PG Music Home Forums PG Music Product Forums Band-in-a-Box for Windows Band in a Box 2025 stutters when I play MIDI [Resolved]

OK, I better understand what you are trying to do. However, my understanding is the BIAB has never done that. Over the years there have been discussion about using external sounds from accompaniment keyboards and it was concluded this did not work. Only midi-in from controller keyboards using the internal BIAB synths (not VSTis) with the thru box enabled (as Andrew said in his post) and as I have configured.
But if you say what you are trying to do did work in prior versions, and now does not work in current version I can only refer you to Andrew and the PGM team. Good luck. By the way I did look up the Clavinova and it looks way cool - but way more than my stiff fingers could play.

Hello Andrew,

Yes, with MIDI Thru enabled, I see the notes on the VIEWS/Bigpiano window (screenshot below) and the MIDI monitor records the MIDI notes : this time, 157 notes recorded before BiaB stutters (screenshots and data list below).

Indeed, if MIDI Thru is not enabled, and even when the MIDI Input Driver is enabled, I do not see the notes displayed on the BigPiano. But what is strange is that, even in this case, the notes played are recorded on the score (see the screenshots sent yesterday).

Do you see anything special in today's data list? For my part, I am surprised to see so many notes with a velocity of 0!

Screenshots




MIDI monitoring
Evt # Time (mS) Source Raw Status Chan Data 1 Data 2
1 3623 Ext 90 48 45 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 69
2 3648 Ext 90 41 36 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 54
3 3665 Ext 90 3D 35 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 53
4 3671 Ext 90 3C 2B Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 43
5 3673 Ext 90 39 21 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 33
6 4248 Ext 90 49 52 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 82
7 4318 Ext 90 48 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
8 4407 Ext 90 49 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
9 4560 Ext 90 4B 53 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 83
10 4681 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
11 4683 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
12 4689 Ext 90 39 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
13 4699 Ext 90 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
14 4715 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
15 4913 Ext 90 48 45 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 69
16 4981 Ext 90 41 21 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 33
17 5015 Ext 90 3D 23 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 35
18 5027 Ext 90 39 18 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 24
19 5027 Ext 90 3C 19 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 25
20 5743 Ext 90 48 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
21 5931 Ext 90 46 56 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 86
22 6025 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
23 6051 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
24 6058 Ext 90 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
25 6058 Ext 90 39 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
26 6079 Ext 90 46 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 0
27 6285 Ext 90 48 4F Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 79
28 6414 Ext 90 48 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
29 6476 Ext 90 49 52 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 82
30 6513 Ext 90 3F 30 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 48
31 6523 Ext 90 3A 31 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 49
32 6528 Ext 90 3B 2D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 45
33 6561 Ext 90 37 14 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = G 4 Velocity = 20
34 6761 Ext 90 49 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
35 6767 Ext 90 4B 4E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 78
36 7123 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
37 7145 Ext 90 46 51 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 81
38 7272 Ext 90 46 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 0
39 7405 Ext 90 44 27 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 39
40 7455 Ext 90 44 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
41 7549 Ext 90 3B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 0
42 7553 Ext 90 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
43 7559 Ext 90 37 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = G 4 Velocity = 0
44 7588 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
45 7735 Ext 90 3F 33 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 51
46 7735 Ext 90 43 42 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = G 5 Velocity = 66
47 7756 Ext 90 3B 33 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 51
48 7764 Ext 90 3A 30 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 48
49 7773 Ext 90 37 1B Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = G 4 Velocity = 27
50 8699 Ext 90 3B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 0
51 8706 Ext 90 43 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = G 5 Velocity = 0
52 8715 Ext 90 37 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = G 4 Velocity = 0
53 8743 Ext 90 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
54 8745 Ext 90 44 54 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 84
55 8756 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
56 8887 Ext 90 44 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
57 9115 Ext 90 46 4F Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 79
58 9201 Ext 90 46 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 0
59 9279 Ext 90 48 4C Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 76
60 9285 Ext 90 41 33 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 51
61 9295 Ext 90 39 24 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 36
62 9298 Ext 90 3C 27 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 39
63 9310 Ext 90 3D 2B Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 43
64 9615 Ext 90 49 4E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 78
65 9632 Ext 90 48 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
66 9765 Ext 90 49 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
67 9982 Ext 90 4B 52 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 82
68 10157 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
69 10200 Ext 90 4D 4C Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 76
70 10296 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
71 10302 Ext 90 39 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
