Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
You need to be logged in to post
Options
Index
#538110 - 05/25/19 08:19 AM [Off-Topic] Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney
Registered: 06/08/05
Posts: 6864
Loc: Redondo Beach, Ca.
jazzmammal Offline
Veteran

Registered: 06/08/05
Posts: 6864
Loc: Redondo Beach, Ca.
This guy is an attorney, an Abelton Certified Trainer and a musician.



This should help answer some questions that pop up here frequently.

Bob
_________________________
Biab/RB latest build, Win 10 64 bit, Intel 4770, 256 Gig SSD, 16 Gigs Ram, Steinberg UR22 MkII, Roland Sonic Cell, Kurzweil PC3, Hammond SK1, Korg PA3XPro, Garritan JABB, Hypercanvas, Sampletank 3, more.

Top
#538151 - 05/25/19 01:42 PM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 12/27/03
Posts: 12118
Loc: Hamlin NY
MarioD Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/27/03
Posts: 12118
Loc: Hamlin NY
Excellent find Bob!

This video should be pinned at the top of the Showcase, the Beginners and Off Topic forums.


Edited by MarioD (05/25/19 01:44 PM)
_________________________
If you are sitting in public and a stranger takes the seat next to you just look straight ahead and say "did you bring the money"?

64 bit Win 10 Pro - the latest BiaB and RB - Roland Octa-Capture audio interface - a ton of software and some hardware.

Top
#538158 - 05/25/19 02:25 PM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 08/20/11
Posts: 5003
Loc: Winston-Salem, NC USA
Jim Fogle Online   happy
Veteran

Registered: 08/20/11
Posts: 5003
Loc: Winston-Salem, NC USA
Well now. That talk made the discussion clear as mud.

Seriously two thoughts came to mind:

When was the presentation given? Ableton published the video on March 19, 2019 so I'm slightly reassured the presentation is current.

Are either of the two cases mentioned in the presentation under appeal? The answer is not readily available so there is no way to know if the definition of infringement of US copyright law will be clarified.
_________________________
Jim Fogle
2019 BiaB (628) UltraPlusPak RB 2019 (Build 3)
Cakewalk by Bandlab - Audacity - Zoom MRS-8 recorder
i3 laptop, 64bit Win 7, 8 GB ram, 480GB SSD
Music at: http://fogle622.wix.com/fogle622-audio-home

Top
#538170 - 05/25/19 04:02 PM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 09/02/18
Posts: 747
Loc: Denmark
Will Josef Online   content
Journeyman

Registered: 09/02/18
Posts: 747
Loc: Denmark
"Clear as mud" as Jim wrote.

I recently heard a sample that you can buy on Splice. It's basically a guy humming/beat boxing the bass line from Rapper's Delight (Sugar Hill Gang), which is also the bass line in Good Times (Chic), which is also a bass line from an older more unknown soul record.

Imagine 10 different people buy that sample from Splice and use it unaltered on 10 different tracks that are all published on Spotify. Who will sue who?
It is hard to believe that a jury "consisting of ordinary people" would say it is fair use.

Edit: Oh, and I think attorneys love the "mud" with contradictory or unclear rulings, because that is how they get clients!

Will


Edited by Will Josef (05/25/19 04:11 PM)

Top
#538190 - 05/25/19 05:26 PM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 06/08/05
Posts: 6864
Loc: Redondo Beach, Ca.
jazzmammal Offline
Veteran

Registered: 06/08/05
Posts: 6864
Loc: Redondo Beach, Ca.
The second case he talked about is 2nd Circuit which means Appeals. I kinda follow the Thicke case and I haven't heard of it being appealed. I think I read they settled it out by paying several mil to Gaye's estate.

I thought he explained the "mud" element pretty clearly when he demonstrated what he did with Uptown Funk. He took samples from that recording and smushed them up so much as to be completely unrecognizable. My takeaway was that would probably be OK but the operative word is "probably". Attorneys' crystal balls are no clearer than anybody else's. If somebody sued somebody for mashing samples up so far as to be unrecognizable and you went to him to defend he would probably say there could be a decent defense here and quote you a fee. There are NEVER any guarantees when you go to court.

People need to read these actual cases based on the trial transcripts to really understand what went on. I'm a nerd with no life and actually do read some of that stuff...

The main thing is you can do anything you want and get away with it if your song never goes anywhere like online for example. Oh, you want to put it up on YouTube? Then be careful. If you're worried about it then don't sample or write or create a certain feel that sounds like a copy of something else. Just don't do it and this whole conversation is moot.

