Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 >
You need to be logged in to post
Options
Index
#668844 - 08/17/21 11:16 AM [Off-Topic] If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it?
Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Mark Hayes Offline
Expert

Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
I'm working on a project that began as a Logic rendering of a Beatles MIDI downloaded from the Internet sometime in the 90s.

At some point, I took all the parts and inverted them, melodically, using Logic's MIDI transform function. To my surprise, the result was surprisingly musical, and required only a little adjustment to sound like a decent pop song. Now, every ascending passage descends and vice versa, and a bouncy major key has become a fairly grim minor.

I like it. But who wrote it?

I can't say I did, for obvious reasons.

But the result is a distinctly different piece of music from the original, and, really, not one to be reasonably (or fairly) credited to Lennon and McCartney.

I wonder about the general ethics / esthetics involved here, given that it's theoretically possible to produce a steady stream of "original" compositions this way.

Top
#668850 - 08/17/21 11:29 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 12/27/13
Posts: 2393
Loc: St. Louis, MO. USA
sslechta Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/27/13
Posts: 2393
Loc: St. Louis, MO. USA
There's a lot of similar videos on YouTube about "inverting" songs so-to-speak. I don't see a problem with this but I'm sure someone out there would take issue.... they always do. smile
_________________________


Steve

BIAB/RB 2022, Pro Tools 2020, Korg N5, JBL LSR 4328 Powered Monitors, AKG/Shure Mics.
PC: Win11 PRO, 1 TB SSD, 2 TB HD, 128 GB Memory

Top
#668855 - 08/17/21 12:29 PM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 12/08/02
Posts: 9255
Loc: Wauconda
MusicStudent Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/08/02
Posts: 9255
Loc: Wauconda
What! You have an original song written by the Beatles which was never published? grin

Or...

Steve Jobs was quoted saying... "good artists borrow and great artists steal." However, he probably stole that quote from Picasso… who probably took it from Stravinsky. crazy We stand on the shoulders of giants as we move forward in life.
_________________________
Dan,
BIAB2022, Dell XPS 8920 Intel Core I7-7700 @ 3.60GHz 16GB RAM, REAPER, nanoKontrol2, SL88-Studio, M-Audio61

SoundCloud


Top
#668915 - 08/18/21 07:17 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 07/06/00
Posts: 5584
Loc: Fort Pierce, Florida, U.S.A.
Notes Norton Offline
Veteran

Registered: 07/06/00
Posts: 5584
Loc: Fort Pierce, Florida, U.S.A.
I don't know. If you want advice, contact a lawyer versed in copyright law.

I do know that in classical music, inversion of a theme is a legit method of developing the song.

Notes
_________________________
Bob "Notes" Norton smile Norton Music
http://www.nortonmusic.com

100% MIDI Super-Styles recorded by live, pro, studio musicians for a live groove
& Fake Disks for MIDI and/or RealTracks

Top
#668917 - 08/18/21 07:51 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 8192
Guitarhacker Offline
Veteran

Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 8192
So.... essentially, if you hadn't said a word about it, no one would have ever guessed where you got the inspiration from..... is that correct?

If it's not an obvious rip-off.... I don't think it's considered stealing. I see it as processing something through the filter of your brain both conscious and subconscious, and getting a unique outcome. But again.... I'm not a lawyer versed in copyright law. If no one recognizes it as having other origins.... it's obviously an original. That's how I look at it.


The secret is to take what you hear from others and make it your own in such a way that the one who inspired the idea doesn't recognize it as something they did in one form or another. We all do this constantly.

Chord progressions, as everyone knows, are not copyrightable. And if you reversed it, and have a different melody, which would obviously be the case, I think you're in the clear. You're under no obligation to even mention it or give credit to the "other" song or writer unless you simply want to let folks like in this forum know how it was achieved. I don't think I would have even done that. Just a simple..... here's a new song. Done


Edit: the only way I could see trouble brewing in a legal sense is if you sampled the original, reversed it and used it. That is a copyright violation. But.... if you don't do that, there's nothing to worry about.


Edited by Guitarhacker (08/18/21 07:53 AM)
_________________________
You can find my music at:
www.herbhartley.com

Add nothing that adds nothing to the music.


As the sword chooses the warrior, so too, the song chooses the writer.

