Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 >
You need to be logged in to post on the forum
Topic Options
#446370 - 12/20/17 01:20 PM [Off-Topic] How should I approach a musician?
Lucm Offline

Registered: 03/24/15
Posts: 34
I am a complete newbie in that aspect (and many others), so please be patient. Yes, I am clueless, so I am asking for guidance.

I've finally begun to write some music and I intend to record a few tracks a bit later this year. I've got a lot going on and done many experiments, and concluded that my biggest hurdle will be guitars. I can do everything else with plugins. Feel free to disagree, but I am happy with all the results except for guitars. They sound really bad with plugins. Some plugins are supposed to sound good, but they're hard to learn, even more so because I can't play a guitar at all. I won't have time to learn that. I am going to need a real, human guitar player.

I don't know any and they're hard to come by where I live. I will have to find one online who will listen to base tracks and record their part on their own and send it to me for mixing.

Now, question #1:
How/where do I find them?

It's a twofold question: where do I find guitar players that will be available for something like this (I understand I will have to pay), and how do I find players whose style is a match to what I have in mind?

and question #2:
What if I don't like the result?

I can write the part, using crappy guitar plugins or even another instrument and tell the guitarist to use it as a guide.

Or maybe I should let them have more freedom to create their part as they see fit. I would definitely be willing to try that experiment, I am sure that many will not just play well but also write better parts than myself.

But what if I don't like it? How do I handle that? I certainly don't want to offend anyone. I don't know if recording the part somehow and telling them to play the same on a guitar is even acceptable. I don't know anything about how that is supposed to work.

Ideas, please? TIA

#446379 - 12/20/17 01:53 PM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: Lucm]
Matt Finley Online   content

Registered: 07/12/00
Posts: 16973
Loc: Hudson Valley & Lake George NY
Hi. I can't help with guitar, but I'm a 50+ year pro horn player. I send my band BIAB songs as composer demos, and a lead sheet that I write, and ask that they reproduce the basic sound when we record in the studio or play a concert. This gives them an idea of the song but doesn't force them to play any particular part exactly. These are world-class players and they are not offended at all.

For my recordings, I hire other musicians as independent contractors. They understand that I may change their tracks by mixing, editing, or even leaving them out. This is just part of the business.

When people hire me to play on their recordings, I ask for an MP3 of the song and work out an arrangement and rough parts in advance. Then at the studio, I record this. They often ask me to play something different, and I record that, too - whatever they suggest. But I've noticed that the part I prepared is always the one they use on their recordings.

BIAB 2018 PC Audiophile; [& 2017 Mac]. Software: Mixcraft, Adobe Audition, Ozone, Encore; Win 10 64 Pro. Hardware: custom i7, 16 Gb RAM; Roland Integra-7, Focusrite 18i20(2), TCE Finalizer, Behringer X-Touch, Adam sub & 6" monitors.

#446409 - 12/20/17 04:24 PM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: Lucm]
MarioD Offline

Registered: 12/27/03
Posts: 10686
Loc: Hamlin NY
Hi Lucm,

I am a guitarist who has collaborated with many other musicians, some here, and many outside of the PGMusic world.

To find a guitarist to help you just post a message on any forums that you are on. I'm sure you will get a hit or two and many will work for nothing more than the recognition that they played the part.

If you have a part that you want a guitarist to play post that with the request. If it is not possible to play what you have on a guitar they will let you know, of course that applies to specific chord voicings and harmonies.

When I work with others I let them know up front that it is their song, not mine, and they have the final say. I have no problem with them saying this isn't what they want. When collaborating one can not have an ego problem. I done stuff that others have loved and I have done stuff that others have hated. If you have thin skin then don't collaborate.

Good luck and I hope this helps.
Yesterday I walked into a room and remembered why I was there! It was the bathroom!

64 bit Win 10 Pro - the latest BiaB and RB - Roland Octa-Capture audio interface - a ton of software and some hardware.