72 10314 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
73 10324 Ext 90 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
74 10324 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
75 10545 Ext 90 50 56 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 86
76 10586 Ext 90 41 24 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 36
77 10597 Ext 90 39 1E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 30
78 10601 Ext 90 3D 2A Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 42
79 10618 Ext 90 3C 24 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 36
80 11015 Ext 90 50 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 0
81 11018 Ext 90 4D 4E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 78
82 11091 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
83 11135 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
84 11365 Ext 90 41 34 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 52
85 11387 Ext 90 50 58 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 88
86 11501 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
87 11545 Ext 90 50 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 0
88 11545 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
89 11555 Ext 90 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
90 11565 Ext 90 39 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
91 11583 Ext 90 52 59 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 6 Velocity = 89
92 11761 Ext 90 52 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 6 Velocity = 0
93 11968 Ext 90 52 63 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 6 Velocity = 99
94 12096 Ext 90 36 39 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 57
95 12125 Ext 90 3F 31 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 49
96 12137 Ext 90 3B 31 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 49
97 12143 Ext 90 3A 2E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 46
98 12547 Ext 90 52 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 6 Velocity = 0
99 12661 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
100 12802 Ext 90 50 5A Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 90
101 12814 Ext 90 3F 45 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 69
102 12952 Ext 90 50 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 0
103 13014 Ext 90 52 4E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 6 Velocity = 78
104 13068 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
105 13088 Ext 90 36 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 0
106 13144 Ext 90 50 4B Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 75
107 13144 Ext 90 52 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 6 Velocity = 0
108 13200 Ext 90 3B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 0
109 13245 Ext 90 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
110 13370 Ext 90 4E 46 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 6 Velocity = 70
111 13394 Ext 90 50 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 0
112 13504 Ext 90 3F 23 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 35
113 13504 Ext 90 35 21 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 4 Velocity = 33
114 13511 Ext 90 3A 20 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 32
115 13515 Ext 90 3B 25 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 37
116 13526 Ext 90 4D 4D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 77
117 13541 Ext 90 4E 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 6 Velocity = 0
118 14211 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
119 14424 Ext 90 4B 5C Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 92
120 14566 Ext 90 35 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 4 Velocity = 0
121 14575 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
122 14665 Ext 90 3B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 0
123 14677 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
124 14681 Ext 90 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
125 14727 Ext 90 4D 4E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 78
126 14824 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
127 14965 Ext 90 4E 52 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 6 Velocity = 82
128 14975 Ext 90 3B 35 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 53
129 14975 Ext 90 3F 28 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 40
130 14986 Ext 90 3A 2E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 46
131 14991 Ext 90 36 26 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 38
132 15241 Ext 90 4E 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 6 Velocity = 0
133 15256 Ext 90 50 4E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 78
134 15435 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
135 15476 Ext 90 4E 4D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 6 Velocity = 77
136 15508 Ext 90 50 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 0
137 15651 Ext 90 3F 2F Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 47
138 15746 Ext 90 4D 56 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 86
139 15754 Ext 90 4E 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 6 Velocity = 0
140 15916 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
141 15988 Ext 90 4B 51 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 81
142 16001 Ext 90 36 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 0
143 16036 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
144 16102 Ext 90 3B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 0
145 16151 Ext 90 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
146 16159 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
147 16215 Ext 90 4D 49 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 73
148 16402 Ext 90 3F 2D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 45
149 16410 Ext 90 3A 1D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 29
150 16411 Ext 90 35 20 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 4 Velocity = 32
151 16415 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
152 16415 Ext 90 4B 52 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 82
153 16419 Ext 90 3B 27 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 39
154 16671 Ext 90 49 46 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 70
155 16682 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
156 16796 Ext 90 49 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
157 16798 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
158 16886 Ext 90 4B 52 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 82
159 17063 Ext 90 3F 2B Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 43
160 17095 Ext 90 49 4E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 78
161 17131 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
