You need to be logged in to post
Options
Index
#254800 - 06/26/14 02:39 PM [User Showcase] " Help Me"
Registered: 02/24/11
Posts: 81
Jeff S Offline
Enthusiast

Registered: 02/24/11
Posts: 81
This is a preliminary mix with a rough vocal track. I recorded the vocals in an open room with very little treatment and it shows. Anyways I'm posting this as a work in progress. I used all BIAB real tracks including the guitar soloist that was custom edited. Let me know what you think.

http://soundcloud.com/jsting1/help-me


Top
#254807 - 06/26/14 04:24 PM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 12/21/13
Posts: 6233
Loc: Davis, CA
Greg Johnson Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/21/13
Posts: 6233
Loc: Davis, CA
Very well conceived and arranged!! I think the track works great as a whole. Guitar, arrangement, composition really flow naturally. I would experiment with different fx and maybe eq on the vocal (maybe a bit more of an intimate sound-it's a bit metallic sounding). Great job!! Take care. Greg

Top
#254817 - 06/26/14 07:02 PM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 12/12/11
Posts: 3145
Loc: York, England
ROG Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/12/11
Posts: 3145
Loc: York, England
Hi Jeff.

A nice track with some interesting changes in texture in the backing.

Lots of potential here, once you get the vocal sound right - as you say, it's suffering a bit from the open room acoustics. The only other thing I might point out is that I found some of the snare drum breaks a little intrusive and maybe a bit of compression on the drum track might help that.

As Greg says, generally the track works great as a whole and I'd be interested to hear a final version of the mix.

ROG.

Top
#254852 - 06/27/14 08:31 AM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 04/07/13
Posts: 6216
Loc: South Carolina
Charlie Fogle Offline
Veteran

Registered: 04/07/13
Posts: 6216
Loc: South Carolina
I agree with the other posters and think your song has a lot of potential. Good first draft and I look forward to hearing the final version.

For some reason, I had to cut/paste the Soundcloud link to start the song.

Charlie
_________________________
BIAB Ultra Pak+ 2021:RB 2021, Latest builds: Dell AIO; Windows-10-64 bit, AMD A9 Processor and 16 GB Ram Memory.

Top
#254855 - 06/27/14 09:09 AM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 7590
Guitarhacker Offline
Veteran

Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 7590
I kinda actually like the sound of the vocals.... you can hear the small room ambiance in them.

Not a bad song, but it can use some work. Since you posted this as a WIP rough draft..... I will comment on something that caught my attention. This is from a writing perspective, not a recording perspective.

The use of the non-root bass throughout the song became a bit tedious to me. The non-root bass is a very useful and creative tool. I hear it used alot in CCM. Try to use it for tension but that tension needs to be released from time to time. At some point, and it should be fairly predictable, the bass needs to hit the root in the right places to release that tension and satisfy the ear. I don't recall that happening often enough.

Song structure is lacking. What I mean here is the verses don't lead into a chorus. At the end of the verses I was waiting and expecting it to go "to the next level" and it never did. There were 12+ measures of instrumental. I would have a look at writing a solid energetic chorus that follows the verses and ties the verses together with a nice hook. Later in the song, something like a chorus, more like a bridge showed up 2x. Perhaps take that and use it to write a chorus.


Overall song length was a bit too much.... close to 6 minutes....I know it's hard to say get to the meat of the issue and get it said and done in 3 to 3:30 minutes but cutting it down will make it much more interesting and force you to eliminate the unnecessary. Start by losing the long instrumental breaks. Let verse one go into a chorus or directly into V2. V2 should immediately go into the chorus if you haven't been there already. short instrumental turn around of 8 measures max then hit the chorus again or if needed, a V3 and CH to the end.

Of course this is all my opinion and you are free to totally disregard anything and everything I say as the ramblings of someone who "doesn't understand your creative process".....

If nothing else, shorten it to 4 minutes max and see what that does for the song.


Just my 2 cents.


Edited by Guitarhacker (06/27/14 09:11 AM)
_________________________
You can find my music at:
www.herbhartley.com

Add nothing that adds nothing to the music.


As the sword chooses the warrior, so too, the song chooses the writer.

Top
#254857 - 06/27/14 10:13 AM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 03/02/13
Posts: 4079
Loc: Helsinki, Finland
dani48 Offline
Veteran

Registered: 03/02/13
Posts: 4079
Loc: Helsinki, Finland

Hi, Jeff !:))


You have a very nice voice
although I´m not sure that
the key you are singing in
is the absolute best for your voice ?
In any case, following Herb´s and
others´advice will help you a lot !:))


Cheers
Dani

Top
#254866 - 06/27/14 11:02 AM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: ROG]
Registered: 12/05/11
Posts: 10177
Loc: GA USA
Janice & Bud Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/05/11
Posts: 10177
Loc: GA USA
Originally Posted By: ROG
Hi Jeff.

A nice track with some interesting changes in texture in the backing.

Lots of potential here, once you get the vocal sound right - as you say, it's suffering a bit from the open room acoustics. The only other thing I might point out is that I found some of the snare drum breaks a little intrusive and maybe a bit of compression on the drum track might help that.