Bob
_________________________
Biab/RB latest build, Win 10 64 bit, Intel 4770, 256 Gig SSD, 16 Gigs Ram, Steinberg UR22 MkII, Roland Sonic Cell, Kurzweil PC3, Hammond SK1, Korg PA3XPro, Garritan JABB, Hypercanvas, Sampletank 3, more.

Top
#538213 - 05/25/19 07:39 PM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 10/09/16
Posts: 597
Loc: Central Ohio
edshaw Offline
Journeyman

Registered: 10/09/16
Posts: 597
Loc: Central Ohio
Rap and hip hop offer particular challenges.


Edited by edshaw (05/26/19 03:47 AM)
_________________________
Biab for WIN 2018
Win 10 64bit
Reaper
TASCAM Digital deck

Top
#538227 - 05/26/19 12:45 AM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 12/20/16
Posts: 567
Loc: Gold Coast, Queensland, Austra...
Teunis Offline
Journeyman

Registered: 12/20/16
Posts: 567
Loc: Gold Coast, Queensland, Austra...
Other than don’t copy or don’t sample other folks. Can anyone tell me what this guy actually said. I could not say I was in anyway enlightened (but then again American English is not my native tongue.)

Tony


Edited by Teunis (05/26/19 12:46 AM)
_________________________
HP i7-4770 16GB 512G SSD, Win 10 Home,
Roland Quad Capture, Launchkey 61, Maton CW80, Telecaster + more
BB 2019 (628) RB 2019 (3), CakeWalk by BandLab, Reaper, Audacity, Melodyne

Top
#538421 - 05/27/19 11:07 AM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 06/08/05
Posts: 6864
Loc: Redondo Beach, Ca.
jazzmammal Offline
Veteran

Registered: 06/08/05
Posts: 6864
Loc: Redondo Beach, Ca.
I can see it would be a bit tricky of you're not a native English speaker.

The first case was this: A famous group of producers freely admitted they loved a song done by Marvin Gaye and wrote a new song similar to it. It had different words and a different bass line but the overall feel and sound was very similar. When Gaye's family heard it they sued saying it was too close to what Marvin did and the court agreed it was copyright infringement. That was a big bomb dropped in the middle of the music biz because everybody thought the feel or rhythm or whatever was ok, it was specific musical licks or melodies they had to watch out for. I listened to both songs and yes they definitely have a certain ambience or overall feel in common even though the new one has different words. This case was not about specific samples it was about the feel of it.

His second point was where do you draw the line with copying samples? If you sample the bass line from Thriller and you can clearly hear it's the bass line from Thriller then forget it, you'll get sued. What he did was sample some parts of Uptown Funk but using Abelton Live he transformed the samples so much they had no resemblance at all to the original sound. He then posed the question, is this OK or not? His answer was "maybe".

These two cases have nothing specific to do with rap or hip hop, it concerns all music. He's talking about soundtracks from big movies like Star Wars or the Avengers, pop songs, classic country, whatever. And, he specifically said if you copy or sample something that is recognizable and release it you WILL get caught so don't even think about it. He even answered the question, how about just one bar? NO. How about just 2 beats? NO. If a third party listening to an original recording of yours can tell even one little thing was exactly the same as the original, you're screwed if the artist wants to sue. There is software now that can pick stuff like that up just like the software universities use to catch students trying to cheat on their term papers by plagiarizing books or other published papers.

Bob
_________________________
Biab/RB latest build, Win 10 64 bit, Intel 4770, 256 Gig SSD, 16 Gigs Ram, Steinberg UR22 MkII, Roland Sonic Cell, Kurzweil PC3, Hammond SK1, Korg PA3XPro, Garritan JABB, Hypercanvas, Sampletank 3, more.

Top
#538465 - 05/27/19 06:11 PM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 08/20/11
Posts: 5003
Loc: Winston-Salem, NC USA
Jim Fogle Online   happy
Veteran

Registered: 08/20/11
Posts: 5003
Loc: Winston-Salem, NC USA
Nice summary Bob!
_________________________
Jim Fogle
2019 BiaB (628) UltraPlusPak RB 2019 (Build 3)
Cakewalk by Bandlab - Audacity - Zoom MRS-8 recorder
i3 laptop, 64bit Win 7, 8 GB ram, 480GB SSD
Music at: http://fogle622.wix.com/fogle622-audio-home

Top
#538466 - 05/27/19 06:32 PM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: Jim Fogle]
Registered: 12/20/16
Posts: 567
Loc: Gold Coast, Queensland, Austra...
Teunis Offline
Journeyman

Registered: 12/20/16
Posts: 567
Loc: Gold Coast, Queensland, Austra...
Originally Posted By: Jim Fogle
Nice summary Bob!


