PG Music Home
Posted By: Robertkc Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/05/22 02:19 PM

A song from my folky-mystical side which Scott agreed to embellish with his delicate guitar talents.

Which Dream


Which Dream

which dream
which dream will you choose

the dream of immortality
losing youth in vanity`s
lake of mirrors
hungry eyes of children look
flipping pages of your book
for an ending clear

waking you`ll know what to do
the mystery
is dreaming you

which house
which house will you build
the heart house shuttered up by fear
pictures whisper when you draw near
leave the door ajar
travelling by compass yearning
raising arches ever learning
where to hang your star

arriving you`ll know what to do
the mystery
is expecting you

which song
which song will you sing

the song played on a cheap guitar
ageing fingers cannot barre
the moon to impress
a voice with no boast or lament
your bones become the instrument
angels bless

beginning you`ll know what to do
the mystery
sings through you

which dream
which dream will you choose

© Robert Cordrey Oct. 2021





Style is _FUNDY.STY (Fundy Songwriter Quartet)

RealTracks in style: 1255:Bass, Electric, PopShiningA-B Ev 120
RealTracks in style: 1264:Piano, Acoustic, Rhythm PopShiningA-B Ev 120
RealTracks in song: 405:Guitar, Acoustic, Strumming Ev 120
RealTracks in song: 1681:Guitar, 12-String Acoustic, Fingerpicking Ev 120
RealTracks in song: 2510:Viola, Background PopEven Ev 120 (1TrackStringQuartet)
RealTracks in song: 3554:Multi[Thickened=5] String Quartet, Rhythm PopHall Ev 085
Posted By: firesong Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/05/22 02:52 PM
Robert...very interesting and enjoyable...first off I think your vocals and harmonies were excellent...secondly I love the track...an acoustic dream if I might say so...I was reminded of Neil Young for some reason and with your harmonies maybe some Crosby, Stills and Nash along at times...you can never go wrong with Scott playing in the track...he is top of the food chain as a guitarist...I really enjoyed this...thanks for posting it...Dan
Posted By: PeterF Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/05/22 09:06 PM
Robert

A lovely mystical folk song. Excellent vocals and harmony in a suitable folky backing with some nice guitar from Scott.
Could imagine Donovan covering this in the 60's.

Nice work.

Peter
Posted By: RnAM Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/05/22 10:39 PM
Very original composition! Indeed mystical, but also slightly dark, like only you can do.

Your songs are always special, this is no exception. In this case, the Roy Orbison timbre is more audible than ever.

Rob
Posted By: vicarn Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/06/22 04:33 AM
Lyrics are really interesting, Robert.
Good one.

Vic
Posted By: PROJECT M Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/06/22 06:42 AM
Hi Robert and Scott
Absolutely interesting song
Really cool melody
Very nice sung
And Scott plays once again excellent guitar
I liked it very much
Many greetings
Andi ;-)
Posted By: BabuMusic Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/06/22 10:06 AM
Robert, your lyrics are always so engaging. You write in a wonderful way of bringing out the imagery. Vocals are so good. Intricate and precise, interweaving and supporting. Scott, your guitar work is always so complimentary to the style. So well done guys.
Posted By: Dewey_MI Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/06/22 11:02 AM
Really intriguing gents! Love the feel, very soothing to be sure. Have you considered lifting the melody in the shorter sections of the lyrics?
Posted By: jannesan Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/06/22 02:15 PM
I really enjoyed the lyrics, mysteries of life in a nutshell, keeping positive dream. Those images are really strong, my favorites: "the dream of immortality/losing youth in vanity`s", "your bones become the instrument/angels bless".
Harmonies are excellent, creating haunting feeling when voices are speaking around, sounds of gospel and African style, amazing work.
Creative use of BIAB instruments even without drums, beautifully flowing mood sits perfectly, that viola together with Scott's light guitar playing make this sound very original and extra-ordinary.

Janne
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/06/22 07:46 PM
Originally Posted By: firesong
Robert...very interesting and enjoyable...first off I think your vocals and harmonies were excellent...secondly I love the track...an acoustic dream if I might say so...I was reminded of Neil Young for some reason and with your harmonies maybe some Crosby, Stills and Nash along at times...you can never go wrong with Scott playing in the track...he is top of the food chain as a guitarist...I really enjoyed this...thanks for posting it...Dan


That`s very kind,Dan. I know my harmonies don`t attain the perfection of CSN&Y, but I`m glad this reminded you of them.


Originally Posted By: PeterF
Robert

A lovely mystical folk song. Excellent vocals and harmony in a suitable folky backing with some nice guitar from Scott.
Could imagine Donovan covering this in the 60's.

Nice work.

Peter


Thank you Peter!

Originally Posted By: RnAM
Very original composition! Indeed mystical, but also slightly dark, like only you can do.

Your songs are always special, this is no exception. In this case, the Roy Orbison timbre is more audible than ever.

Rob


Rob,
I like to think the flowerpowerish feel of this is tempered by that darker side you noticed.
Thanks very much for your listen and comments!

Originally Posted By: vicarn
Lyrics are really interesting, Robert.
Good one.

Vic


Thank you, Vic!

Originally Posted By: PROJECT M
Hi Robert and Scott
Absolutely interesting song
Really cool melody
Very nice sung
And Scott plays once again excellent guitar
I liked it very much
Many greetings
Andi ;-)


Andi,
I`m glad you found the song interesting and heard Scott`s contribution.
Initially this was written with the idea of just the strings to embellish - I think Scott came up with some lovely delicate playing that fits the mood.
Thank you for commenting.