#446411 - 12/20/17 04:55 PM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: MarioD]
rharv Offline

Registered: 05/30/00
Posts: 18705
Loc: Marysville, Mi. USA
Originally Posted By: MarioD

When I work with others I let them know up front that it is their song, not mine, and they have the final say. I have no problem with them saying this isn't what they want. When collaborating one can not have an ego problem. I done stuff that others have loved and I have done stuff that others have hated. If you have thin skin then don't collaborate.

I've worked with Mario and other guitar players online (here and other forums/sources).
I agree with him; look for a volunteer first. This will hone your skills at collaboration and (maybe) negotiation. Plus you may find a piece of gold along the way.

Some experiments/experiences may not end as expected, but you do get to learn from every one.

/I've personally used things that Mario contributed and discarded others, and it has never been a problem. Not all musicians have an ego. <grin>
Make your sound your own!

#446415 - 12/20/17 05:11 PM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: Lucm]
eddie1261 Online   content

Registered: 04/08/11
Posts: 4073
Loc: Cleveland, Ohio
Things to consider:

Guitar players are people first. They just know how to play the guitar. Approach them as you would approach a mechanic or a plumber. "Hi. I need some work done and I wonder if you would be interested in it?"

This is important for us to know. Do YOU play? You said you don't play guitar. Do you play keyboards or anything? Do you have a music background. That would be helpful in the long haul as far as basing your decisions.

As far as knowing who to ask, when you contact them just ask for clips. You are a boss interviewing applicants.

If you don't like their track, tell them gently, something like "Hey, that's good for a first pass. Do you have any other ideas, possibly something in a completely different vein?" And this is where your music knowledge would come into play. "Maybe you can start on a higher octave and work back down from there", or "Maybe you could cut the timing of the phrases in half". Keep in mind, it's your song. It may be as simple as "Can you give me something like "(and here you hum or doo doo doo doo what your mind's ear hears)?" Or "Can you base that solo a little more on what the melody line is?" Whatever you do, whatever you say, speak with a smile. Always give positive suggestions and energy or the guy will tell you to buzz off. You can also use those generated parts you say you don't particularly like as a baseline. Send him the tracks and tell him to use this as a starting point and "send me some ideas". Ask for 5.

I work with Rog in England quite a bit. He gives me his thoughts, I listen with an open mind, and unless it is totally out of left field (and it rarely is) we tweak and work with it. He once completely retooled one of my songs and it turned out to be as good a pop tune as it was a country tune. Fortunately we both understand who owns the song and who gets the final say. I think we compliment each other pretty well. When he had a lot of vocal students they did a lot of singing and reworked 4 of my songs completely. His kids got experience, I got another set of ears on what I wrote, and I grew as a writer from it.

The key is mutual respect. Everybody works from a different level and a different knowledge base. A guy with a Masters Degree is going to know more about the core and roots of the music, where someone with less exposure plays it by ear. Both ways work, it's the difference between someone with knowledge of cars who knows enough to change oil and a guy who builds engines. Just don't become intimidated or settle for something you don't want. This is your recipe. Use the brand of sugar you want.
I don't fear deep water as much as I fear shallow people.

#446453 - 12/20/17 09:24 PM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: Lucm]
Tobias Offline

Registered: 03/26/04
Posts: 1557
Loc: Way too close to Palm Springs,...
I have a few questions for you since I'm a guitar player who has worked with mostly local musicians for many years.
1. Do your songs "need" guitars?
2. Where in the world could you possibly live where guitarists are hard to come by?
Does the noise in your head bother me ?

#446486 - 12/21/17 05:06 AM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: Lucm]
Janice & Bud Offline

Registered: 12/05/11
Posts: 5305
Well you can always “approach” the award winning renown BiaB RealTrack players. Find a guitar RT to your liking, generate multiple tracks (if needed) and cut/paste them to your liking. And they are assuredly not “crappy plug-ins.” The user forum is packed with great examples. There fine guitar players on the forum who frequently use RT’s.

Best to you and happy holidays.
Never grow's a trap.
J&B SoundCloud Sampler
J&B YouTube Sampler
J&B Website

#446497 - 12/21/17 06:54 AM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: Tobias]
Lucm Offline

Registered: 03/24/15
Posts: 34
Originally Posted By: Tobias
1. Do your songs "need" guitars?