I agree with Jim. Well put.

Tony
_________________________
HP i7-4770 16GB 512G SSD, Win 10 Home,
Roland Quad Capture, Launchkey 61, Maton CW80, Telecaster + more
BB 2019 (628) RB 2019 (3), CakeWalk by BandLab, Reaper, Audacity, Melodyne

Top
#538514 - 05/28/19 06:21 AM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 6378
Guitarhacker Offline
Veteran

Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 6378
Folks it's as simple as this....

If you have lawyers and money involved.... nothing is ever going to be simple and concise. They make their living in the shades of grey.

Write your song. Let the chips fall where they may. Don't intentionally use copyrighted material and you'll probably be ok..... most of the time.

If you do get served with a lawsuit.... get a good music lawyer and .......welcome to the grey side.
_________________________
You can find my music at:
www.herbhartley.com

Add nothing that adds nothing to the music

Top
#538517 - 05/28/19 06:36 AM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 08/21/18
Posts: 579
Tangmo Offline
Journeyman

Registered: 08/21/18
Posts: 579
Which was really the point of the talk, imo. He wasn't giving (much) specific legal advice. He was explaining the current (as of the date of the talk) state of the law. If the law (and the precedents set in the courts) are in flux, how is a concise answer even possible? His points about undermining the value of a copyright shouldn't be ignored either. If you've done no damage (you haven't usurped money or driven value from the original to your "homage") then a suit for damages is pointless. If you HAVE, then things are really slippery at the moment until settled more firmly. Beware.

It's also worth remembering that there are essentially two types of copyright pertaining to recorded music. Mechanical rights are about the actual recording. This is mostly what he demonstrated.

Publishing rights are about, essentially, what happens before a song is recorded to hard media (including computer hard-drives). Lyrics, melody, etc. This is mostly what he talked about in the Marvin Gaye scenario. They weren't accused of using even bits of the recording of that song, but copying one or more of the creative decisions made in the creation of the song. That's the "scary" one for music and musicians in general.

It's exceeding easy to NOT COPY recordings--not even a single lick or note. It's a more open question when "creative decisions" can be construed to infringe. Sometimes it's blatant and obvious. Other times it may be coincidental. And other times, it's just the nature of music that there are only so many choices available in progression or in intervals. As long as juries understand this, then I think they can be trusted to judge rightly.


Edited by Tangmo (05/28/19 07:10 AM)
_________________________
BIAB 2019 Audiophile. Windows 10. Former user of old version. Prefer creating while learning over learning before creating. Passable, intermediate level acoustic rhythm guitar player. Songwriter, lyricist, composer loving all styles.

Top
#538591 - 05/28/19 04:30 PM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 10/09/16
Posts: 597
Loc: Central Ohio
edshaw Offline
Journeyman

Registered: 10/09/16
Posts: 597
Loc: Central Ohio
I followed one of the references, the Estate of Marvin Gaye vs. Robin Thicke, who many here have probably heard of. A fairly routine copyright complaint suddenly takes a dystopian turn when the judge considers the idea that the song of the defendant had the same "feel" of the Marvin Gaye song.* This would be an outrage if it were not for the eerie pre-recognition of things possibly to come, as Google and Artificial Intelligence continue to team up to produce programs like China's "social credit system," which now has identified over three million "citizens of questionable social value," or thoughts. Not bad for a couple of years work.
It takes no loss of the senses to imagine a world in which Google uses Ai to compile a data base of "finger prints," in a manner of speaking, of every element of the audio universe, carefully tabulated and cross referenced to suggest possible duplication that could be used to gin up litigation on behalf of lawsuit happy children of the creator. Not a leap at all.
Add to this the fact that broad distribution makes it possible to claim a violation occurred in virtually any corner of the civilized world; meaning, with that much territory, plaintiffs are bound to find a sympathetic judge, somewhere.
Typically, we underestimated Silicon Valley. We have heard the plan is to use copyright law to shut down criticism of media content, de facto censorship, or that the purpose of the tech giant's buying up intellectual property en masse was to start a super library. Silicon Valley is always two steps ahead of us. It is in the water.
A good reference on this is UC Davis's Professor Darrell Hamamoto's "The Dark Side of Asian America." Darrell has the technocracy sussed.
Here's more food for thought:
https://www.cheatsheet.com/entertainment/music/a-court-date-has-been-set-for-the-copyright-infringement-lawsuit-against-ed-sheeran.html/
................................
*"The basis of the Gaye defendants' claims is that 'Blurred Lines' and 'Got to Give It Up' 'feel' or 'sound' the same," the lawsuit states. "Being reminiscent of a 'sound' is not copyright infringement. The intent in producing 'Blurred Lines' was to evoke an era."
https://www.nydailynews.com/entertainment/music-arts/robin-thicke-files-lawsuit-blurred-lines-article-1.1429185


