Both are lovely but the live version with Kiana is lush and “big” while the BiaB version is more intimate and “light."
Your productions are outstanding and Kiana is a wonderful singer.
It's great she is part of your music circle.

Your use of the synth vocalist is spectacular.
If we had to make a choice we'd likely go with the live version but they are both superb.

Thanks for sharing!
J&B