PG Music Home
Posted By: Will Josef There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/03/19 09:12 PM
I found this new style in the 2019-version: _Doomed and wanted to try it out. Was intrigued by the Cello meet heavy rock. It's a bit like the beauty meet the beast...

There Is A Cello In My Soup

I included a soloist too from RT3232.

Will
Posted By: Deej56 Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 03:51 AM
Will,

The cello slays . . . pretty listen throughout. The opening didn’t quite kill for me. The drum really overpowered the bass, which should’ve shined a bit more, IMHO. But it was all fine listening from there . . . and then some! Good stuff!

All the best,

Deej
Posted By: Jim Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 06:52 AM
I told already but I'll repeat it...
Nice composition!
Posted By: Scott C Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 10:55 AM
Got a chuckle out of name out of the song. I really liked this song. Guitar was very cool. Very nice listen. Well done
Posted By: rsdean Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 11:53 AM
Will,

Cool title and very nicely done!

Bob
Posted By: Deryk - PG Music Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 01:03 PM
Wow - this is really refreshing, and an interesting tune in general, let alone the showcase here. The title did make me smile - but the song itself is no joke! I would have never thought to combine elements of these types of music. But it works flawlessly here.

Thanks for sharing smile
Posted By: 44kfl Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 01:05 PM
I like the overall sound

maybe the drums are a little overpowering in the beginning

but I like them

this is a cool song

enjoyed,

Kenny
Posted By: furry Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 04:08 PM
Really unusual. Awesome listening though and really enjoyable
Posted By: floyd jane Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 08:10 PM
Cool one, Will.

The Metal RTs are under utilized (here on the forum, at least) so it is nice to hear someone using them...

Good mix. (I like loud drums smile )

fj
Posted By: Ezekiel's Storm Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 08:18 PM
Love the title! This is delightfully unique. There is nothing better than a head-banging cello solo.
Posted By: Rustyspoon# Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 08:34 PM
Will,

Is this a darker side of Vanessa Mae?
Unusual and interesting composition. Love the title. Guitar is super!

Thanks,
Misha.
Posted By: gruverider Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 08:48 PM
Inspiring!
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 09:19 PM
Originally Posted By: Deej56
Will,

The cello slays . . . pretty listen throughout. The opening didn’t quite kill for me. The drum really overpowered the bass, which should’ve shined a bit more, IMHO. But it was all fine listening from there . . . and then some! Good stuff!

All the best,

Deej



Originally Posted By: 44kfl
I like the overall sound

maybe the drums are a little overpowering in the beginning

but I like them

this is a cool song

enjoyed,

Kenny



Hi Deej and Kenny,

I thank you both for listening. You might have a point about the drums - I will consider a remix if I ever become a pro-member of Soundcloud (cannot replace songs in the moment as a non-paying member).

I appreciate that you both took time to listen and commenting!
Will
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 09:22 PM
Originally Posted By: floyd jane
Cool one, Will.

The Metal RTs are under utilized (here on the forum, at least) so it is nice to hear someone using them...

Good mix. (I like loud drums smile )

fj


Thank you, Floyd!

Haha.. and now I am confused about those drums... are they too loud or not?

Thank you for listening!
Will
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 09:25 PM
Originally Posted By: Deryk - PG Music
Wow - this is really refreshing, and an interesting tune in general, let alone the showcase here. The title did make me smile - but the song itself is no joke! I would have never thought to combine elements of these types of music. But it works flawlessly here.

Thanks for sharing smile


Hi Deryk,

I appreciate that you took time to listen and thanks for the nice comments.

It is actually you - the good people from PGMusic - who got the idea to combine these types of music through your making of the style _Doomed. I just utilized your idea. smile

Will
Posted By: Ember - PG Music Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/04/19 10:15 PM
Okay, the title really gave me a good chuckle. Thanks for sharing!
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/05/19 03:20 PM
- Fun title

- Cool arrangement with a super RT/RD choice

- Great mix

- A LOT to like! And we did.


J&B
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/05/19 09:48 PM
Originally Posted By: Jim
I told already but I'll repeat it...
Nice composition!


Originally Posted By: Scott C
Got a chuckle out of name out of the song. I really liked this song. Guitar was very cool. Very nice listen. Well done


Jim & Scott, Thank you so much for listening! Appreciate it!

Will
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/05/19 09:51 PM
Originally Posted By: Ezekiel's Storm
Love the title! This is delightfully unique. There is nothing better than a head-banging cello solo.



Originally Posted By: Rustyspoon#
Will,

Is this a darker side of Vanessa Mae?
Unusual and interesting composition. Love the title. Guitar is super!

Thanks,
Misha.


Ezekiel & Misha,

As always I appreciate that you took time to listen and write such nice comments!

Will
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/05/19 09:54 PM
Originally Posted By: Janice & Bud
- Fun title

- Cool arrangement with a super RT/RD choice

- Great mix

- A LOT to like! And we did.


J&B



Dear Janice & Bud,

I am really happy that you liked the track and your nice comment is - as always - making me blush.