162 17291 Ext 90 35 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 4 Velocity = 0
163 17414 Ext 90 49 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
164 17417 Ext 90 48 4E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 78
165 17434 Ext 90 3B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 0
166 17444 Ext 90 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
167 17454 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
168 17581 Ext 90 48 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
169 17774 Ext 90 49 52 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 82
170 17780 Ext 90 35 31 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 4 Velocity = 49
171 17803 Ext 90 3D 2A Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 42
172 17829 Ext 90 36 34 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 52
173 17896 Ext 90 3A 0E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 14
174 18206 Ext 90 49 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
175 18288 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
176 18318 Ext 90 46 4B Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 75
177 18481 Ext 90 3D 2D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 45
178 18488 Ext 90 46 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 0
179 18657 Ext 90 44 54 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 84
180 18710 Ext 90 35 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 4 Velocity = 0
181 18740 Ext 90 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
182 18776 Ext 90 36 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 0
183 18846 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
184 18858 Ext 90 44 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
185 19103 Ext 90 44 3D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 61
186 19127 Ext 90 34 26 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = E 4 Velocity = 38
187 19180 Ext 90 38 2D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 4 Velocity = 45
188 19206 Ext 90 3F 44 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 68
189 19214 Ext 90 3A 32 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 50
190 19227 Ext 90 46 4C Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 76
191 19233 Ext 90 44 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
192 20230 Ext 90 46 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 0
193 20254 Ext 90 44 57 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 87
194 20280 Ext 90 34 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = E 4 Velocity = 0
195 20284 Ext 90 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
196 20290 Ext 90 38 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 4 Velocity = 0
197 20411 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
198 20430 Ext 90 44 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
199 20594 Ext 90 36 3D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 61
200 20612 Ext 90 44 4D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 77
201 20612 Ext 90 3F 31 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 49
202 20628 Ext 90 45 4D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 5 Velocity = 77
203 20631 Ext 90 3C 35 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 53
204 20716 Ext 90 44 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
205 21051 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
206 21135 Ext 90 48 57 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 87
207 21213 Ext 90 45 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 5 Velocity = 0
208 21269 Ext 90 3F 37 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 55
209 21365 Ext 90 48 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
210 21416 Ext 90 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
211 21434 Ext 90 36 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 0
212 21470 Ext 90 4B 5A Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 90
213 21523 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
214 21618 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
215 21981 Ext 90 44 3D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 61
216 21984 Ext 90 50 59 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 89
217 21993 Ext 90 3F 3A Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 58
218 21997 Ext 90 39 25 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 37
219 22005 Ext 90 3D 33 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 51
220 22264 Ext 90 4E 52 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 6 Velocity = 82
221 22290 Ext 90 50 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 6 Velocity = 0
222 22406 Ext 90 44 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
223 22449 Ext 90 4E 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 6 Velocity = 0
224 22575 Ext 90 4D 55 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 85
225 22610 Ext 90 44 37 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 55
226 22751 Ext 90 44 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
227 22830 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
228 22884 Ext 90 4B 4E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 78
229 22906 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
230 22918 Ext 90 39 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
231 22946 Ext 90 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
232 23042 Ext 90 49 51 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 81
233 23048 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
234 23204 Ext 90 49 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
235 23418 Ext 90 41 36 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 54
236 23422 Ext 90 48 4C Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 76
237 23433 Ext 90 3D 30 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 48
238 23443 Ext 90 39 24 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 36
239 23452 Ext 90 3C 29 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 41
240 24242 Ext 90 48 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
241 24332 Ext 90 46 46 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 70
242 24449 Ext 90 46 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 0
243 24467 Ext 90 48 52 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 82
244 24518 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
245 24544 Ext 90 39 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
246 24562 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
247 24586 Ext 90 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
248 24647 Ext 90 46 50 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 80
249 24678 Ext 90 48 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
250 24816 Ext 90 41 26 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 38
