Originally Posted By: colly

I love this forum ..but I would love it too be more open honest..etc. Like my post to you ..I am only honest on what I hear....a wee tweak and you have a belter as we say in Glasgow..and it would sound awesome...I wish I got a response like this...I would know then I was doing alright or what to change..

Take care


Hey Colly,

So you're asking for a helpful detailed critique of your submissions then? I'd say some people don't always feel comfortable critiquing a recent member to avoid running them off. And others may not feel qualified to make a critique. Initially you'll probably have to accept the light-handed reviews. You might state in your submissions that you really WANT a helpful critique and encourage members to help you get better. Taste in music and the production thereof are very subjective areas, so getting suggestions that are more personal opinions may not really help you all that much. I'd say give it some time. Keep posting your songs and take what you can from the reviews.

~Bob grin

BIAB 2018 ULTRA
https://soundcloud.com/bob-buford
https://www.youtube.com/user/hawgly
https://www.songtradr.com/user/profile/bob.buford