Originally Posted By: gibson
Noel,

fascinating analysis of a wonderful song.

Makes me wonder how Ira and George actually wrote this because then they were writing "from the head" with no reference to songs gone before, as in the analysis. I feel that they would have to have worked together, at the same time, on this song which makes the song, rhythm and rhymes even better.
Never the less an analysis I will remember, thank you. wink

Alyn


Hi Alyn,

It's great to see you over here in this neck of the woods. I read once somewhere that when George and Ira wrote songs, the music usually came first and the lyrics second. Whether or not this is true, I have no idea. One thing that stands out in this song, just like you indicate, is that the words and the music are a perfect partnership. The prosody is outstanding.

All the best,
Noel

MY SONGS...
Audiophile BIAB 2025