I burned it with BIAB using the "Audio" menu "Burn audio CD". When the box popped up with the "Burn audio CD" button, I clicked that and elected to not finalize. I finalized after I burned 3 songs.

If burning more that on song on a CD is possible, I may have clicked a wrong button by mistake.

I'll just try it again if it is possible. If it is, someone let me know!