listening. Most folks I know listen with buds in stereo. Heck if they are listening via most device's external speakers IMO nothing will sound decent.

BTW I know zip about Android phones/tablets but my Apple products have external stereo speakers.

OK...pardon the musings that did nothing to address your issue smile

Bud
_________________________
Never grow up...it's a trap.
Our 2018 album release
J&B YouTube Sampler
J&B Website

Top
#424162 - 08/02/17 05:04 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
BlueAttitude Offline
Expert

Registered: 11/30/07
Posts: 1699
Loc: Ontario, Canada
Hi Bud,
Shows what I know about iPads! I'm so out of the loop when it comes to that stuff, I don't even own a cell phone blush

I'll modify my original post to get rid of that line, thanks smile
_________________________
Dave

Blue Attitude: Homepage, Youtube page

Top
#424164 - 08/02/17 05:27 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
Janice & Bud Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/05/11
Posts: 6231
Loc: GA USA
I've also read about the reasons for the mono approach but have never understood it. We hear in stereo -- why confine any sound stage to mono when we've had stereo technology for decades?

And why remix just to hear it in mono? Simply converting a stereo mix to mono destroys all the work done to assign each track to its "place." A place where it has its uniqueness yet cooperates with fellow tracks. It seems that a good sounding mono mix would require a dramatically different approach and work.

Perhaps this is where I should be silent and appear to be ignorant rather than opening my mouth and confirming it. smile

Bud
_________________________
Never grow up...it's a trap.
Our 2018 album release
J&B YouTube Sampler
J&B Website

Top
#424192 - 08/02/17 08:30 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
90 dB Offline
Veteran

Registered: 04/20/10
Posts: 4746
Loc: Florida
_________________________
Dyslectics Untie!


https://90dbband.bandcamp.com/

https://soundcloud.com/90-db



Top
#424195 - 08/02/17 09:34 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: 90 dB]
BlueAttitude Offline
Expert

Registered: 11/30/07
Posts: 1699
Loc: Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted By: 90 dB


Excellent article! Thanks! smile
_________________________
Dave

Blue Attitude: Homepage, Youtube page

Top
#424226 - 08/02/17 12:19 PM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
Janice & Bud Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/05/11
Posts: 6231
Loc: GA USA
I'm gonna make a second attempt to read that Bob and hopefully get schooled. On my first attempt I didn't get past the "...For example, a lot of portable radios are mono." In my old age have I missed some mono radio revival like the vinyl thing? Seriously....well mostly. smile I do remember walking around with my little mono transistor radio in the late 50's.

Edit:

I read it all but still have difficulty with: "However, if you can get the mix to sound good in mono first, it will definitely sound great in stereo too." That seems to imply that you just hit a stereo button and presto the mono is stereo. But know you can't do a wholesale conversion in either direction. And then he said mixing in stereo is "easy." I guess that is very relative as that has not been my experience. I'm gonna dig deeper and see if some epiphany can emerge. I know I'm still missing something given the expertise of the proponents.


Edit:

Short but seems to hit on the primary reasons: https://mixcoach.com/does-mixing-in-mono-really-help/
He mentions how mono mixing can help understand (help eliminate?) sonic issues of having tracks stepping on one another. I can see how it would help there except for the always troublesome kick and bass that are, at least by me, mixed in the center in a stereo mix. Hey Dave, hope you don't think I hi-jacked your thread. Janice will tell you that I have a penchant for thinking out loud...often to a fault smile

Bud


Edited by Janice & Bud (08/02/17 01:41 PM)
_________________________
Never grow up...it's a trap.
Our 2018 album release
J&B YouTube Sampler
J&B Website

Top
#424257 - 08/02/17 03:13 PM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
Matcham Offline
Apprentice

Registered: 07/05/16
Posts: 221
Loc: Byron Bay, NSW, Australia
I've been following the mix-in-mono arguments too. While they are very logical, at the end of the day there seems no escaping that there are significant differences between mono and stereo mixing. You could do your head in trying to straddle both camps. Instead a lot of engineers talk about checking mono compatibility during their mixes. So they mix in stereo and check every so often that their work still sounds good in mono especially given that you can introduce weird phasing issues stereo to mono. There are plugins now that quickly convert the stereo buss to mono for an instant listen.

