Originally Posted By: rayc

I'm just making suggestions based on what I heard.
That is the point of sharing isn't it?

Nope. I myself was in a similar position as you not to long ago.

This is a safe and friendly place where BiaB users can post their songs.

If someone isn't specifically asking for feedback, you can assume that they are happy with everything about their song, and have posted it simply for people to enjoy.

Now, some people post songs and include statements like "Feedback welcome" or "Have at it!", which invites feedback.

But if that's not stated, assume they aren't actively seeking "corrective" feedback - i.e. telling them how it could be made better.

You might mention their vocals are buried in the mix, or that the drums could be turned up.

But don't be surprised if their response is that they are happy with everything exactly the way it is.

-- David Cuny
My virtual singer development blog

Vocal control, you say. Never heard of it. Is that some kind of ProTools thing?