Top
#668939 - 08/18/21 10:39 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Mark Hayes Offline
Expert

Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Guitarhacker: "So.... essentially, if you hadn't said a word about it, no one would have ever guessed where you got the inspiration from..... is that correct?"

I guess that would depend on the listener; some people can hear things like that! But essentially, yeah. I'm not thinking of anything you could call an "interpretation" of the original, as a normal listener would hear it. A normal listener can recognize a theme in a different key, or a different mode, but not inverted.

But regardless of normal listeners and recognizeability, it's a trivial matter to reverse-engineer a reversed piece back into the original. And I don't know how such things actually play out in courts, but I can imagine a lawyer playing a contested song on a laptop and showing how you just do "select all" then take a certain menu option and suddenly you're listening to "Raindrops Keep Fallin On My Head" – and the jury going, whoa, it's the same song.

I suppose what you do to finesse the legal situation is take your inversion of "Raindrops" and call it something like "Neutrons Keep Shooting From the Ground" where the listener will get the winky-winky meaning.

In terms of "obligations", I would just feel dishonest if I presented such as I've described as completely original material. Plus it would be too easy to get caught, once any suspicions were raised!

Top
#668940 - 08/18/21 11:05 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 03/07/18
Posts: 3716
Rustyspoon# Online   content
Veteran

Registered: 03/07/18
Posts: 3716
ecilA morf dnalrednoW thgim wonk eht rewsna.

Top
#668942 - 08/18/21 11:23 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Rustyspoon#]
Registered: 12/08/02
Posts: 9255
Loc: Wauconda
MusicStudent Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/08/02
Posts: 9255
Loc: Wauconda
Originally Posted By: Rustyspoon#
ecilA morf dnalrednoW thgim wonk eht rewsna.


Good idea Misha. Mark, can you upload the song in question for a brief period, to this very select audience, to allow us to see if we recognize it from the Beatles catalog?
_________________________
Dan,
BIAB2022, Dell XPS 8920 Intel Core I7-7700 @ 3.60GHz 16GB RAM, REAPER, nanoKontrol2, SL88-Studio, M-Audio61

SoundCloud


Top
#668943 - 08/18/21 11:31 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: MusicStudent]
Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Mark Hayes Offline
Expert

Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Originally Posted By: MusicStudent
Originally Posted By: Rustyspoon#
ecilA morf dnalrednoW thgim wonk eht rewsna.


Good idea Misha. Mark, can you upload the song in question for a brief period, to this very select audience, to allow us to see if we recognize it from the Beatles catalog?


Sure! I was of course thinking of doing that, but didn't want to if the discussion never took off.

https://soundcloud.com/mark_hayes/inversion

To complicate things even further, the MIDI that I started out with says it is "(C)1996 by Eiko & Nobuo Takenaka". Not sure how that works, considering that these are note-for-note transcriptions of the original Beatles performances, but I certainly owe those folks a lot of credit here.

Top
#668944 - 08/18/21 11:41 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 12/27/03
Posts: 17232
Loc: Hamlin NY
MarioD Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/27/03
Posts: 17232
Loc: Hamlin NY
Inverting a Beatles' song has already been done. It played "Paul is dead"!
_________________________
How did the man who made the first clock know what time it was?

64 bit Win 10 Pro, the latest BiaB and RB, Roland Octa-Capture audio interface, a ton of software and some hardware

Top
#668946 - 08/18/21 11:44 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 07/12/00
Posts: 23450
Loc: Hudson Valley & Lake George NY
Matt Finley Online   content
Veteran

Registered: 07/12/00
Posts: 23450
Loc: Hudson Valley & Lake George NY
The rhythm of the resulting song melody would be identical to the original, correct? You’re doing a vertical mirror image, not a horizontal one?
_________________________
BIAB 2022 Win Audiophile. Software: Studio One 5 Pro, Swam horns, Audition, Notion 7; Win 10 64 Pro. Hardware: custom i7 16 Gb; Roland Integra-7, Presonus Studio 192, Presonus Faderport 8, Royer 121, Adam Sub8 & A5X monitors

Top
#668951 - 08/18/21 11:49 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Matt Finley]
Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Mark Hayes Offline
Expert

Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Originally Posted By: Matt Finley
The rhythm of the resulting song melody would be identical to the original, correct? You’re doing a vertical mirror image, not a horizontal one?


Correct, I didn't mess with that at all.

