PG Music Home
OK, this one is WAY off-topic, but here goes.

There is some marvelous harmon mute trumpet playing in a short music snippet during a rerun episode of House on TV. I would love to know who this is who is playing, and I'll buy this recording.

The episode is season one (1995), episode nine, called DNR.

In the episode, a fictitious trumpet player named John Henry Giles gets sick. House is shown listening to a record (yes, an LP) with the name John Henry Giles on the album. Later, Giles' music is played after he has the operation he needs.

I taped two short audio files of it.

The first is while House listens to the album with headphones, as Foreman enters.

http://premium.fileden.com/premium/2008/2/1/1735022/House/John%20Henry%20Giles%20part%20one.mp3

The second is a wonderful quartet including vibes backing up the trumpet. It sounds fairly modern to me. Who is this?

http://premium.fileden.com/premium/2008/2/1/1735022/House/John%20Henry%20Giles%20part%20two.mp3
_________________
I've done everything except contact the producers of the show to find out who it is. I can't. It is very possible that it's some studio musician in L.A. that does TV and movie stuff.

I just don't know.

Gary
I'm a bit of a freak for House, M.D.

Long story.

Anyway, here's a page of resources comprising websites about every aspect of the show. Music is midway down. Tunefind.com is the site I have used to learn about the striking pop music used in the show, in particular the theme, a remix of Massive Attack's "Teardrop".

Interestingly, several episodes are based on musicians. In the episode you cite, the only music credit given is Louis Armstrong playing "What A Wonderful World", which you would certainly recognize.

You note that he 'actually plays an LP'; did you notice that a turntable mfr is in the product list at the end of the program?

Here's my question. While I know that Hugh Laurie is fully capable of playing any keyboard part which he is shown doing, it is sometimes clear that what we are hearing is a sampled or effected piano. But does anyone know if Mr Laurie actually plays the guitar? Dr House is often portrayed playing a Flying V, Les Paul, Strat, or other vintage honey--but only rarely through an amp, even though we hear distorted guitar lines.

R.
If the dude that writes it comes back to town maybe I could find out. He was born here and went to the University the same years as my wife. I met his brother when there was a fire in the cedar hut back of the synogogue, one of my most bizzare arson cases ever.
Thanks, guys. That's far more info than I received on the two trumpet forums I frequent. Nobody there knew anything, and collectively we normally know all things trumpet.

Ryszard, that's a formidable list of House-related resources. I had stumbled onto similar sites through Google, but none of them give the credit for this music clip, only Louis Armstrong at the end. I love Louis Armstrong, but this music isn't him.

Gary, are you saying you previously noticed this particular music and enjoyed it? I'm not surprised. I know several guys in L.A. alone who this could be.
You very well could be looking for a keyboardist, Matt.

Because I hear no lip correction on certain key notes that a three-valve trumpet would *have* to do. It is dead on tempered scale, I think this quite easily could be modern modeled-plus-sampled stuff.

There are other clues in there, as well, for example, the key sig of the first example you give -- falls under the fingers on a keyboard and are really licks that gospel/soul keyboardists know and play all the time.

It is very clean. Too clean.

And the vibrato is always at the same rate.

But unless they manipulated the thing using something like Autotune, I have yet to hear *any* trumpet player able to nail every note to the Tempered Scale like that without leaving the clues that only trumpet players with well trained ears know to listen for.


--Mac
That's a great suggestion, Mac. The playing is extraordinarily good. Could be too good. And pretty high for a harmon to sound that good.

Ironic, isn't it, if the music in the show about a fictitious trumpet player is fictitious trumpet playing.

FYI, I actually don't care about the trumpet playing. I just want to learn the song in the second clip.

ps an Emmy nod should go to the sound guy for bringing in the elevator door opening sound on key and on the beat at the end of the 2nd clip
Mac,
I had that nagging thought too, in the back of my head. Not that *I* would *hear* what you hear, but that so many shows are actually using sampled libraries for an 'on the cheap' studio production.

If that were the case then I would point you to one Mr. Cody Westheimer as a possible culprit.

There was an uncredited appearance by 'Brand New' singer/guitarist Jesse Lacey as the guitarist in the band.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNR_(House)

And yes, Matt, I truly enjoyed the music of that. I didn't not see the show, but listening to the clips, it's good stuff. I'd like to hear more of it, too.

Gary
Quote:

That's a great suggestion, Mac. The playing is extraordinarily good. Could be too good. And pretty high for a harmon to sound that good.

Ironic, isn't it, if the music in the show about a fictitious trumpet player is fictitious trumpet playing.

FYI, I actually don't care about the trumpet playing. I just want to learn the song in the second clip.

ps an Emmy nod should go to the sound guy for bringing in the elevator door opening sound on key and on the beat at the end of the 2nd clip




One of the reasons I'm hooked on the show is the extraordinary music direction and composition.

