You need to be logged in to post
Options
Index
#536519 - 05/13/19 05:58 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] MP3 or WAV
Registered: 02/23/16
Posts: 34
BryanDP Offline
Enthusiast

Registered: 02/23/16
Posts: 34
I'm a plain old muso who's love for music far exceeds my abilities. I do my tracks in BIAB keeping them as simple as possible. Then render them into MP3's to strum and sing along to. Budget equipment is the best I can do. Alto mixer and active speakers. The question is would it make that much difference rendering to WAV files rather than MP3's. In truth i can't really hear the difference, too many years of music, motorcycles and machining has done the damage.

Top
#536525 - 05/13/19 06:38 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: MP3 or WAV [Re: BryanDP]
Registered: 12/17/15
Posts: 80
Loc: Illinois
TLMelvin Offline
Enthusiast

Registered: 12/17/15
Posts: 80
Loc: Illinois
IMHO-if all you're doing is playing along for your own benefit- mp3 is fine. It also takes up less space on your drive and as you say, you can't hear the difference.
_________________________
https://soundcloud.com/tmelvin-950716356

Top
#536534 - 05/13/19 07:07 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: MP3 or WAV [Re: BryanDP]
Registered: 07/12/00
Posts: 18567
Loc: Hudson Valley & Lake George NY
Matt Finley Offline
Veteran

Registered: 07/12/00
Posts: 18567
Loc: Hudson Valley & Lake George NY
I concur. Of course, MP3s can be made in greatly varying quality. If you make one at 44.1K, 320 Kbps, stereo, then few people will be able to tell the difference between that and a .WAV file. If you make a mono .MP3 at 128 Kbps, you'll save space but more people will hear the difference.
_________________________
BIAB 2019 Win Audiophile; [& 2018 Mac UltraPak]. Software: Cakewalk, Adobe Audition, Ozone, Encore; Win 10 64 Pro. Hardware: custom i7, 16 Gb; Roland Integra-7, Focusrite 18i20(2), TCE Finalizer, Behringer X-Touch, Adam sub & monitors.

Top
#536547 - 05/13/19 07:55 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: MP3 or WAV [Re: BryanDP]
Registered: 01/24/10
Posts: 139
Loc: on the edge of the sandbar
mrgeeze Offline
Apprentice

Registered: 01/24/10
Posts: 139
Loc: on the edge of the sandbar
Like Matt Finley said, High quality mp3's are probably fine.
To me, 128kbps are not good enough for performing.
You can hear the difference.

Personally I use .wav files because disk storage is hardly an issue these days.
Mp3's are compressed files. Compression is lost data.

It probably doesn't matter at 320Kbps. But perhaps sometimes it does.
_________________________
win7 biab2019
dell 2 quad i716gb ram 1tb ssd
audioengine usb audio out Mbox Audio
Suhr Tele/PRS C24/FenderVibrolux/Quilter MicroPro Hd
tanacom 1000 deep drop (12 volt)
costa del mar sunglasses
honda element (275Kmiles)

Top
#536619 - 05/14/19 02:21 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: MP3 or WAV [Re: BryanDP]
Registered: 02/23/16
Posts: 34
BryanDP Offline
Enthusiast

Registered: 02/23/16
Posts: 34
Thanks, the BIAB does the MP3 at the 320 setting which sounds great to me. It helps for the storage on the little tablet I use as well. All's well. Take Care.

Top
#536623 - 05/14/19 04:23 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: MP3 or WAV [Re: BryanDP]
Registered: 12/20/16
Posts: 533
Loc: Gold Coast, Queensland, Austra...
Teunis Offline
Journeyman

Registered: 12/20/16
Posts: 533
Loc: Gold Coast, Queensland, Austra...
For performing I use MP3@320kbps. After all I play to folk that are eating, chatting, elderly and or hard of hearing in some other way. I play the music through a PA in buildings that have air conditioners blowing away, or a bit of 50 cycle hum and/or many other extraneous noises. I don’t think anybody even if they were listening closely could pick the difference between the MP3 or a .wav in that environment.

It is possible to find the losses and have a listen to them. In a nutshell you could pull both the .wav and 320 kbps MP3 into something like Audacity. Set (normalise) them to exactly the same level, ensure both are set exactly at the same time, invert one of them then play the song. The tracks will pretty much cancel out. The sound you are left with is the losses. @320kbps the result is not that much, usually high end sound most people struggle to hear.

@128kbps you will hear more losses.

That was my experience.

Tony


Edited by Teunis (05/14/19 04:25 AM)
_________________________
HP i7-4770 16GB 512G SSD, Win 10 Home,
Roland Quad Capture, Launchkey 61, Maton CW80, Telecaster + more
BB 2019 (627) RB 2019 (3), CakeWalk by BandLab, Reaper, Audacity, Melodyne

Top
#536738 - 05/14/19 05:25 PM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: MP3 or WAV [Re: Teunis]
Registered: 05/30/00
Posts: 19268
Loc: Marysville, Mi. USA
rharv Offline
Veteran

Registered: 05/30/00
Posts: 19268
Loc: Marysville, Mi. USA
Quote:
Set (normalise) them to exactly the same level, ensure both are set exactly at the same time, invert one of them then play the song.


If you ever attempt to use this method you indeed need to make sure the two are exactly in time.
By 'invert' I think Teunis means to reverse the polarity of both tracks.

This also means both would need to be at the same volume (Normalizing would get them close but other ways exist).