Ah, yes, they do. It's rock'n'roll. cool Nothing harsh or heavy, but it kind of rocks and would be toothless without a guitar.

Originally Posted By: Tobias
2. Where in the world could you possibly live where guitarists are hard to come by?

For one thing, I just moved to a relatively small city where I know exactly zero people. It's going to be a while until I scout the area and get to know the music scene.

For another thing, I'm quite far from America and there are regional issues. Everyhing that is popular around here is tragically different from my taste. God bless the Internet.


Loving the answers so far. Looks like it's a lot less formal and easier than I thought. I was afraid there might be some kind of tricky etiquette around musicians besides the usual in the daily interaction with people. I just don't want any Keith Richards to throw knives at me. grin

#446508 - 12/21/17 07:57 AM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: Lucm]
BlueAttitude Offline

Registered: 11/30/07
Posts: 1191
Loc: Ontario, Canada
As Bud said you shouldn't have any problem finding a BIAB guitar realtrack that will fill your needs, there are many rock guitar realtracks to choose from.

Blue Attitude: Homepage, Latest song: The Traveller

#446519 - 12/21/17 08:52 AM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: Lucm]
eddie1261 Online   content

Registered: 04/08/11
Posts: 4073
Loc: Cleveland, Ohio
Lucm, visit the User Showcase forum and find my song Things That Go Together. Give it a listen. All during the verses and chorus, the rhythm guitars you hear are Real Band tracks. There is some human guitar in there, but that guitar on that song is 90% Real Band, as is the bass. I played the guitar part on the intro, Rog added the fills, sang the harmonies, and spiced up the drums with his drum samples. But the guitars, which are your main concern here, were Real Band tracks.

My suggestion is that you spend some time with BIAB/RB and explore. You will truly find anything you need. My CD was 75-80% Real Band tracks.
I don't fear deep water as much as I fear shallow people.

#446525 - 12/21/17 09:28 AM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: BlueAttitude]
Charlie Fogle Offline

Registered: 04/07/13
Posts: 4230
Loc: South Carolina
Originally Posted By: BlueAttitude
As Bud said you shouldn't have any problem finding a BIAB guitar realtrack that will fill your needs, there are many rock guitar realtracks to choose from.

That's my thought as well. There are many benefits to looking at RT's first.

You save time, and the time you save can be spent in BIAB RT's creating your specific track.

Scheduling is not an issue, nor is setup. To record a live guitarist, time is spent setting up equipment, tuning, tweaking, warming up, reviewing and learning your song, developing and trying out ideas to how to play your song and even just getting comfortable.

Not every guitarist you find will be a good or even adequate session player. Even in such hotbeds as LA, NY and Nashville, there are loads of really good guitarists that get steady work in road bands, gig every night, but they are not on any studios short list of session musicians. It's just not a skill everyone has or wants.

BIAB/RB generated RealTrack guitars can be as easy as 1-2-3 or you can work for weeks or more on a single track. Most assuredly, you will likely find something as suitable from RealTracks as you will getting a guitarist off the street.
BiaB Ultra Pak 2018:Build 512, RB 2018 Build 5; Windows 7 64 bit AMD Athlon IIX2 215 Dual-core processor; 500GB hard drive; 4GB DDR3 Memory.

#446553 - 12/21/17 11:39 AM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: Lucm]
dcuny Offline

Registered: 09/27/10
Posts: 1918
Loc: Sacramento, California
Out of curiosity, did you try using RealTrack guitars? If so, were there any particular issues you found with them?

If you need a more custom rhythm, you can use modifiers with the chord symbols:

  • C.. Strum, then mute the chord
  • C... Strum and hold the chord
  • ^C Anticipate the beat by an 8th note
  • ^^C Anticipate the beat by a 16th note

Since it sounds like you're using an external DAW, you can build the guitar track by itself in BiaB, and then export it to the DAW.

Edited by dcuny (12/21/17 01:18 PM)
Edit Reason: "Anticipate" is more descriptive than "push."
-- David Cuny
My virtual singer development blog

Vocal control, you say. Never heard of it. Is that some kind of ProTools thing?