251 24818 Ext 90 3D 2A Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 42
252 24824 Ext 90 39 1F Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 31
253 24834 Ext 90 3C 21 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 33
254 25535 Ext 90 46 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 0
255 25826 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
256 25838 Ext 90 48 3C Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 60
257 25856 Ext 90 39 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
258 25888 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
259 25928 Ext 90 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
260 26048 Ext 90 49 3C Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 60
261 26088 Ext 90 48 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
262 26098 Ext 90 49 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
263 26228 Ext 90 3D 23 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 35
264 26236 Ext 90 41 22 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 34
265 26258 Ext 90 39 1F Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 31
266 26258 Ext 90 4D 39 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 57
267 26271 Ext 90 3C 1C Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 28
268 26364 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
269 26611 Ext 90 4D 48 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 72
270 26702 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
271 26731 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
272 26906 Ext 90 41 30 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 48
273 26960 Ext 90 4D 4A Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 74
274 27096 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
275 27188 Ext 90 4B 3C Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 60
276 27220 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
277 27276 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
278 27294 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
279 27308 Ext 90 39 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
280 27325 Ext 90 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
281 27516 Ext 90 4D 34 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 52
282 27676 Ext 90 41 20 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 32
283 27679 Ext 90 39 22 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 34
284 27688 Ext 90 3D 23 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 35
285 27696 Ext 90 3C 1E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 30
286 28454 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
287 28606 Ext 90 4B 5D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 93
288 28618 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
289 28630 Ext 90 39 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
290 28642 Ext 90 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
291 28650 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
292 28732 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
293 28916 Ext 90 4D 54 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 84
294 29034 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
295 29094 Ext 90 36 36 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 54
296 29124 Ext 90 4B 4A Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 74
297 29132 Ext 90 3B 2F Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 47
298 29135 Ext 90 3F 22 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 34
299 29140 Ext 90 3A 25 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 37
300 29220 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
301 29473 Ext 90 4B 4E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 78
302 29556 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
303 29794 Ext 90 4B 50 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 80
304 29925 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
305 30002 Ext 90 49 4B Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 75
306 30106 Ext 90 49 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
307 30269 Ext 90 36 0E Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 14
308 30292 Ext 90 4B 4F Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 79
309 31206 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
310 31331 Ext 90 3B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 0
311 31346 Ext 90 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
312 31385 Ext 90 36 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 0
313 31482 Ext 90 49 50 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 80
314 31620 Ext 90 49 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
315 31718 Ext 90 4B 38 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 56
316 31824 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
317 31891 Ext 90 39 22 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 34
318 31898 Ext 90 41 24 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 36
319 31904 Ext 90 4D 45 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 69
320 31904 Ext 90 3C 2D Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 45
321 31914 Ext 90 3D 31 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 49
322 32042 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
323 32227 Ext 90 4D 4F Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 79
324 32339 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
325 32608 Ext 90 4D 56 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 86
326 32788 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
327 32840 Ext 90 4B 43 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 67
328 32929 Ext 90 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
329 32960 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
330 32960 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
331 32971 Ext 90 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
332 32991 Ext 90 39 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
333 33121 Ext 90 39 36 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 54
334 33136 Ext 90 3D 41 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 65
335 33136 Ext 90 41 47 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 71
336 33138 Ext 90 4D 55 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 85
337 33148 Ext 90 3C 33 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 51
338 33320 Ext 90 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
339 33334 Ext 90 41 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
340 33340 Ext 90 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
341 33347 Ext 90 39 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
342 33350 Ext 90 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 1 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0

