Hi, Izzy.

Originally Posted by Izzy
Well,.....
When I hit play on Mr David's "Down That Long Road," I'm not just getting a song; I'm getting an experience. And by "experience," I mean a masterclass in musical storytelling, accompanied by the kind of liner notes that could win a Pulitzer.
Ha! You crack me up laugh

With these comments, you are the one who deserves the prize!

Quote
Seriously, if you ever wondered what goes into crafting a piece of music, Mr David has laid out the entire blueprint, from the initial "blind fumbling" (his words, not mine!) to the raven's epic comeback tour.
It really is blind fumbling! By starting with the music, I then have to figure out who is singing, and why.

Fortunately - as floyd jane has observed - almost all songs are love songs. And even if they aren't, that element is going to be there because that's what makes people (and songs) tick.

Quote
I've seen shorter novels, but I've rarely seen such transparency and dedication, making the journey behind the song almost as compelling as the track itself! You could practically enroll in "Songwriting 101" just by reading the description.
If you check out the thread, you'll see that it's Nekujak who takes me to school, not the other way around. And a few other people jump in to gently let me know when I'm going in the wrong direction. wink

Unfortunately, I replaced the versions as I went along (I did a lot of changes), so you can't necessarily hear what they're talking about. But reading posts like "The part that starts with "When I'm standing on that golden shore." Just my opinion, but I'm not liking that part. Again, just my opinion, but ... I'm really not liking that part." is enough to get the idea across. laugh

Quote
Now, onto the actual tune! "Down That Long Road" is a beautifully crafted piece of bluegrass Americana that wraps you in a warm (if slightly melancholic) embrace from the first twang.
Oh, how I wish I could figure out how to make that voice twang!

Quote
And that raven? What a comeback! From a potentially discarded title to a symbolic guide, it's a testament to the song's evolving narrative.
That poor raven - a harbringer of doom. It was going to be a murder ballad, after all.

I had heard that ravens like to collect stuff, and weave that into the story... but that turned out to be a myth.

Quote
Instrumentally, it's a hoedown of authenticity. The fiddle weeps, the banjo clacks, the mandolin skips, and the guitars strum their way through a landscape of fading hope. It’s all impeccably played, evoking the dusty roads and echoing hollers of the region.
Of course, that's all BiaB. Man, can it do country music!

Quote
Now, in my humble, ever-so-slightly-less-detailed opinion, if there's one thing that could give this long road a bit more gravitas, it might be a subtle rumbling from the very bottom of the sonic spectrum.
It's almost as if the bass, perhaps feeling the economic pinch described in the lyrics, decided to pack its bags and follow its own long road, heading off to find a new gig. It's there, holding down the fort, but a touch more "oomph" in the low-end EQ could give the whole arrangement a bit more of that earthy, grounded feel, like the mountains themselves settling in for a long, quiet evening.
Thanks, I'll have another listen.

As you noted, the poor bass player is there, but he's literally standing in the back of the group in the virtual room.

Quote
It's a journey worth taking, and with its exhaustive (and highly entertaining) backstory, I felt like I've been on the ride with Mt David from concept to final mix.
That's a... metaphor all right! laugh

Thanks for listening, and your delightful comments!

-- David Cuny
My virtual singer development blog

Vocal control, you say. Never heard of it. Is that some kind of ProTools thing?