Originally Posted by PROJECT M
Hello Floyd
A beautiful soulful song
Very good vocal performance
The guitar solo fits in great
A very nice piece of work
Many greetings
Andi ;-)

Thanks, Andi....

Originally Posted by Birchwood
Hi Floyd,

I listened to a very touching song. And I liked it!
It's always nice if you can use a chello in a 'sad' song.
And your vocals are always great, this song is no exeption to that. Not at all.
When listening to your song (again), I followed the piano.
It was very nice, and like Rob, I wondered if you played it yourself.
On the other hand, I would have liked a little more expression in that piano playing, but of course that's a matter of taste.
But the song itself is very touching, as I wrote in my first line!

Hans

Thanks, Hans.
I just taught myself to play piano this past year. Hopefully, I will get more expressive as I continue.


Originally Posted by Scott C
What a lovely vocal Floyd. Awesome lyric. Everything is put together so perfectly. Really well done

Thanks, Scott.



Originally Posted by Noel96
Hi floyd.

This is such a good song.
I listened to it a couple of weeks ago with the thought in mind that I'd "come back tomorrow and write a comment."
Well, a few tomorrows came and went and I didn't get back. Sorry.
Everything about this song is perfect.
You have all the instruments sitting very comfortably together and your performance is the icing on this fine musical cake.
I love what you've done and I love how you've done it.
Music doesn't get any better than this.

In relation to the piano track... Recently, I've been playing around with creating user tracks. They're quite amazing things. If you want, I'm happy to try and create a piano user track for you from your piano accompaniment. I can't guarantee how successful I'll be but I'll do my best. If you'd like me to see what I can come up with, please send me a message and I'll tell you what is needed for creating a track. One of the beauties of user tracks is that you can build them up bit by bit. It's not necessary to do all the chords at once. New chords can be added over time as they are need. If you're interested in finding out about UserTracks, there are a couple of great PG Music videos at the below URL.

https://www.pgmusic.com/usertracks1.htm

I also found the below video on using creating user tracks in Realband informative.

Creating UserTracks in Realband

I hope that you and your family have a brilliant Christmas and a really great 2024.
--Noel

Thanks, Noel.
Since I just started learning piano (or at least getting to the point that I feel I can record it) the idea of doing a User Track strikes me as premature.
I would imagine that would turn out to be a rather one-dimensional UT.
Plus - I go down too many other rabbit holes to add yet another.
The thought is certainly appreciated....
Merry Christmas, my friend...


Originally Posted by dani48
Hi, Floyd !😊

Wonderful tune and performance !
I am awed, this is your best without doubt !
I find it incredible that you can surpass
your other wonderful tunes with every new tune !
It is remarkable, but so it seems to me !😃

I love everything about this masterpiece !

You and your nearest shall have a most Merry
Christmas and shall the New Year be even
better for you and for everyone !

Cheers
Dani

Much appreciated, Dani. Good to see you back around...

150+ Songs produced using BIAB RealTracks
And 50 more...
and some more...