PG Music Home
Posted By: edshaw I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/02/21 11:37 AM
I Surrender All (Van DerVent and Weeden, 1865)

Hoping to keep a rotation of PD Classics and Original Old Tyme.
One of my favorites in Dmaj.
Posted By: floyd jane Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/02/21 01:41 PM
Ed,

"Authentic" is always the word that comes to mind when listening to you recordings...

fj
Posted By: edshaw Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/03/21 03:53 PM
Thanks, fj. Hope I am over the target.
Posted By: MarioD Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/03/21 05:02 PM
This sounds really good to me Ed. Good vocal and mix.
Excellent job on this one.
Posted By: edshaw Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/03/21 08:11 PM
Floyd and Mario: Many Thanks for listening and commenting.
Posted By: Guitarhacker Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/03/21 09:16 PM
That is back road, country church, on Sunday Morning, authentic. The recording is clean and nicely done.
Posted By: edshaw Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/10/21 05:56 AM
Thanks, Herb. This hymn is receiving a lot of attention today in those very venues. Thanks for listening and commenting.
Posted By: BabuMusic Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/10/21 09:09 AM
Well done, Ed. Greet choices on instruments for the perfect bed for your voice.
Posted By: TuneMonger Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/10/21 12:37 PM
Beautiful, this was a favorite of mine as a child. Great voc, great tune.
Posted By: Robertkc Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/10/21 01:06 PM
Ed,
Another tender, genuine performance of a lovely hymn.


Robert
Posted By: David Snyder Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/10/21 10:39 PM

Ed,

Sounds great man.

Hey I saw the dope comment from the promoter who wants you to submit this to the Hip Hop street battle mash-up.

You should man.

That would be fly!

smile
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/11/21 05:09 PM
Well done...remember that one from growing up attending small rural churches.

J&B
Posted By: dcuny Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/12/21 01:19 AM
Coming from different religious tradition, most of these hymns are new to me.

So it's especially nice to hear these for the first time like this - in the "Original Old Tyme" style.

Nicely done! smile
Posted By: bluage Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/12/21 02:44 AM
Hello, Mr. Shaw...

Listening to your spirtuals helps me slow-down the hectic pace of my thoughts, like a siesta for my soul. I believe a steady diet of this kind of song could work great changes in a person's heart. I wouldn't miss your posts for anything in the world.
Posted By: edshaw Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/12/21 08:21 AM
Boxers: My gratitude for the kind and encouraging words. In so many ways, this has been a group project smile
Posted By: edshaw Re: I Surrender All (PD Hymnal) - 05/13/21 11:33 AM
Hey, David. You really think I might bring some calm to the Hip-Hop street battle mashup? Well, worth a try, perhaps.
I notice there are several threads out there talking about promotion services, which, we understand, are in nearly all musician and writer posting sites, such as Spotify, etc. The general idea seems to be to warn people not to get taken advantage of; but, it is one of those elusive subjects. I have heard with the right connections producers can get any You Tube video to go viral. Bots, I assume.
© PG Music Forums