Sorry, one more quick "note". Would it be possible for you to do a screen capture or video of your efforts? I think a number of folks would enjoy seeing the Clavinova in action with BIAB and it may help Andrew with his troubleshooting.

Hello again Andrew,

I started the experiment again but this time with Band in a Box 2020 by launching it directly from the hard drive on which it was delivered to me 5 years ago.

Well, no problem: I was able to record a complete chorus without Band in a Box stuttering and/or stopping (503 notes recorded in MIDI before the next chorus that I had programmed to be played by a RealTrack).

I am sending you below the screenshots and an extract of the MIDI monitoring data list (apparently the forum do not accept sending the entiree list)

I conclude that the problem comes from Band in a Box 2025: either the version I received on my disk is corrupted (two files were already missing), or the MIDI management by Band in a Box 2025 is not identical to that of previous versions and is no longer compatible with my Clavinova CVP 307, or ... I don't know :-)!

PS: Is there a solution to send a txt or pdf file as an attachment rather than pasting several hundred lines in the body of the message?

Screenshots




MIDI monitoring
Evt # Time (mS) Source Raw Status Chan Data 1 Data 2
1 3090 Ext 94 41 64 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 100
2 3111 Ext 94 48 4C Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 76
3 3116 Ext 94 4D 58 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 88
4 3129 Ext 94 3D 4B Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 75
5 3129 Ext 94 39 45 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 69
6 3137 Ext 94 3C 42 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 66
7 3250 Ext 94 3D 38 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 56
8 3999 Ext 94 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
9 4064 Ext 94 4B 5B Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 91
10 4159 Ext 94 48 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
11 4201 Ext 94 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
12 4214 Ext 94 41 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
13 4340 Ext 94 48 5E Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 94
14 4353 Ext 94 4D 60 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 96
15 4360 Ext 94 41 54 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 84
16 4371 Ext 94 39 3C Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 60
17 4394 Ext 94 3C 3E Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 62
18 4402 Ext 94 3D 41 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 65
19 5310 Ext 94 41 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
20 5322 Ext 94 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
21 5331 Ext 94 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
22 5369 Ext 94 39 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
23 5380 Ext 94 48 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
24 5440 Ext 94 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
25 5886 Ext 94 37 44 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = G 4 Velocity = 68
26 5888 Ext 94 3F 5B Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 91
27 5890 Ext 94 4B 67 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 103
28 5910 Ext 94 3B 4F Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 79
29 5916 Ext 94 3A 4D Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 77
30 6810 Ext 94 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
31 6858 Ext 94 49 63 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 99
32 6930 Ext 94 3B 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 0
33 6933 Ext 94 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
34 6941 Ext 94 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
35 6956 Ext 94 37 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = G 4 Velocity = 0
36 7081 Ext 94 49 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
37 7098 Ext 94 3F 4F Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 79
38 7108 Ext 94 4B 59 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 89
39 7108 Ext 94 37 37 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = G 4 Velocity = 55
40 7110 Ext 94 47 50 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = B 5 Velocity = 80
41 7113 Ext 94 3B 50 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 80
42 7118 Ext 94 3A 4A Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 74
43 7952 Ext 94 47 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = B 5 Velocity = 0
44 8278 Ext 94 37 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = G 4 Velocity = 0
45 8287 Ext 94 3B 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 0
46 8308 Ext 94 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
47 8326 Ext 94 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
48 8507 Ext 94 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
49 8681 Ext 94 4D 59 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 89
50 8697 Ext 94 48 4C Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 76
51 8697 Ext 94 41 4F Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 79
52 8700 Ext 94 3C 4B Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 75
53 8705 Ext 94 3D 5B Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 91
54 8707 Ext 94 39 45 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 69
55 9586 Ext 94 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
56 9694 Ext 94 4B 60 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 96
57 9733 Ext 94 48 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
58 9754 Ext 94 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
59 9773 Ext 94 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
60 9777 Ext 94 41 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
61 9780 Ext 94 39 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
62 9988 Ext 94 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
63 10064 Ext 94 41 40 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 64
64 10079 Ext 94 4D 58 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 88
65 10079 Ext 94 3D 4B Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 75
66 10087 Ext 94 39 3F Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 63
67 10087 Ext 94 3C 45 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 69
68 10093 Ext 94 48 4F Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 79
69 10277 Ext 94 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
70 10475 Ext 94 48 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
71 10486 Ext 94 41 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
72 10500 Ext 94 39 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
73 10505 Ext 94 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
74 10514 Ext 94 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
75 10601 Ext 94 52 63 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 6 Velocity = 99
76 10605 Ext 94 48 53 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 83
77 10628 Ext 94 39 40 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 64
78 10632 Ext 94 41 47 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 71
79 10660 Ext 94 3C 41 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 65
80 10670 Ext 94 3D 45 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 69
81 10724 Ext 94 52 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 6 Velocity = 0
82 10734 Ext 94 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
83 10775 Ext 94 41 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
84 10784 Ext 94 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
85 10788 Ext 94 39 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
86 10830 Ext 94 48 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
87 10976 Ext 94 41 47 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 71
88 10978 Ext 94 48 58 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 88
89 10985 Ext 94 4D 69 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 105