Edited by edshaw (05/29/19 04:19 AM)
_________________________
Biab for WIN 2018
Win 10 64bit
Reaper
TASCAM Digital deck

Top
#538642 - 05/29/19 06:30 AM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 6378
Guitarhacker Offline
Veteran

Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 6378
Then.... there was the time when I was riding down the road....I was listening to a local gospel radio station and a song came on that made my jaw drop. It was by a local (in this state) gospel quartet. I forget the names involved but this song had a melody, lyrics and a groove that was practically a dead ringer for a song I had written a few years previous. I was floored by the similarities.

HOWEVER.....

The song I wrote was never released.... this was back before the internet was a thing. Stuff was still recorded mostly on tape and transferred to tapes. No chance they had heard my song.... at least not very likely. It was simply and amazing coincidence.

No I didn't get a lawyer, no I didn't sue.... I never heard that song from that group again. In fact... I never heard anything from that group. They probably faded into the dust heap of countless, faceless, gospel quartets.
_________________________
You can find my music at:
www.herbhartley.com

Add nothing that adds nothing to the music

Top
#538651 - 05/29/19 07:29 AM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 02/15/17
Posts: 2208
Deryk - PG Music Offline
PG Music Staff

Registered: 02/15/17
Posts: 2208
Thanks for sharing - I found this to be very informative. Still a little muddy, yes - but he's an attorney in the subject and even he finds it muddy. Unfortunately the grey area on the subject right now is vast. I look forward to hearing where it all ends up.

There's a growing surplus of experimental artists on the underbelly of the hip hop and rock scene I follow. I have a suspicion as these laws get stricter and stricter, we'll see more and more experimental and abstract artists coming to the forefront. I could be wrong, but it'd be nice to see.

It's a tough time for pop artists though. It's scary knowing if something even has the vibe of another tune - by accident even - that you can be sued.
_________________________
Cheers,
Deryk

Top
#538686 - 05/29/19 01:51 PM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: Deryk - PG Music]
Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 6378
Guitarhacker Offline
Veteran

Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 6378
Originally Posted By: Deryk - PG Music


It's a tough time for pop artists though. It's scary knowing if something even has the vibe of another tune - by accident even - that you can be sued.


Yep... I imagine that ruined George Harrison's day. "I'm being sued for 3 freaking notes?"
_________________________
You can find my music at:
www.herbhartley.com

Add nothing that adds nothing to the music

Top
#538844 - 05/30/19 05:29 PM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 10/09/16
Posts: 597
Loc: Central Ohio
edshaw Offline
Journeyman

Registered: 10/09/16
Posts: 597
Loc: Central Ohio
I turned this up while looking at the subject of Ai and music production and analysis. Confirms some suspicions.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oVME_l4IwII


Edited by edshaw (05/31/19 07:19 AM)
_________________________
Biab for WIN 2018
Win 10 64bit
Reaper
TASCAM Digital deck

Top
#538883 - 05/31/19 07:26 AM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: edshaw]
Registered: 12/27/03
Posts: 12118
Loc: Hamlin NY
MarioD Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/27/03
Posts: 12118
Loc: Hamlin NY
Edshaw, I am sending this out to all of my musician friends who are not on the forums. This explained a lot of way I dislike most of the songs on the radio today. It also explained why I like most of the music in the showcase!
_________________________
If you are sitting in public and a stranger takes the seat next to you just look straight ahead and say "did you bring the money"?

64 bit Win 10 Pro - the latest BiaB and RB - Roland Octa-Capture audio interface - a ton of software and some hardware.