Thanks for listening!
Will
Posted By: rayc Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/06/19 06:07 AM
Interesting arrangement.
personally I'd like MORE kick drum - particularly in the intro (which is a bit long and lacks something to focus on - like a cello - to be honest).
The rhythm guitars are a bit fizz given the rounder sounds of everything else including the solo guitars.
Cool stuff notwithstanding my minor quibbles.
Posted By: Crossroads Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/06/19 03:01 PM
Hi Will,

smile smile smile smile SOOOOO GOOD !!!! You must be on vacation, Will, because you're coming up with great and very original, witty and most surprising stuff almost on a weekly basis.

This one is funny, but also musically great - the exact opposite of boring!

And the title alone deserves 5 stars.

I can only repeat: I like what you're doing !!!

All the best,

Stefan
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/06/19 08:35 PM
Originally Posted By: rayc
Interesting arrangement.
personally I'd like MORE kick drum - particularly in the intro (which is a bit long and lacks something to focus on - like a cello - to be honest).
The rhythm guitars are a bit fizz given the rounder sounds of everything else including the solo guitars.
Cool stuff notwithstanding my minor quibbles.


Thanks a lot for listening, rayc!

It's very good, constructive and useful critique and it is all things I will take into consideration if I ever make a new mix of this track.

I appreciate that you took the time to listen and comment!

Will
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/06/19 08:40 PM
Originally Posted By: Crossroads
Hi Will,

smile smile smile smile SOOOOO GOOD !!!! You must be on vacation, Will, because you're coming up with great and very original, witty and most surprising stuff almost on a weekly basis.

This one is funny, but also musically great - the exact opposite of boring!

And the title alone deserves 5 stars.

I can only repeat: I like what you're doing !!!

All the best,

Stefan


Hi Stefan,

Oh, how I wish I was on a vacation now, but I'm actually as busy as ever at my work. I just find making music to be a nice way of relaxing when I have a little spare time.

I signed up for this FAWM-thing that I read about on this forum, but there is no way I will manage to create 14 songs in February... just way too busy at work.

Thanks for listening and your nice comments!
Will
Posted By: Sundance Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/08/19 11:57 PM
Cool title and track Will.
Posted By: animarorecords Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/10/19 04:29 AM
Will,

It is a very nice idea.
I think that cello and rock band are rarely played together like this tune as actual performance, but it surely will attract the audience if it is realized.
Enjoyed my listen a lot.

Best regards.

Shigeki Adachi
Posted By: Torrey Bliss Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/10/19 04:55 PM
Will, it's an odd combination that works wonderfully together! You are contributing some very good stuff to the forum! Thanks, Torrey
Posted By: Noel96 Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/11/19 07:45 AM
Will,

First off I have to say that I really love this title!

You have a flair for bringing together some pretty amazing sounds from diverse genres and making them work. That's a skill I admire a lot!

This is really, really well done.

All the best,
Noel
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/11/19 09:30 PM
Originally Posted By: Sundance
Cool title and track Will.


Thanks a lot! I appreciate that you took the time to listen to it.
Will
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/11/19 09:32 PM
Originally Posted By: animarorecords
Will,

It is a very nice idea.
I think that cello and rock band are rarely played together like this tune as actual performance, but it surely will attract the audience if it is realized.
Enjoyed my listen a lot.

Best regards.

Shigeki Adachi


Yeah, I would vote for more cellos or other string instruments at rock concerts. Diversity is great!

Thank you so much for listening and commenting!
Will
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/11/19 09:33 PM
Originally Posted By: Torrey Bliss
Will, it's an odd combination that works wonderfully together! You are contributing some very good stuff to the forum! Thanks, Torrey


Thank you for your kind words, Torrey. Much appreciated!
Will
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/11/19 09:39 PM
Originally Posted By: Noel96
Will,

First off I have to say that I really love this title!

You have a flair for bringing together some pretty amazing sounds from diverse genres and making them work. That's a skill I admire a lot!

This is really, really well done.

All the best,
Noel


Hi Noel,

Like Shigeki mentioned, it is seldom that we hear a cello in a rock band... as seldom as finding a cello in your soup. smile

Thank you for listening. As always I feel blessed when experienced musicians like you
- and all the other good people here - take time to listen and comment.

Will
Posted By: dani48 Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/13/19 09:13 AM
Hi, Will !:))


I must say that this is mighty
- really truly mighty music that
could go into a movie also !!:))
Very nice Will !


Cheers
Dani
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/14/19 08:43 PM
Originally Posted By: dani48
Hi, Will !:))


I must say that this is mighty
- really truly mighty music that
could go into a movie also !!:))
Very nice Will !


Cheers
Dani


Thank you so much for your nice comment, Dani! Much appreciated!
Will
Posted By: PeterF Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/14/19 10:16 PM
Like those before me I enjoyed this piece nice interesting blend of sounds & styles.

Peter
Posted By: Will Josef Re: There Is A Cello In My Soup - 02/14/19 10:25 PM
Thank you Peter, much appreciated!

Will
© PG Music Forums