PG Music Home
Posted By: edshaw When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/17/21 05:34 PM
When Jesus Got a Hold on Me

Still plugging away with the Fusion Project. Thanks for listening.
(Starting to get the hang of the R-16 smile
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/20/21 12:50 PM
Flows like a gentle stream...

Nice!

J&B
Posted By: edshaw Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/20/21 11:07 PM
I was hoping you'd like it smile
Posted By: Gary Weder Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/21/21 01:15 AM
Hi Ed
Your vocals are hitting it for six (cricket parlance) . I think in the USA you say hitting it out of the park . I could not think of another way to compliment your excellent vox.

Ed wrote <"Starting to get the hang of the R-16">

Yep , sounding good.

Keep 'em coming Ed (btw do you do requests? Closer Walk with Thee )

cheers
Gary.
Posted By: dcuny Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/21/21 02:52 AM
I got up to 1:40 and figured it was an instrumental. grin

I enjoyed the listen - thanks for posting!
Posted By: edshaw Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/21/21 05:18 PM
Thanks, Gary. I have this one, that to my surprise out performed the rest on Drooble. It is instrumental & about time for it to get the vocal track.
https://drooble.com/song/3029693
Hey, David. it is:
V1 Ch1 -- Instr. Piano
V2 Ch2 -- Instr. G.
V3 Ch3 -- Vocal
If you were to rearrange, what would you? I confess, my arrangements today are based on what I feel are the best takes. Not a good system. Thanks for the comment.
Posted By: gruverider Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/21/21 06:35 PM
Warm and calming.

Much enjoyed.
Posted By: dcuny Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/21/21 08:05 PM
Originally Posted By: edshaw
Hey, David. it is:
V1 Ch1 -- Instr. Piano
V2 Ch2 -- Instr. G.
V3 Ch3 -- Vocal
If you were to rearrange, what would you?

Just because a song falls outside the norms doesn't mean it should be changed. smile

Generally, there's nothing wrong with having a short vocal song. I'd have probably dropped the long instrumental, or put it at the end.

But would it have been an improvement? I wouldn't say that.

I didn't comment because I was complaining, just that I was surprised.

Unless you've got someone who skips your version because they don't find vocals in the first half - and that's not likely a real problem - I see no reason to change it.
Posted By: edshaw Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/21/21 10:32 PM
Thanks, David. Good Advice.
Thank you for that, gruverider
Posted By: floyd jane Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/22/21 11:28 AM
ed,

One of your best.
Good balance between vocal and tracks.
Well done.

fj
Posted By: Scott C Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/23/21 04:10 PM
Well done Ed. Guitar sounds great. Well done
Posted By: edshaw Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/23/21 10:36 PM
Thanks Floyd. Thanks, Scott.
I'm finding a work flow -- do a public domain, do an original. Going with that.
Posted By: CaptainMoto Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/24/21 01:04 PM
You nailed your genre.
Well done.

moto
Posted By: firesong Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/24/21 01:19 PM
Hey Ed...love the easy flow and feeling of the tune and really appreciate the message...great job...Dan
Posted By: edshaw Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/26/21 02:42 PM
Thanks for that, Captain Moto.
Thank you, Firesong.
You guys do nice work!
Posted By: Derochette Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 03/26/21 05:45 PM
Hi edshaw,

Nice very catchy composition. It is soft in the chosen arrangement. It's pleasant and well done.

Kindly regard
Derochette
alias JaniJackFlash
Posted By: edshaw Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 04/03/21 11:57 AM
Thanks, Derochette. I enjoy sharing this space with you and so many other inspirational musicians.
Posted By: Deej56 Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 04/03/21 09:07 PM
Ed,

It’s a pretty arrangement, and your vocal is really strong (though I’m wondering if it should sit back in the mix just a little bit—it’s a little too forward on a couple of notes). I think for me among the best I’ve heard from you.

I do think David has a point about the long “intro”—not sure the casual listener will stay with it (unless they are a fan of instrumentals). Mind you, it works as is. If I were to think about an alternative way to do it, I’d shorten the intro (maybe to 30 seconds or so) and then use the break after the first verse (at 2:32) to go into a longer instrumental, finishing up with that last verse and ending the song just how you do.

As David said, that’s not necessarily an improvement, just a different approach to cater to the dwindling attention span of many of today's listeners.

Good stuff, Ed!

All my best to you,

Deej
Posted By: Greg Johnson Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 04/07/21 08:11 PM
Originally Posted By: Janice & Bud
Flows like a gentle stream...

Nice!

J&B


Agreed!! Very comfortable and authentic sound!! Take care. Greg
Posted By: edshaw Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 04/07/21 10:44 PM
Thanks for the listen and comment, Deej56. Points well taken.
Thank you, Greg. There's this undiscovered treasure trove of
bluegrass gospel on YouTube that has been helpful.
Posted By: BabuMusic Re: When Jesus Got a Hold on Me - 04/08/21 08:58 AM
REALLY good, Ed. Makes me want to get in on the hug.
© PG Music Forums