Top
#668953 - 08/18/21 11:55 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: MarioD]
Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Mark Hayes Offline
Expert

Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Originally Posted By: MarioD
Inverting a Beatles' song has already been done. It played "Paul is dead"!


Mister Ed the Talking Horse got in trouble when his TV show theme was exposed as containing backwards Satanic messages. Here's the song reversed, if you try hard, you really can hear "someone sung this song for Satan" and "the source is the devil".

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bHbHpz3KwnM


Top
#668955 - 08/18/21 11:56 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 8192
Guitarhacker Offline
Veteran

Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 8192
I don't recognize it. I might have figured out that it was reversed, or maybe not. There's only a few places that sound like they are reverse audio.

I was going to capture it but couldn't figure out how.... so I can't reverse it to unlock the magic .... oh well.

It's actually pretty cool sounding. The only thing is that the melody line.... that flute sounding thing..... if it's the original melody to the song, if reversed would give it away.... then your simple solution is to delete that midi track and create your own. It becomes totally unidentifiable at that point I would assume.
_________________________
You can find my music at:
www.herbhartley.com

Add nothing that adds nothing to the music.


As the sword chooses the warrior, so too, the song chooses the writer.

Top
#668957 - 08/18/21 12:02 PM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Guitarhacker]
Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Mark Hayes Offline
Expert

Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Guitarhacker, thanks for the listen! To be clear, the lines are inverted, not reversed.

Top
#668964 - 08/18/21 12:31 PM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 12/08/02
Posts: 9255
Loc: Wauconda
MusicStudent Offline
Veteran

Registered: 12/08/02
Posts: 9255
Loc: Wauconda
I got nothing! I would have to analyze the notes very carefully to ID the origin and I'm likely not one who could do it. Thanks for sharing. grin
_________________________
Dan,
BIAB2022, Dell XPS 8920 Intel Core I7-7700 @ 3.60GHz 16GB RAM, REAPER, nanoKontrol2, SL88-Studio, M-Audio61

SoundCloud


Top
#668993 - 08/18/21 02:43 PM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 05/30/00
Posts: 21045
Loc: Mi., USA
rharv Offline
Veteran

Registered: 05/30/00
Posts: 21045
Loc: Mi., USA
OK, I'll say it, if anyone bothered to look you'd get caught.
ie, if I wrote a song and you inverted it, it would catch my attention enough to notice (IF I heard it).

Not many Beatles left to worry about these days, and I doubt they are on your Soundcloud channel <grin>

Simply knowing it was a Beatles song tipped me off enough to know it was familiar, let alone if it was a song I wrote.

I'd still have to re-engineer it back to prove anything, but that would be the easy part if I had the same tools.
_________________________
Make your sound your own!
.. I do not work here, and the benefits are still awesome

Top
#669016 - 08/18/21 04:44 PM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Mark Hayes Offline
Expert

Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
This be the song it came from... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OsjTO0yZQjk

Top
#669022 - 08/18/21 05:03 PM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Mark Hayes Offline
Expert

Registered: 06/21/21
Posts: 1497
Originally Posted By: Mark Hayes
This be the song it came from... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OsjTO0yZQjk


PS – Another "conceptual" thing I considered was taking the original recording, isolating the vocal and fixing one long and horribly flat note of Paul's that's been bothering me for 50 years now. But then a voice from deep within my soul said: NO, DO NOT GO THERE, and I didn't even let myself try it for chuckles and yucks – I didn't want that corrected version in my head!

Top
#669065 - 08/19/21 12:59 AM [Off-Topic] Re: If I turn somebody else's song upside down, who wrote it? [Re: Mark Hayes]
Registered: 09/27/10
Posts: 5119
Loc: Sacramento, California
dcuny Offline
Veteran

Registered: 09/27/10
Posts: 5119
Loc: Sacramento, California
Gerry Beckley took the song "Till The Sun Comes Up Again", ran it backwards and came up with "Now Sue".



Of course, since he wrote "Till The Sun Comes Up Again", he avoids issues of authorship.

As you said, you can't really say that you wrote it.

Although the Beatles didn't write the melody, it would reasonably and fairly be credited to Lennon and McCartney.

From a legal perspective, it's "derivative work" - deriving new content from existing material.

I can't take credit for this statement - someone on this Reddit thread wrote it, making my own comment here a derivative work. wink

There in fact was a case where someone sued a songwriter for using the reverse version of his melody.