I like the idea that mono mixing can help you achieve frequency separation amongst instruments but as Bud says a lot of the main clashes are right down the centre anyway.
_________________________
Soundcloud:
https://soundcloud.com/matcham-caine/sets/originals

Top
#424263 - 08/02/17 03:45 PM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
rharv Offline
Veteran

Registered: 05/30/00
Posts: 18967
Loc: Marysville, Mi. USA
IMHO, it helps for 2 things.
1. As mentioned; sonics (frequency ranges and signal strength of various tracks).
It is possible to actually have phase cancelling going on and a MONO mix will make it more evident, let alone bass and bass drum stepping all over each other on certain notes, etc.
B. It's always good to at least know what the mix will sound like in MONO (maybe it will get played over a PA at some unknown location someday). At least you will have improved it .. whether or not it is ideal.

I do not do separate mixes. I'll do my stereo mix, listen to it in MONO (easy as clicking the MONO button on the mixer in PT or RB). If I can improve by doing so, why not? There will always be a happy medium.

Years ago bands/producers experimented with quadraphonic mixes .. but it had to still work in MONO, which was by far more common at the time than now. These were vinyl records.

These days an equivalent is 5.1 etc.

.. plus 'Soundbars', which are essentially a MONO source 'location' with smoke and mirrors to make you think it is something more. By that I mean all speakers are located within inches of each other .. like bolting your stereo speakers together; the sound comes from one location, but you do get multiple 'channels' ..

There are lots of various listening environments where checking the mix in MONO could be a good thing.
_________________________
Make your sound your own!

Top
#424290 - 08/02/17 06:37 PM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
Janice & Bud Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/05/11
Posts: 6231
Loc: GA USA
So your approach is that a stereo mix should be built around the possibilty that it might be heard in a mono environment? And that this can be achieved sans compromises with the stereo mix? That is all WAY above my paygrade. My first mixing was at a studio in Atlanta in 1965 when I was 19 and, yep, it was mono but I have not thought of mono mixes in many decades. Too old to go back. smile
_________________________
Never grow up...it's a trap.
Our 2018 album release
J&B YouTube Sampler
J&B Website

Top
#424311 - 08/03/17 03:57 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: Janice & Bud]
BlueAttitude Offline
Expert

Registered: 11/30/07
Posts: 1699
Loc: Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted By: Janice & Bud
Hey Dave, hope you don't think I hi-jacked your thread. Janice will tell you that I have a penchant for thinking out loud...often to a fault smile

Bud


No worries Bud! I'm enjoying reading all the comments smile

What started this for me was I submitted my latest song to this new facebook group where you can have people critique your mix. Lots of comments, but one very detailed one from someone who really knew his stuff, and one of the many things he mentioned was that my mix sounded like crap when played back in mono.
And sure enough, it does!

In my case as you know our songs feature guitar, sometimes lots of guitar tracks, plus a female vocalist. Both occupy the same frequency range. When I'm mixing in stereo that is not a problem, I handle it via panning so everything has it's own space in the stereo spectrum.

The key thing I got out of the article is the need to use eq to carve out space for the vocalist:

"Yet, when that great‑sounding stereo mix is collapsed to mono, you will often find it no longer works, because those sources occupy the same spectrum and end up trampling all over one another."

That is something I don't do, but I think I should be. It seems if I do that it will probably improve the stereo mix too, it won't be as muddy. Anyway it is something I'm going to spend some time learning more about.
Also I've been checking into izotope neutron, it seems like that may be a great solution.


Edited by BlueAttitude (08/03/17 03:59 AM)
_________________________
Dave

Blue Attitude: Homepage, Youtube page

Top
#424313 - 08/03/17 04:53 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
Janice & Bud Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/05/11
Posts: 6231
Loc: GA USA
As I've often said Neutron's feature that allows you to compare multiple tracks to isolate competing frequencies has been for me worth the price of admission alone. It's easy to use and IMO effective. And not just for kick and bass but for any tracks that tend to occupy the same eq areas.
_________________________
Never grow up...it's a trap.
Our 2018 album release
J&B YouTube Sampler
J&B Website

Top
#424324 - 08/03/17 06:12 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
beatmaster Offline
Journeyman

Registered: 05/16/17
Posts: 657
Mixing in mono is only done as a reference. You use it to check EQ separation without the extra "artificial" separation caused by panning. You don't leave it that way.

