JohnJohnJohn yes!!! RustySpoon I do like your idea of honest, frank but constructive comments. I wouldn't really call that negative, but a constructive comment, if you really have something to say that might help someone or make a difference to improve the song. However as we all know, some people are really sensitive to anything said about a song and may not benefit from the comment and unfortunately it raises negative emotions in that person. Also, sometimes it's way over someone's head the advice given and also may not be helpful. I do think sometimes we would all benefit more from honesty rather than "Good write" or "Another Good One", but I think most people would think it's close to suicide. I think it's in the way something's presented and a lot of people may not know how to do that.