Robert
Posted By: MarioD Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/06/22 09:22 PM
Robert, the first singer that came to mind was Art Garfunkel. He could have sung this one.

The lyrics are magical, brilliant write.
Super vocal, backing tracks, and mix.

Loved it.
Posted By: Al-David Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/07/22 03:07 AM
Hi Robert & Scott


Mario said it pretty darn good. His Art Garfunkle suggestion is spot on. Your lyrics always paint such wonderful mindscapes. And Scott casn make just about any song better.

Very nice! And it's great to hear another one from you.

Alan
Posted By: floyd jane Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/07/22 12:27 PM
Robert,

"the song played on a cheap guitar
ageing fingers cannot barre
the moon to impress
a voice with no boast or lament
your bones become the instrument
angels bless"

You have such a unique and interesting poetic lyric style.
They transport the listener to magical and mystic places.
AND make one think.

Cool vocals and harmonies.
Cool BAND.

Scott's guitar is the perfect compliment (as always).

Much enjoyed.

fj
Posted By: B.D.Thomas Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/07/22 05:11 PM
For whatever reason I see a Disney movie when I listen to the song, would be a prefect film music in my opinion. You create images...

And I dig your harmonies, really good vocals!
Posted By: Bass Thumper Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/07/22 05:30 PM
Robert, you are a poet indeed.
Great job !

"leave the door ajar
travelling by compass yearning
raising arches ever learning
where to hang your star"
Posted By: Scott C Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/07/22 10:09 PM
Thanks for checking the song. I was so glad to be able to play on one of Roberts folk songs. Really glad you like it....
Posted By: David Snyder Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/08/22 09:50 AM

Really beautiful Robert. Classic dreamy folk with your own unique mystical twist.

Loved it!
Posted By: musician17 Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/08/22 12:37 PM
Oh my word. This is incredible. You are by far one of the very best songwriters on here. It really is an honour to hear your songs, thank you so much for sharing.

Lyrics, harmonies ... everything. Your gift for communication is incredible, and defies analysis and analytical description. The lyrics, for me, are so special here, that said. Some of your lyrics, at times, are a little inscrutable - at least for the likes of me ... I'd like to think that I understood the ones in this song, though.

Just as a "sample":

"the song played on a cheap guitar
ageing fingers cannot barre
the moon to impress
a voice with no boast or lament
your bones become the instrument
angels bless

beginning you`ll know what to do
the mystery
sings through you" ...

WOW.

I'd love to think that the mystery is indeed dreaming me. I hope so, anyway.

Thank you for your extraordinary sensitivity of the soul, and for sharing these inspired songs with us.
Posted By: Janice & Bud Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/08/22 05:52 PM
“the mystery
sings through you”

Yes!

A lovely folk song with mystical harmonies that gave us images of scenes from A Midsummer Night’s Dream.

Scott’s dreamy playing was a great addition to the delicate fingerpicked guitar and the viola.

Dream some more!

J&B
Posted By: Robertkc Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/09/22 10:11 PM
Marti, Dewey, Janne, Mario, Al, Floyd, B.D. Thomas, Bass Thumper, David, James, Janice & Bud:
Thanks to you all for your listens and very interesting and supportive comments!

Robert
Posted By: Torrey Bliss Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/10/22 12:17 PM
Robert,

Wow what a fabulous use of those RealTracks! You melded together such a unique sounding backing! Love those complex (at least to me they are) lyrics. You always excel in that department! Love the vocals and backround vox. Nice touches added by Scott!

Thanks, Torrey
Posted By: rsdean Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/10/22 12:59 PM
Robert / Scott,

Another great collaboration. These songs have a special feel and vibe - done with care and some really fine performances.

Loved it!

Bob
Posted By: Scott C Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/17/22 10:48 PM
Thanks again everyone for the awesome comments. They are very much appreciated.
Posted By: Ezekiel's Storm Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/18/22 08:35 PM
Engaging piece. Original overall sound. Sort of a bit of psychedelic folk sound.

Love the harmonies. Very cool to listen to.
Posted By: Rustyspoon# Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/18/22 09:47 PM
Robert & Scott
Beautiful tune! Amazing harmonies & very melodic. Very unusual soundscape. Enjoyed it and thank you for sharing.

Misha.

P.S. Robert, I think vocal recording is one of your best.
Posted By: TuneMonger Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/20/22 04:07 PM
Amazing lyrics delivered by that hypnotic, quavery voice I notice someone here compared to Roy Orbison.

The line about bones and angels stood out to me as brilliant, but there are many good lines in this one.

Hard to believe, sometimes, the talent that is working on this forum.
Posted By: Scott C Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/20/22 10:17 PM
Thanks again for checking out the song. Your comments are very much appreciated. Glad you liked it..
Posted By: BlueAttitude Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/21/22 08:23 AM
Nice to see Spirit Level with a new one!

Excellent lyrics as always, and a great vocal, especially liked the harmonies.

Also nice hearing Scott in there, he always seems to find the perfect part to play.

Good one, guys.
Posted By: Derochette Re: Which Dream ( with ScottC) - 08/21/22 04:24 PM
Hi Robertkc,

Nice and original intro. Quite gently, with a very pleasant melody. Well done.

Kindly regard
Derochette
alias JaniJackFlash
© PG Music Forums