90 10989 Ext 94 3C 4D Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 77
91 10990 Ext 94 3D 4F Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 79
92 11036 Ext 94 41 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
93 11036 Ext 94 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
94 11044 Ext 94 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
95 11058 Ext 94 4D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 6 Velocity = 0
96 11061 Ext 94 48 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
97 11490 Ext 94 4B 56 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 86
98 11498 Ext 94 3A 4D Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 77
99 11500 Ext 94 3F 44 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 68
100 11504 Ext 94 47 43 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = B 5 Velocity = 67
....
900 84829 Ext 94 42 6C Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Gb 5 Velocity = 108
901 84849 Ext 94 44 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
902 84989 Ext 94 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
903 85057 Ext 94 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
904 85061 Ext 94 3B 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = B 4 Velocity = 0
905 85098 Ext 94 42 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Gb 5 Velocity = 0
906 85211 Ext 94 41 69 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 105
907 85232 Ext 94 35 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 4 Velocity = 0
908 85553 Ext 94 35 3B Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 4 Velocity = 59
909 85557 Ext 94 3A 51 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 81
910 85568 Ext 94 36 4C Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 76
911 85572 Ext 94 44 70 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 112
912 85577 Ext 94 3D 45 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 69
913 85604 Ext 94 41 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
914 86016 Ext 94 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
915 86098 Ext 94 42 76 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Gb 5 Velocity = 118
916 86119 Ext 94 44 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
917 86250 Ext 94 3D 54 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 84
918 86460 Ext 94 41 78 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 120
919 86466 Ext 94 42 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Gb 5 Velocity = 0
920 86505 Ext 94 36 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 0
921 86513 Ext 94 35 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 4 Velocity = 0
922 86595 Ext 94 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
923 86810 Ext 94 34 5C Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = E 4 Velocity = 92
924 86890 Ext 94 41 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
925 86939 Ext 94 3A 3A Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 58
926 86943 Ext 94 38 4A Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Ab 4 Velocity = 74
927 86971 Ext 94 46 76 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 118
928 86981 Ext 94 3F 5E Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 94
929 87838 Ext 94 46 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 0
930 87865 Ext 94 34 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = E 4 Velocity = 0
931 87956 Ext 94 44 78 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 120
932 87975 Ext 94 38 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Ab 4 Velocity = 0
933 87981 Ext 94 3A 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 4 Velocity = 0
934 88410 Ext 94 36 58 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 88
935 88439 Ext 94 3C 55 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 85
936 88442 Ext 94 3F 58 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 88
937 88446 Ext 94 4B 78 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 120
938 88866 Ext 94 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
939 88977 Ext 94 49 75 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 117
940 88993 Ext 94 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
941 89110 Ext 94 3F 55 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 85
942 89320 Ext 94 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
943 89332 Ext 94 49 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
944 89335 Ext 94 48 71 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 113
945 89370 Ext 94 36 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Gb 4 Velocity = 0
946 89426 Ext 94 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
947 89722 Ext 94 48 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
948 89806 Ext 94 4B 71 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 113
949 89815 Ext 94 44 59 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 89
950 89827 Ext 94 39 43 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 67
951 89833 Ext 94 3F 53 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 83
952 89839 Ext 94 3D 50 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 80
953 90299 Ext 94 44 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
954 90350 Ext 94 49 72 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 114
955 90388 Ext 94 4B 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 6 Velocity = 0
956 90452 Ext 94 44 52 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 82
957 90613 Ext 94 44 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Ab 5 Velocity = 0
958 90829 Ext 94 49 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 6 Velocity = 0
959 90836 Ext 94 39 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
960 90836 Ext 94 48 6C Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 108
961 90846 Ext 94 3F 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Eb 5 Velocity = 0
962 90881 Ext 94 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
963 91094 Ext 94 48 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
964 91211 Ext 94 48 6B Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 107
965 91221 Ext 94 41 4F Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 79
966 91237 Ext 94 3D 53 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 83
967 91244 Ext 94 39 42 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 66
968 91248 Ext 94 3C 4A Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 74
969 91681 Ext 94 41 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
970 91791 Ext 94 46 72 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 114
971 91871 Ext 94 48 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
972 91900 Ext 94 41 50 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 80
973 92015 Ext 94 46 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 0
974 92138 Ext 94 48 74 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 116
975 92230 Ext 94 41 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
976 92311 Ext 94 39 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
977 92335 Ext 94 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
978 92346 Ext 94 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
979 92363 Ext 94 48 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 6 Velocity = 0
980 92642 Ext 94 3D 4E Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 78
981 92646 Ext 94 46 68 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 104
982 92646 Ext 94 41 47 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 71
983 92659 Ext 94 39 43 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 67
984 92663 Ext 94 3C 45 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 69
985 93814 Ext 94 39 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = A 4 Velocity = 0
986 93831 Ext 94 41 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = F 5 Velocity = 0
987 93845 Ext 94 3C 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = C 5 Velocity = 0
988 93864 Ext 94 3D 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Db 5 Velocity = 0
989 93866 Ext 94 46 00 Note On ($9x) 5 Pitch = Bb 5 Velocity = 0