As Greg says, generally the track works great as a whole and I'd be interested to hear a final version of the mix.

ROG.


Plus one here. I could not have better stated it. Keep it up!!
_________________________

J&B Soundcloud
J&B YouTube
J&B Website

Top
#254874 - 06/27/14 11:42 AM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 02/24/11
Posts: 81
Jeff S Offline
Enthusiast

Registered: 02/24/11
Posts: 81
Thanks for all the constructive criticism. It's a long song I know and something I have struggled with. All the suggestions are issues I encountered when writing and producing this piece.

The writing process was one that just fell together. It doesn't follow standard song structure I know and believe me I have tried going the less is more route with the instrumental breaks and contemplating adding a chorus as opposed to what seems like 2 bridges.

There is a natural tension in the song not just in the bass line and snare hits but in the structure itself. The instrumental breaks I think give a bit of relief but The song does seem unresolved but that was kinda of where I was at when I wrote it. It's a cry for help but before you get there you have to ride this anxiety and tension and in the end its unresolved because isn't that just the way life is.

Any ways I have many standard songs that follow predictable patterns so I'm happy with the structure of this one. I do think I should maybe dial the snare down with a volume envelope on those hard hits.I tried a few key changes early on when writing it and it just didn't feel right. Too far along now to reconsider that. I'm thinking about the bass line resolve but not sure yet where it would be beneficial in the song without losing the natural tension.

Again thank you for the feed back I really appreciate it. I take no offense to any of it as it helps me grow and understand. I have some other songs I will post up later which should give a good idea of the style I naturally write in and perhaps this one will benefit from that.

Top
#254877 - 06/27/14 12:03 PM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 04/20/10
Posts: 4858
Loc: Florida
90 dB Offline
Veteran

Registered: 04/20/10
Posts: 4858
Loc: Florida
Jeff,

I like this song. It's unique. Too long? Maybe that's how long it had to be. That's your call. Is “Hotel California” 'too long'? No; that's how long it needed to be.


“Song structure” is a bogus construct. This is a work of art, not a garage addition. Conforming to accepted song forms only leads to a boring sameness. Verse,verse, chorus, verse, bridge, chorus and end, ad nauseum. Rinse and repeat.

I think this is quite well done. I don't think you need anyone to tell you how to write.


Regards,

Bob

Top
#254884 - 06/27/14 12:49 PM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Charlie Fogle]
Registered: 06/22/12
Posts: 2873
Loc: Karlsruhe, Germany
boehm Offline
Veteran

Registered: 06/22/12
Posts: 2873
Loc: Karlsruhe, Germany
Hi Jeff,
Originally Posted By: c_fogle
I agree with the other posters and think your song has a lot of potential. Good first draft and I look forward to hearing the final version.


Thanks for sharing.

Guenter
_________________________
http://www.21d.de/
Latest Song: What You Desire

Top
#254967 - 06/28/14 09:13 PM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 02/11/05
Posts: 2646
Loc: Kentucky
PgFantastic Offline
Veteran

Registered: 02/11/05
Posts: 2646
Loc: Kentucky
Really like the guitar work on this one! Thanks for sharing!
_________________________
My Tunes

Psalm 57:7 My heart, O God, is steadfast, my heart is steadfast; I will sing and make music.

Top
#254994 - 06/29/14 09:09 AM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 08/10/12
Posts: 9156
Loc: Florida
floyd jane Offline
Veteran

Registered: 08/10/12
Posts: 9156
Loc: Florida
Jeff,

A lot of cool stuff happening in this. The guitars are nice. The mix is good. Keep 'em coming...

floyd

Top
#255059 - 06/29/14 11:56 PM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: floyd jane]
Registered: 02/24/11
Posts: 81
Jeff S Offline
Enthusiast

Registered: 02/24/11
Posts: 81
Thanks all for the kind comments.

Top
#255425 - 07/04/14 09:38 PM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 05/30/08
Posts: 4652
Sundance Offline
Veteran

Registered: 05/30/08
Posts: 4652
Hi Jeff,

If you'll put the whole url address to your song in your post then people who want to listen only have to click on it. Or you can click the little link button that make the link and have just your song title show. I thought you'd taken the link down until I realized I had to copy and paste it....

This reminded me of early 70's album rock. I think a different effect on the vocal might fit the style better.


Josie

Top
#255661 - 07/07/14 01:46 PM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Sundance]
Registered: 02/24/11
Posts: 81
Jeff S Offline
Enthusiast

Registered: 02/24/11
Posts: 81
Thanks Sundance. I will repost it with the full link when I get the vocals redone.