#446556 - 12/21/17 11:45 AM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: dcuny]
eddie1261 Online   content

Registered: 04/08/11
Posts: 4073
Loc: Cleveland, Ohio
Originally Posted By: dcuny

  • ^C Push the beat by an 8th note
  • ^^C Push beat by 8th note

Aren't those 2 the same thing? The second one is just missing a "the" and an "an".

This has always confused me because my brain says I want to PULL the music back an 8th note. I have to start thinking "anticipate". Just another example of things I don't use much in RB. I still don't know how you guys make RB sing harmonies. I still can't figure out to accurately program half note triplets... I have had this thing for like 7-8 years and still I have just scratched the surface on the tools inside this software.

Those triplets though.... grin
I don't fear deep water as much as I fear shallow people.

#446559 - 12/21/17 11:51 AM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: Lucm]
eddie1261 Online   content

Registered: 04/08/11
Posts: 4073
Loc: Cleveland, Ohio
Still interested in knowing what your music background is. People with some theory background tend to use phrases that are inherent to that knowledge, like telling someone "A major chord is 1-3-5."

To which the student asks "What's a 3? What's a 5? For that matter what's a 1?" If the student doesn't know a keyboard and where the half steps and whole steps are about, the next question is usually "When do I use the black keys?" Or in this specific example "What do you mean C?"

When you say you are a newbie, a newbie to music overall or a newbie to this software? To ask someone to sit down at the chord chart page and "Enter your chord progression here" would be met with a blank stare if they know zero about music and chords. A good number of people write lyrics beautifully but have no musical knowledge to take those lyrics and apply them to a melody to turn them into a song.

So please share with us a little about your background. We are pretty friendly overall and very willing to help but we have to know what "language" to speak in.

Edited by eddie1261 (12/21/17 11:53 AM)
I don't fear deep water as much as I fear shallow people.

#446560 - 12/21/17 11:52 AM [Off-Topic] Re: How should I approach a musician? [Re: Lucm]
jford Offline

Registered: 12/20/00
Posts: 10232
Loc: Pensacola, Florida
That was a typo. The ^^ is to push by a 16th note.

HP Win10Pro-64, 8GB
ASUS Win10Pro-64, 16GB
HP Win7Pro-64, 8GB

H/W-Behringer U-Phoria UMC404HD, Casio Kbds
S/W-BB/RB2018/Sonar/Reaper/Studio One/Samplitude/MixBus/Notion/Finale/Noteworthy/NI Komplete/Halion/Garritan/IK

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 >

PG Music News
User Tip - Custom Drum Shots

Have you ever wanted more control of the RealDrums generated within Band-in-a-Box? (example: with the same consecutive shot/hold/push)

Forum user Pipeline shared their steps in an incredibly detailed forum post to our Tips & Tricks forum - check it out: Custom Drum Shots.

#FunFactFriday - Team PG!

Did you know... Within Band-in-a-Box®, choose Help | About Band-in-a-Box, and you'll see more than just information on the program - you'll also see a complete list of Team PG - we're currently at 35 team members!

#TBT - Automatic Soloing in Band-in-a-Box® 7!

Band-in-a-Box® 7 included some great new features - like Automatic Soloing! This introduced program users to the powerful Soloist capabilities of Band-in-a-Box®, which also includes the Soloist Maker.

Automatic Soloing!
Pick any song or chords in any style, and choose a "soloist." Band-in-a-Box® then creates and plays a professional quality solo in the style of your choice. Previous versions of Band-in-a-Box created great accompaniment. Now you can hear sensational solos as well - showing you exactly what notes are played. Choose from "soloists" in the style similar to great Jazz musicians such as Django Reinhardt, John Coltrane, or Country/Pop soloists and others, or create your own soloists using the "Soloist Maker."

Soloist Maker
This module allows you to define your own soloists. For example, let's say you want to create a soloist in a style similar to the style of "John Coltrane" - the great Jazz saxophonist. The Soloist Maker allows you to define the parameters essential to Coltrane's playing, such as instrument range (i.e. tenor saxophone), extra legato playing, playing more on top of the beat than typical Jazz musicians, and playing straighter 8th notes than usual Swing 8th notes. Also, you can set phrasing options, such as how long the phrase should be and how much "space" to leave between phrases. You can also set how "outside" the playing should be. In the case of a John Coltrane style - you set that to the maximum! Then "turn him loose" and hear the soloist play over any song!