Naturally, the first thing you notice on watching is House's smartass rebelliousness, along with his obsession for excellence in medicine--at any cost. But after watching a couple of seasons' worth, more and more often I find myself in tears at the end of a show as some expertly-chosen song plays which recapitulates the emotion of some character or situation--often House's loneliness.

I suspect that little of the music which appears to be being played on screen is, in fact. It's acoustics which gives it away for me. It wouldn't have occurred to me to listen for what Mac is hearing, but it fits with the rest.

The music cues are subtle but so right on. No "Miami Vice" in-your-face stuff here. But watch an episode a couple of times so you don't have to pay attention to the story, and just listen to the music. Co-composers Jason Derlatka & Jon Ehrlich, who seem to always work as a pair, are way up on my list of musicians to pay attention to, at least for what I'm doing.

Ryszard
If you guys are correct, there may not even be a whole song to learn. This could have been written just for the scene. I've done some of that work myself, for radio and TV commercials. It's harder to write a non-song than it is a song! What I mean by that is, "write music to fill 27 seconds, and it has to move from this mood to that mood at the 19 second mark" - stuff like that. It's tough to not finish a song.

I'm still hoping that this is someone's real CD that has been picked up by a sound library service, and someone else will recognize the artist.

Of course, I could just start with what is there, and write the song myself, as it might have been.
I saw a replay of that and also enjoyed it. I just took the trumpet performance as a stab at a "Miles" vibe. Exchanging the horn at the end was quite the gesture of generous appreciation....
FWIW, ALL MIDI patches of Harmon mute trumpet are aimed at the "Miles vibe".

For one thing, every one of 'em is Harmon mute with the "wha" tuning tube and cup removed, something that Miles exploited...

I used to think the whole thing was rather funny, Miles stopped using it almost entirely for a while yet everyone else beat it into the ground. Twice.


--Mac
True. The vibrato is pretty fast for Miles, though.

By the way, I already transcribed the song excerpt. It's nice.
Quote:

I'm still hoping that this is someone's real CD that has been picked up by a sound library service, and someone else will recognize the artist.


Matt, this iPhone app could help in theory. I've never seen it used, only heard about it. I guess it implies there's a database on a server somewhere that contains all recorded music, searchable by any digital fragment. Not the tag info from the track, mind you, but an actual sample fragment. (Can this be!?)

Sure would like to know if there's access to such a utility from my PC I notice when I ask iTunes to look up CD track info, it sometimes gives a choice of two or three different albums from which to display the data. I've wondered if this means it's submitting not the tag data, but actual samples (and hence finding several albums containing the same tracks). Anyone know how that works?

-Ron

EDIT - Just found this. As usual, shoulda googled first.
Thanks, Ron. I had heard about that. I'll send it to my son who has an iPhone. Good suggestion!

[EDIT: saw your edit. Thanks again.]
We tried using Listen on an iPhone. The song it found was techno. No resemblance whatsoever to this music. Very peculiar.
Hi, Matt -

It must not be a song that Steve Jobs listens to...

House

1. My wifes fav show

2. I was shocked Hugh had an accent

3. He always finds a cure

Sorry I couldn't help on the music part.

Trax
The song is called Harmon Jazz (composed by Jon Ehrlich and Michael Wayne Jones). You can play or download it here: http://www.jecomusic.com/libraries/source/search_browse.php
Wow. Blast from the past. Thank you!

I took those audio snippets down a few years ago, so you must really know the inside scoop here. Welcome to the forum.

Yes, that is definitely the first song. I wonder if the same folks did the second song in the show as well? Very likely. I was hoping this was from a music library as I suspected.

Again, thank you so much!
Hi, glad I could help. I just watched that episode of House, and I remembered that it drove me up the wall not being able to find the whole thing. So gave it a try and voila It`s a beautiful piece. I remember, a few years ago, i actually thought, it was Botti

P.s. Smoked glass, same library.
Smoked Glass is very pretty! That's not the tune, though. I'll post a snippet again.
I can't find the recording of the tune now, but I had transcribed it and here is a short snippet done in BIAB. It is rough but should be enough to recognize the real thing for anyone who knows it.

http://www.mattfinley.com/promos/johnhenrygiles.mp3

By the way, several of the songs in that library (which sound great) are the same song performed at different tempos. Aperitif and Smoked Glass, for example.
Here's what I thought was weird: House has been on since 1995? Now I feel old!
Good point, Scott. 2005 is more like it. As you saw, it's many years since my original post,and I have no idea where Google would have gotten the data on that episode when I looked it up. But they can't put anything on the Internet that isn't true, right?
© PG Music Forums