Top
#538907 - 05/31/19 09:59 AM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 10/09/16
Posts: 597
Loc: Central Ohio
edshaw Offline
Journeyman

Registered: 10/09/16
Posts: 597
Loc: Central Ohio
Thank you Mario. I hesitated to post that link. Your positive comment on it makes all the difference. Thx.
Yeah, Ai and out of control domination is affecting so many areas, not to mention music. I also turned up a PBS Nova clip (3:00) on Deep Fakes, which I had only heard mentioned.
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/video/deepfake-videos-are-getting-terrifyingly-real/
Not to dwell on it, but it goes to show what can happen when the business agents take over all the jobs, kind of like robots in an auto plant.
_________________________
Biab for WIN 2018
Win 10 64bit
Reaper
TASCAM Digital deck

Top
#538936 - 05/31/19 12:19 PM [Off-Topic] Re: Copyright law - A 15 minute vid by an attorney [Re: jazzmammal]
Registered: 12/20/00
Posts: 11317
Loc: Pensacola, Florida
jford Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/20/00
Posts: 11317
Loc: Pensacola, Florida
When computer-created music becomes more mainstream and computer AI's can easily detect copyright violation, maybe we'll get into a situation where computers start suing the computers over artificial intellectual property infringement. smile
_________________________
John

LaptopBeast HP Win7Pro64, 8GB
AudioBeast ASUS Win10Pro64, 16GB
VideoBeast HP Win10Pro64, 8GB

UMC404HD/Casio Kbds/BB-RB2019/Cakewalk/Reaper/Studio One/Samplitude/MixBus/Notion/Finale/Noteworthy/NI Komplete/Halion/Garritan/IK
http://www.sus4chord.com

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >


PG Music News
Video - Band-in-a-Box® for Windows: Exporting MIDI

Learn how to export MIDI when you watch our latest video: Exporting MIDI.

Video - Custom Endings (Band-in-a-Box® 2019 for Windows)

You can create your own custom endings within Band-in-a-Box® - just head to your song settings! Anthony explains how to adjust the settings so that your song ending is customized... watch it now: click here.

Read more about Custom Endings in the online manual, here.

Video - The Melody Sequencer & MIDI Channels in Band-in-a-Box® 2019 for Windows

In our latest video, Anthony explains using the Melody Sequencer to separate MIDI channels within the program - Watch now!

Read more about this feature.

Customers LOVE Band-in-a-Box®!


Here's some of the wonderful feedback we've received lately:

"I gotta admit Band-in-a-Box is great software. I have version 2018 and I use it for a ton of my videos i make on my YouTube channel."
"Wow this program has come a long way over the years! Great sounding audio tracks!"
"I absolutely love this product and use it everyday."
"If you want to write songs, then you should use Band-in-a-Box. I simply love it! It really produces a professional touch!"
"For an amateur songwriter like me this software is a dream come true and the fact that these musicians have been paid to create these tracks makes me happy to use this software without worrying about ripping people off. Just brilliant!"
"I've been a PG Music customer for over 20 years. Best value for music software product hands down. Create a full backing track in minutes and then experiment with styles and different instruments for a whole evening. The software is so good, it's the main component in TRIO band creator!"
"I bought the UltraPAK - wow what a revelation! There is so much that can be done to create a backing track of your own making! It took a while at first but now I feel like a pro in just a Month its good value for money..."
"I've been using Band-in-a-Box for decades and love it. Now using Reaper with Band-in-a-Box - Band-in-a-Box Rocks more than ever!"
"This is the greatest thing out, I've got it, just fantastic!"
"It's absolutely unique. No other music software can do what Band-in-a-Box does, and with such great results"
"Band-in-a-Box is an incredible product. Once you get up and running (and it doesn't take long at all) the musical possibilities are endless. The sound quality of the various styles and instruments is superb!"

Thank you everyone - we think our customers are AMAZING!

Do you love Band-in-a-Box too? Take a moment to check the Video Testimonials offer that is always available, and you could receive your next version FREE! For inspiration, check out the Video Testimonials that have already been submitted here!

Portuguese Band-in-a-Box® 2019 for Windows is Here!

Band-in-a-Box 2019® em Português!

Novas Funções
Pacotes

Polish Band-in-a-Box® 2019 for Windows is Here!

Istnieje wiele ekscytujących nowych funkcji w Band-in-a-Box 2019!

Band-in-a-Box® z RealBand 2019: Pakiety
Band-in-a-Box® z RealBand 2019 dla Windows : Nowych Funkcji

Spanish Band-in-a-Box® 2019 for Windows is Here!

Band-in-a-Box® 2019 para Windows® está aquí!

Nuevas características
Todos los Paquetes

Forum Stats
29610 Members
60 Forums
58406 Topics
491371 Posts

Max Online: 2434 @ 11/14/17 12:37 AM
Newest Members
tintop, Hooch, Peter Mark, Cheapsc8, Andyp2

29610 Registered Users
Top Posters (30 Days)
Jim 140
rsdean 139
Tommyc 124
Janice & Bud 123
Jim Fogle 115
floyd jane 112
Noel96 106
Joe -PG Music 105
Ember - PG Music 101
Tangmo 96
Today's Birthdays
Saxfred