That case didn't succeed. But a case against your version of this song undoubtably would.

Quote:
To establish copyright infringement, you must establish that you own a valid copyright in the work and that:

  • The work has been copied; and
  • The copy is “substantially similar” to the protectable elements of the original work.

There's no doubt that the work has been copied. It's rhythmically identical to the original melody, with the intervals exactly inverted.

So it's a copy that's substantially similar.

While The Beatles didn't compose the work, the derivative relies entirely on their creative work - none of it could exist without the source material, and the resulting material lacks anything that creatively transforms it.

It's a bit like taking a photograph of the Mona Lisa, and claiming the negative of the painting is your own creative work.

Sure, it was "transformed" - but every element of that transformed painting came from the painter, even if it's an inversion of some of those creative choices.

Since the derivative work is 100% built on a melody by Lennon and McCartney, not crediting them for the result would simply be wrong, as you'd be passing off someone else's work as your own.
_________________________
-- David Cuny
My virtual singer development blog

Vocal control, you say. Never heard of it. Is that some kind of ProTools thing?

Top
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 >


PG Music News
Holiday Hours - Monday, May 23, 2022

We are celebrating Victoria Day on Monday, May 23th! Our hours this weekend are:

Saturday, May 21: 8am-4pm PDT
Sunday, May 22: Closed
Monday, May 23: 8am-4pm PDT

Regular Hours resume Tuesday, May 24th.
www.pgmusic.com/contact.htm

Fun with Band-in-a-Box® - A Reunion Event: "Life Is Hard"

Getting together and playing music and writing songs is a wonderful way to spend some free time!

Recently, a few of our Forum members did just that... and they made a video to prove it!

Check out what Charlie Fogle, Eddie, Herb, Pat Marr, David Snyder got up to - and how they did it: Fun with Band-in-a-Box® - A Reunion Event: "Life Is Hard"

...hopefully it inspires you to keep the fun in making music!

How to: Replace a RealTrack with a MIDI Track in Band-in-a-Box®

Starting with a RealStyle in Band-in-a-Box®, and want to make one of your tracks a MIDI track? See how this is done using the MIDI Track Picker dialog with our video How to Replace a RealTrack with a MIDI Track in Band-in-a-Box®.

Want to see a quick video tutorial that's not on our Tips & Tricks list? You can post your request to our I want a video that shows me how to .... forum.

Band-in-a-Box® Tuba RealTracks

Today (May 6) is International Tuba Day!

Celebrate your love for the Tuba today - add one of our Tuba RealTracks (available in Sets 143, 162, and 248) played by either Brad Muirhead or Philip Santner.

Already have a Band-in-a-Box® song with a Tuba? Share it here!

How to: Search for RealTracks in Band-in-a-Box®

Looking for a specific RealTrack for your song? See how easy it is to search by keyword or file name when you watch our latest video, How to Search for RealTracks in Band-in-a-Box®.

Want to see a quick video tutorial that's not on our Tips & Tricks list? You can post your request to our I want a video that shows me how to .... forum.

Update Your Band-in-a-Box® 2022 for Windows Today!

Using Band-in-a-Box 2022 for Windows? Great news! We've released a free update that enhances many of the MIDI features and Drum Stems tracks, updates the program manual and documentation, and resolves a few user reported issues.

This free update includes additional enhancements to the DAW Plugin, and updates it to version 4.5.33.

Make sure you download this free update today!

Learn more...

How to: Capturing and Adding a Screenshot to the PG Music Forums

The PG Music Forums is packed with an incredibly active community, always happy to discuss and share Band-in-a-Box tips, help with any questions other users have, and of course share their songs!

Want to know how to add a screenshot to your forum post? Follow the steps in our helpful video tutorial.

Forum Stats
36046 Members
64 Forums
74406 Topics
652960 Posts

Max Online: 2537 @ 01/19/20 07:09 AM
Newest Members
John gitaar, Dutchadup, dragonrd3, yl956, Karmamrak

36045 Registered Users
Top Posters (30 Days)
MarioD 118
AudioTrack 118
MusicStudent 104
David Snyder 96
Matt Finley 95
Janice & Bud 90
rayc 90
BabuMusic 89
Scott C 86
justanoldmuso 76
Today's Birthdays
No Birthdays