PG Music Home
Posted By: dsbw Generating Music. Please Wait... - 06/19/18 10:39 PM
Opened up an SGU in RealBand and the little comments thing comes up and the main page says "Generating Music. Please Wait..." on the title bar.

I actually wrote to say "and then it never came back" but it does actually come back an hour later. Is that right?
What did it do in all that time?

(My larger context: I set up a song in BiaB and figured I would replace each of the tracks one by one with me playing a real instrument. I'm not sure if this is even the way to go about it but I thought that was a curious delay.)
Posted By: rharv Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 06/19/18 10:59 PM
"Generating Music. Please Wait..."

I usually see an "Initializing Accompaniment" message
but either way an hour seems really excessive. That usually lasts a minute or so at most here.

But yes, RB is an ideal tool to replace the BB tracks one by one.
In my workflow, one of the first things I do if I plan to replace all the tracks is use the 'Make all BB tracks regular tracks' option, so it doesn't try to keep generating them (and possibly causing the above mentioned screen).

Then I can work in more of a DAW like setting.
Posted By: dsbw Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 06/20/18 01:40 AM
Thanks. Cool. I shall carry on.

Maybe it was because they were all Real Band tracks? (Which is kinda pointless, I guess, if I'm replacing them all.)
Posted By: rharv Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 06/20/18 08:58 PM
Yes, if you are going to replace them yourself, might as well just use what you have for now until you replace it, as opposed to repeatedly regenerating stuff you plan to replace anyway. smile

Here, if they are BB tracks in Realband they show with blue titles (track names) and regenerate .. after making them Regular tracks they have black titles and don't auto-generate.

Attached picture BBtracks-RB.jpg
Attached picture RegularTracks-RB.jpg
Posted By: Guitarhacker Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 06/21/18 04:10 PM
I have a 10 year old, XP Pro 32bit machine with 4 GB of memory.....and it only takes about 20 seconds to a minute depending on the song and the tracks.

It tells me it's "Initializing Accompaniment". Even at startup it's only a minute.

So yeah, an hour seems extremely long. Even my old really slow laptop didn't take more than a minute or two at the most to generate the tracks in RB.

Larger context: Yep.... if you can play the tracks in question better than the RB RT players..... certainly. I do this all the time. Just mute the track it created and set up a new track to record your instrument.

More than one time, I have spent hours working on a part and in the end.... decided to work with the RB RT since it was clearly better. Either in tonal quality or performance. So.... don't delete the track until you're absolutely sure your track is the keeper.
Posted By: DebMurphy Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 06/22/18 07:03 AM
Might your anti-virus be causing the issue? I've seen slow response from other apps.

...Deb
Posted By: Kent - PG Music Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 06/22/18 09:45 PM
Hi DSBW,

Which version of Windows are you using? Also, what's the make and model of your processor, and how much RAM do you have? If you're not sure about the processor and RAM, you can find out by going to the Windows Control Panel and clicking on System.

Thanks
Kent
PG Music
Posted By: dsbw Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 06/30/18 10:40 PM
Windows 10.0.10586 (64-bit)

Intel i7-6700 CPU @ 3.40Ghz

32 GB of RAM

It's very peculiar and very consistent (in terms of taking a long time). It also doesn't seem to generate anything, oddly enough. Like after it's all done, I press play and it just flashes on the -1 measure.
Posted By: dsbw Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 06/30/18 10:44 PM
I don't have anti-virus. It causes way too many problems for me as a developer.

"AHHHHH! NEW UNRECOGNIZED EXE! KILL IT!"
"No, really, I just made it, it's fine."
"TURN OFF CHECKS FOR THIS DIRECTORY OR I'LL KEEP SCREAMING!"
"OK. Turned off."
"AHHH!! WHO ARE YOU AND WHAT IS THAT .EXE!"

40 years and I've never had a virus except in circumstances I expected them (when checking suspect machines in loosely controlled business situations); I'm very disinclined to use anything that annoying.
Posted By: dsbw Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 06/30/18 10:46 PM
Oh, I have a knack for finding weird stuff like this. I probably did something funky in BiaB.

The problem I have with BiaB's sound, so far, is essentially the aural version of "uncanny valley". I think I can get around that when I'm better with it but right now, I'm finding it hard to groove to.
Posted By: dsbw Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 06/30/18 10:46 PM
Ooh, good tip, thanks, rharv!
Posted By: DebMurphy Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 07/01/18 02:26 PM
Sorry, slightly off topic. Bur responding to this thread.

Before I retired, I worked at a university with 40,000 plus students. The students were always giving us viruses... human and computer versions...

Back in the days of the "I love you" virus, a friend said she never knew the students and staff to be so affectionate.

...Deb
Posted By: dsbw Re: Generating Music. Please Wait... - 07/01/18 07:28 PM
Students are top-flight virus vectors (on so many levels!) because you just say "Hey! This is free!" and they'll bite.

Lab technicians (this is some kind of irony, I'm sure) have also been a rich source of virii in my experience.
© PG Music Forums