The theory is that what is in one track sending a negative value would cancel out another track sending a positive value.
This has been a proven technique, but understanding the mechanics can be important.
Get them out of time a little and the results are wrong (usually results in a noticeable phasing).
Having one a little off on volume can also skew the results .. but the science is pretty cool to know. smile

Interesting application of the theory Teunis! I wouldn't have thought of this.
_________________________
Make your sound your own!

Top
#536754 - 05/14/19 08:17 PM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: MP3 or WAV [Re: rharv]
Registered: 12/20/16
Posts: 533
Loc: Gold Coast, Queensland, Austra...
Teunis Offline
Journeyman

Registered: 12/20/16
Posts: 533
Loc: Gold Coast, Queensland, Austra...
Yes, you need to ensure both the MP3 and the .wav are exactly the same in volume and where the play back is from or you will get the sound of phasing and volume imbalance skewing the result. The easiest way to get the start lined up is to go to the first transient on both tracks and line them up.

The term used by Audacity to reverse the “polarity” of a track is to “invert” it. That is the option under effects.

So basically what you are doing is putting the tracks 180 degrees out of phase. If both tracks were exactly the same the result will be zero output. Usually even what you are left with (assuming MP3@320kbps and .wav) you’d need to amplify a fair bit to hear.

Tony


Edited by Teunis (05/14/19 08:20 PM)
_________________________
HP i7-4770 16GB 512G SSD, Win 10 Home,
Roland Quad Capture, Launchkey 61, Maton CW80, Telecaster + more
BB 2019 (627) RB 2019 (3), CakeWalk by BandLab, Reaper, Audacity, Melodyne

Top
#536888 - 05/16/19 01:58 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: MP3 or WAV [Re: BryanDP]
Registered: 02/23/16
Posts: 34
BryanDP Offline
Enthusiast

Registered: 02/23/16
Posts: 34
Thanks Guys, I'm quiet happy with what I'm hearing as I believe the old folk who I play for are happy. so I don't think I'll go looking for the bits I don't have. Even if I found them I wouldn't know what to do with them. The digital thing has passed me by a long time ago and gives me a headache. I still have my toolkit for servicing my car, feeler gauge, Timing light, Dwell meter, Exhaust gas analyser etc. But Digital came along now all I can do is oil change and top up fluids. Now I'm feeling my age. Take care from sunny Durban.

Top
#537300 - 05/19/19 09:10 AM [Recording, Mixing, Performance and Production] Re: MP3 or WAV [Re: BryanDP]
Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 6327
Guitarhacker Offline
Veteran

Registered: 04/03/09
Posts: 6327
High quality MP3 (320KBS) is very difficult to hear the difference. I have used MP3 tracks in my recordings and no one notices. A singer sent me the MP3 and later, when I got ready to mix, the wave was simply not available....

That song is In A World Without you. on my music page
_________________________
You can find my music at:
www.herbhartley.com

Add nothing that adds nothing to the music

Top


PG Music News
Video - Repeats & Endings Dialog Overview for Band-in-a-Box® 2019 for Windows

In our latest video, video we go over the Repeats & Endings Dialog within Band-in-a-Box® 2019 - Learn more...

This video includes information on repeats, 1st/2nd endings, dc al coda, ds al coda, dc al fine, ds al fine, and Fake Sheet Mode.

Holiday Hours - Monday, May 20, 2019

We are celebrating Victoria Day on Monday, May 20th! Our hours this weekend are:

Saturday, May 18: 8am-4pm PST (Technical Support closed)
Sunday, May 19: Closed
Monday, May 20: 8am-4pm PST (Technical Support closed)

Regular Hours resume Tuesday, May 21st.

Testimonial - Woody Piano Shack's Thoughts on Band-in-a-Box®

Check out our latest Video Testimonial from Woody of Woody Piano Shack! Woody uses Band-in-a-Box primarily as a training tool within his YouTube channel and private lessons. He's been a Band-in-a-Box user since the Atari ST days, and is very impressed with the evolution of our program - watch and you'll see! Click here...

Video - Audio Harmony Overview in Band-in-a-Box® 2019 for Windows

We've updated our Audio Harmony Overview video using the latest Band-in-a-Box 2019 for Windows program! Watch now...

Learn even more about Audio Harmonies using the Online Manual, here.

Danish Band-in-a-Box® 2019 for Windows is Here!

Band-in-a-Box® 2019 til Windows® er klar!

Pakker
Nye funktioner

Dutch Band-in-a-Box® 2019 for Windows is Here!

Band-in-a-Box® 2019 voor Windows® is hier!

Pakketten
Nieuwe Functies

Video - Band-in-a-Box® for Windows: Simple Arrangement

Head into the RealTracks Picker window, and you'll see a [ ] Simpler option - but what does that mean? Anthony explains in our latest video, here.

Forum Stats
29478 Members
60 Forums
58069 Topics
487635 Posts

Max Online: 2434 @ 11/14/17 12:37 AM
Newest Members
derStephan, Gord Lang, Jazzismagic, TBProAudio, fierropiano

29478 Registered Users
Top Posters (30 Days)
Jim 140
Noel96 130
rsdean 119
Ember - PG Music 110
Janice & Bud 109
Tangmo 105
rayc 96
Joe -PG Music 86
Jim Fogle 85
Torrey Bliss 83
Today's Birthdays
CountryTrash, Júlíus Hraunberg