1. Collapsing the master to mono is sufficient
2. The assumption is you'd put the master back into stereo, where you can pan things wherever you want.
3. You should never have to do that
4. Reverb is tough to deal with in mono. Mixing in mono is really just to check levels and EQ. I wouldn't make reverb decisions in mono.
5&6. If the final song is in stereo (as 99% of music made after 1965 is), then you'd obviously master in stereo. Mastering is where you are making the final decisions. Whatever comes out is the song.
_________________________
win 10 64 bit 16gb, ssd 500gb, Alesis multimix8 usb,ketron sd 1000,shure sm7b,sonar,acid,mixcraft, variety of plugins.Sample tank 3, digitech vocalist live 2 ,Byerdynamic 770 pro, akg k270,akg k701.
https://beatmaster1.bandcamp.com/releases

Top
#424338 - 08/03/17 08:28 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: beatmaster]
BlueAttitude Offline
Expert

Registered: 11/30/07
Posts: 1699
Loc: Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted By: beatmaster
Mixing in mono is only done as a reference. You use it to check EQ separation without the extra "artificial" separation caused by panning. You don't leave it that way.



Well yes, I think that was understood. I don't think anyone thought you would leave it in mono eek


Edited by BlueAttitude (08/03/17 01:37 PM)
_________________________
Dave

Blue Attitude: Homepage, Youtube page

Top
#424374 - 08/03/17 02:25 PM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
Matcham Offline
Apprentice

Registered: 07/05/16
Posts: 221
Loc: Byron Bay, NSW, Australia
I recall Ozone has a button right there on the main screen where you can check mono compatibility. You'll know all about it if it seems half your song has been sucked out. Non-Ozone users have easy options too.
_________________________
Soundcloud:
https://soundcloud.com/matcham-caine/sets/originals

Top
#424414 - 08/04/17 03:24 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: Matcham]
BlueAttitude Offline
Expert

Registered: 11/30/07
Posts: 1699
Loc: Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted By: Matcham
I recall Ozone has a button right there on the main screen where you can check mono compatibility. You'll know all about it if it seems half your song has been sucked out. Non-Ozone users have easy options too.


I use reaper to mix, it also has a mono button on the main screen.
_________________________
Dave

Blue Attitude: Homepage, Youtube page

Top
#424416 - 08/04/17 04:46 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: Janice & Bud]
BlueAttitude Offline
Expert

Registered: 11/30/07
Posts: 1699
Loc: Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted By: Janice & Bud
As I've often said Neutron's feature that allows you to compare multiple tracks to isolate competing frequencies has been for me worth the price of admission alone. It's easy to use and IMO effective. And not just for kick and bass but for any tracks that tend to occupy the same eq areas.


Bud, which version of neutron do you have, the standard or advanced? I see they are both on sale at the moment,
standard is on sale for $199, advanced is $299. They both have the masking meter feature (elements does not)
_________________________
Dave

Blue Attitude: Homepage, Youtube page

Top
#424421 - 08/04/17 05:36 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
Janice & Bud Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/05/11
Posts: 6231
Loc: GA USA
I've got the standard version that I bought on the cheap from Izotope on a deal offfered to folks who own a host of their products. I have a filter that alarms before I over purchase with features that I'd likely never use (or understand) smile I did buy the advanced version of Ozone 7 solely for the reason that any of the modules can individually be used on a single track.

Bud
_________________________
Never grow up...it's a trap.
Our 2018 album release
J&B YouTube Sampler
J&B Website

Top
#424436 - 08/04/17 06:29 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: BlueAttitude]
beatmaster Offline
Journeyman

Registered: 05/16/17
Posts: 657
So sorry, but I seemed to have misunderstood the posting.

I will say I am guilty, on this occasion of not reading the post thoroughly.

I should have so I stand corrected and hung drawn, and quartered.

OUCH !
_________________________
win 10 64 bit 16gb, ssd 500gb, Alesis multimix8 usb,ketron sd 1000,shure sm7b,sonar,acid,mixcraft, variety of plugins.Sample tank 3, digitech vocalist live 2 ,Byerdynamic 770 pro, akg k270,akg k701.
https://beatmaster1.bandcamp.com/releases

Top
#424440 - 08/04/17 06:50 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: Tips for making a mix sound good in mono? [Re: beatmaster]
BlueAttitude Offline
Expert

Registered: 11/30/07
Posts: 1699
Loc: Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted By: beatmaster
So sorry, but I seemed to have misunderstood the posting.

I will say I am guilty, on this occasion of not reading the post thoroughly.

I should have so I stand corrected and hung drawn, and quartered.

OUCH !


