David, this is a catch 22 situation. In essence you are asking for a "Casual Review Showcase" and a "Critical Review Showcase". This is a good idea but could lead to difficulties. I have seen wars break out over "critical" reviews on other sites; one must have very tough skin when posting a song for criticisms.

Plus who does the critical reviews? How would a jazz musician give a critical review of an ambient song? It could get very difficult. There are other sites that can evaluate your songs, Taxi is one. There pros can do the evaluations.

I have seen a number of constructive criticisms welcomed on the current showcase forum. As I have said before all of my posts are open for constructive criticisms.

I can see both sides of the issue on this suggestion.


Waitress "How did you find your steak sir"?

Me "I just looked next to the potatoes and there it was"!

64 bit Win 10 Pro, the latest BiaB/RB, Roland Octa-Capture audio interface, a ton of software/hardware