Top
#267546 - 11/06/14 11:45 PM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 10/07/14
Posts: 73
A-Z Offline
Enthusiast

Registered: 10/07/14
Posts: 73
Jeff
I like your track
smile
love the guitar
has great atmosphere
and the melody line catches my attention and kept me for the whole length

Atlantis
https://soundcloud.com/atlantisz
_________________________
Ä-nē-cha Dē
Feels Like Alice
www.soundcloud.com/feelslikealice

Top
#267566 - 11/07/14 07:23 AM [User Showcase] Re: " Help Me" [Re: Jeff S]
Registered: 10/25/08
Posts: 7947
Loc: Winston-Salem, NC
Pat Marr Offline
Veteran

Registered: 10/25/08
Posts: 7947
Loc: Winston-Salem, NC
Hi Jeff,

I was going to welcome you to the forum until I saw you've been here since 2011... but 25 posts in 3.5 years?? you must have a life or something! (unlike me) wink

I liked an awful lot about this song! In certain places it reminded me of Journey, a band I like quite a bit. I wish you had posted some information about the song, such as lyrics, real tracks used, parts you may have played etc.

I liked your explanation of why you created tension in the composition.. yes, that *IS* how life is. And I liked the message in the song.

I thought the suggestions being made were all very insightful (especially Herb's observation about non-root bass notes... that's something my mind has considered but never explored to that degree. Thanks , Herb. You've set some thoughts in motion...)

But although its customary in song writing forums to evaluate a song according the "rules", I tend to weigh in along the same lines as Bob (90dB).

Bottom line, I enjoyed the song quite a bit, and I look forward to hearing more from you.

Top


PG Music News
Band-in-a-Box® 2021 Spanish for Windows is Here!

En PG Music tenemos el placer de anunciar la disponibilidad de Band-in-a-Box 2021 en Español. Despues de arduo trabajo hemos agregado, entre otras cosas, 80 funciones nuevas y una gran colección de nuevas incorporaciones y contenido que incluyen 202 RealTracks, nuevos RealStyles, MIDI SuperTracks, Estudios Instrumentales, Interpretaciones de Artistas, RealDrums 'Single' adicionales, transcripciones de RealDrums, MultiStyles PAK 1, Xtra Styles PAK 10 ¡y mucho mas!

Nuevas características | Todos los Paquetes

New Update Available for Band-in-a-Box® 2021 for Windows!

Update your Band-in-a-Box® 2021 today!

We've applied some updates to a variety of Add-ons, improved transcriptions and simple tags, resolved playback issues with MIDI tracks, and more. Plus, this free update adds the latest DAW Plugin 3.46!

Learn more & download now.

Band-in-a-Box® 2021 Polish for Windows is Here!

Efektem naszej ciężkiej pracy w ostatnim czasie jest m.in. dodanie 80 nowych funkcji i wspaniałej kolekcji nowych dodatków i zawartości, które obejmują 202 RealTracks, nowe RealStyles, MIDI SuperTracks, Studia Instrumentalne, Wykonania Artystów, dodatkowe RealDrums "Pojedyncze ", transkrypcje RealDrums, pakiet MultiStyles PAK 1, Pakiet Xtra Styles PAK 10 i wiele innych!

Nowych | Pakiety

Band-in-a-Box® 2021 Dutch for Windows is Here!

We zijn bezig geweest en hebben 80 nieuwe functies toegevoegd en een verbazingwekkende collectie van nieuwe inhoud, inclusief 202 RealTracks, nieuwe RealStyles, MIDI SuperTracks, Instrumentale Studies, Artiest Uitvoeringen, Bonus RealDrums "Singles", RealDrums transcripties, MultiStyles PAK 1, Xtra Stijlen PAK 10 en meer!

Nieuwe Functies | Pakketten

Band-in-a-Box® 2021 Danish for Windows is Here!

Vi har haft travlt, og har tilføjet 80 nye funktioner og en fantastisk samling af nyt indhold, bl.a. 202 RealTracks, nye RealStyles, MIDI SuperTracks, Instrumental Studies, Artist Performances, bonus RealDrums "Singles," RealDrums transsriptioner, MultiStyles PAK 1, Xtra Styles PAK 10 og meget mere!

Hvan er Nyt | Pakker

Band-in-a-Box® 2021 for Windows Update Available!

The latest Band-in-a-Box® 2021 update for Windows enhances the JukeBox, adds a "Set all tracks to this:" option to the MIDI import dialog, improves chord sheet view during playback, and more!

Learn more & download this free update.

Read the patch announcement.

Band-in-a-Box® 2021 Swedish for Windows is Here!

Vi har varit flitiga och lagt till över 80 nya funktioner och en fantastisk samling av nytt innehåll, innefattande 202 RealTracks, nya RealStyles, MIDI SuperTracks, Instrumental Studies, Artist Performances, Bonus RealDrums "Singles," RealDrums transcriptions, MultiStyles PAK 1, Xtra Styles PAK 10, med mera!

Paket | Vad är nytt

Forum Stats
34266 Members
67 Forums
69149 Topics
593877 Posts

Max Online: 2537 @ 01/19/20 07:09 AM
Newest Members
Stiobard, mikeswell23, slotz, Rhume123, GoGirlGuitar

34265 Registered Users
Top Posters (30 Days)
VideoTrack 199
Matt Finley 161
Noel96 123
Pipeline 115
Janice & Bud 110
dcuny 103
Simon - PG Music 102
Jim Fogle 101
Guitarhacker 100
Rustyspoon# 98
Today's Birthdays
boomerballads, Hogman, Marius1976