No worries, it happens smile
_________________________
Dave

Blue Attitude: Homepage, Youtube page

Top


PG Music News
National Dictionary Day - Guitar & Piano Chord Dictionaries

Today is National Dictionary Day!

We offer 2 dictionaries for just $19 each: the Guitar Chord Dictionary & the Piano Chord Dictionary!

Each of these programs are easy to use! Simply choose a root note, select the chord you want to learn, and the Dictionary will play and display the chord!

An Essential Tool for any Musician!

User Tip - Band-in-a-Box® to Reaper: The Basics

Forum user DeaconBlues09 has created a video to demonstrate how easy the process is for them to streamline their workflow with DAWs, particularly Reaper - check it out: click here to watch.

Join the forum discussion.

Train Your Brain with Band-in-a-Box®

National Train Your Brain Day is October 13th!

Open your Band-in-a-Box® program, and you'll find the [Practice] button in the toolbar - it's a GREAT resource!
Minimized your toolbar? Head to Window | Practice Window or ALT SHIFT L to access

In this window, you'll find many options to help you practice, including Ear Training games, access to the Chord Builder and Chord Subs, some helpful tools within the Playalong Features menu, and more!

Train Your Brain with Band-in-a-Box® today!

Band-in-a-Box Patch Updates - #TechTuesday

Visit our Patches & Updates page, and you will see that with every version released, there are 2+ patch updates applied to that version.

Patch updates are important, and should definitely be installed to your BB folder. They can add new features, update the help resources of the program, fix bugs reported by users, and make your entire Band-in-a-Box experience run smoothly!

Band-in-a-Box update options can be adjusted within the program too - within Band-in-a-Box for Mac, head to Band-in-a-Box | Check for Updates | and then you can select to automatically check for updates by however many days you choose!

Xtra Styles PAK 5 Contest - Listen to All the Entries!

Our Xtra Styles PAK 5 Contest is over, and the winners have been announced - congratulations again to forum users fiddler2007, rodipoet, Will Josef, and Ezekiel's Storm!

And, a BIG thank you to everyone who entered their songs on our contest - WOW what a great list of songs! We've arranged all the song entries into one simple list, if you'd like to listen to all the entries click here.

Congratulations Xtra Styles PAK 5 Song Contest Winners!

Thank you again to everyone who submitted their songs to our Xtra Styles PAK 5 Song Contest - 59 entries in total!

As always, we were blown away with every song entered! We truly enjoy listening to what everyone comes up with using Band-in-a-Box!

Our judging team listened to all the songs, and choosing the winners wasn't easy... some of the things taken into consideration were the quality of the composition, Xtra styles used, use of program features within the song, and originality - and we're now ready to announce the winners!

The Winners are:

Country:
I Will Be Your Doggie Listen to the song here
Artist/Forum User: fiddler2007
Xtra Style used: _WILDONE
Original Forum Post

Jazz:
Wie zingt verjaagt zijn pijn (He who sings expels his pain) Listen to the song here
Artist/Forum User: rodipoet
Xtra Styles Used: _SILKY
Original Forum Post

MIDI:
Child of the 70s Listen to the song here
Artist/Forum User: Will Josef
Xtra Style Used: HORIZON
Original Forum Post

Rock-Pop:
Hide it Away Listen to the song here
Artist/Forum User: Ezekiel's Storm
Xtra Style used: _CHEATED
Original Forum Post

Congratulations everyone!

Band-in-a-Box® 2018 for Windows: Making Songs

Visit Chapter 6: Making Songs in our online Band-in-a-Box 2018 for Windows User's Guide, and you'll learn (or be reminded of) all the different steps you could take for creating your own song using Band-in-a-Box®!

Learn about naming your song, choosing a key, setting the tempo, chord entry, and more! There's even information for more advanced use! Read about Song Settings (endings, tags, style variations, pushes, rests, and chord embellishments), Part Markers, Substyles, Song Form, applying Styles, using RealTrack/RealDrums, importing MIDI, and chord entry - just to name a few!

Forum Stats
28071 Members
57 Forums
54411 Topics
449796 Posts

Max Online: 2434 @ 11/14/17 12:37 AM
Newest Members
ugtk, Laureli06, helenmai, chuckster55, KeithR

28071 Registered Users
Top Posters (30 Days)
Alyssa - PG Music 215
David Snyder 160
Noel96 155
Janice & Bud 141
Matt Finley 140
Tangmo 130
Will Josef 129
MarioD 120
Jim Fogle 113
Deryk - PG Music 113
Today's Birthdays
dmws