Review all of the features added with Band-in-a-Box® 7:

#TechTipTuesday - Opening MIDI Tracks in PowerTracks Pro Audio

Open your MIDI file in PowerTracks Pro Audio (or RealBand), and you'll see the instruments separated onto their own track - an excellent way to hear all the instruments individually for that song, and a great way to learn!

There's no trick to it either - just use the File | Open dialog, locate the MIDI file, and click [Open].

Note: Type 0 MIDI files have all channels on one track, and should ask whether you want to separate them. If you accidentally chooses no, hit Edit - MIDI - Extract Channels to Tracks. Typically, Type 1 MIDI files have the instruments automatically separated.

With the release of Band-in-a-Box® 2018 for Windows we also released 202 NEW RealTracks, including 8 Sets (68 RealTracks) for Rock-Pop!

Learn more about these and listen to demos:

RealPAK 14: Rock-Pop includes:
RealTracks Set 286: Pop & Rock Guitars with Brent & Joe
RealTracks Set 287: Pop Songwriter - Acoustic Guitar
RealTracks Set 288: Southern Pop Drums with Land Richards
RealTracks Set 289: Fretless Bass, Pop Keys, and Punk Drums
RealTracks Set 290: More Pop Percussion Singles
RealTracks Set 291: Modern Dancehall
RealTracks Set 292: Klezmer!
RealTracks Set 293: A Taste of Europe - France, Italy, and Sweden

Purchasing the Band-in-a-Box® 2018 PlusPAK, UltraPAK, or Audiophile Edition? These new Rock-PopRealTracks are already included!
Band-in-a-Box® 2018 Pro and MegaPAK customers interested in adding these to their collection can purchase RealPAK 14: Rock-Pop for just $79 at

Audio Edit Window Enhancements in Band-in-a-Box® 2018 for Windows!

With Band-in-a-Box® 2018 for Windows, the Audio Edit Window GUI has been updated to include a dedicated settings button and a Marker Mode button. Plus, editing features can now be applied to the entire track (if no specific region is highlighted).

We've also added the following items to the Edit button within the Audio Edit Window:

Paste (Mix) - This will mix the audio from the clipboard with the existing audio instead of overwriting it. You will be given the option to set the percentage of the existing audio to keep and the pasted audio to mix in.
Paste (Insert) - This will insert the audio from the clipboard to the current location, instead of overwriting the existing audio. The audio to the right of the insertion point will be shifted to make room for the new audio.
Delete - This will delete the selected region of audio.
Insert Silence - This will insert silence at the cursor. The duration of the silence inserted will be equal to the duration of the selected region.
Convert Channels - If the audio is stereo, this will convert it to mono. If it’s mono, this will convert it to stereo. You will be given the option to set the percentage of the left and right channels to include.
Harmonize - This will launch the Audio Harmony dialog, which can be used to harmonize the selected region of audio.
Transcribe - This will transcribe the audio to the Melody or Soloist track.
Fix Tuning - This will automatically correct the tuning of the selected region according to the key of your song. For example, in the key of C, if a C# is detected then it will be transposed down to C or up to D depending on which one is closer.

YouTube Find - Tools to Improve Your Music Composition

My secret weapon is Band-in-a-Box...
Brian Johnston

Brian explains why we're his secret weapon in this great article: Improving Music Composition Diversity

And he even created the following video: Tools to Improve Your Music Composition

Forum Stats
27233 Members
49 Forums
50671 Topics
416870 Posts

Max Online: 2434 @ 11/14/17 12:37 AM
Newest Members
Phil Leith, jocowe, prems, judedi, Ivan

27232 Registered Users
Top Posters (30 Days)
Matt Finley 180
VideoTrack 165
Noel96 152
MarioD 135
Deryk - PG Music 115
BlueAttitude 112
David Snyder 110
Pipeline 109
Janice & Bud 107
dcuny 107
Today's Birthdays
Joey45, Karantois