Unfortunately, no. Only image files are allowed.
As a workaround, you can upload other file types to a file sharing service such as Drop Box, and then attach the link to your post.

This is a good idea: it would allow to understand exactly what is happening to me.

As I don't know how to make a dynamic screenshots capture, I will try to make a video with my smartphone. But how to send a video on this forum?

You need to upload the video file from you phone to an online hosting application. There are several free good options for that. I recommend:

https://workspace.google.com/products/drive/

It is free, you just need to create an account with your email and signin. After that you will have a place to put any file which will allow you to "send" the file to anyone with a link. then you post the link here in the forum. Check it out

Thanks, AudioTrack
Yes, as I've got a Microsoft account with OneDrive, I could do that.
I'll think about it for next time :-)!

Here is the link to a short video where one understands well what is happening: here, Band in a Box 2025 stopped just after a few seconds after I started playing, resumed, then stopped again...:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1s7gT41Otr7lpMetxorr7xGTv0ysQg_B2/view?usp=sharing

You have sent the link, "...with security turned on".

You are almost there. You need to adjust security so the anyone with link can open it.

I'm not familiar with google Drive!

Here is a new link:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1s7gT41Otr7lpMetxorr7xGTv0ysQg_B2/view?usp=sharing

Can you see the video now?

Yes I can see it now. Good job getting this done and to us. It was not what I expected, but may have been what you been trying to explain all along. A picture is worth a 1000 words. I had already concluded I would not be able to help you, and this video does not change my conclusion. That is some messed up stuff going on with BIAB and your piano. BIAB is simply falling apart as it tries to play the chord backing. I have never heard that from the box. Hopefully, Andrew has some idea.

Thanks for the link. I also had interpreted incorrectly. I was originally under the impression (incorrectly) that the MIDI was what was doing the stuttering.

Q1:
I'm presuming that the song plays OK as long as you don't play anything on your keyboard. Is that correct?

Q2:
Have you tried a "Return To Factory Settings - ALL", from the Options menu? (I can't recall above if that's been suggested). You would have to then reset some values.

After viewing the video, I'm not surprised to see the error code 121 timeout error.
Hopefully, Andrew can provide some insight & make some suggestions.

A couple of questions;

1) How old is the computer processor and

2) How many background tasks are running when the stuttering occurs.

Don't forget that 2025 requires more get up and go than the 2020 version.

Keith

Hello AudioTrack

Q1: Yes, everything works perfectly as long as I don't play when MIDI Input Driver is enabled (if MIDI Input Driver is disabled, I can play normally with Band-in-box accompaniment, but obviously I can't record myself in MIDI)

Q2: Thanks for this idea. I will try asap and come back with the results.

Hello Keith,

1. Currently, I am testing Band in a box 2025 with my HP 22 c0020nf desktop computer that I bought in November 2018: it is therefore a little over 6 years old (*). The processor is an Intel(R) Core(TM) i3-8130U CPU @ 2.20GHz 2.21 GHz.
My Dell XPS 18 (1820) computer dedicated to music is older: I bought it in December 2014. It is on this one that I first encountered the BiaB 2025 stuttering problem. It is currently at a professional who must install a faster SSD drive and increase the RAM from 8 to 12 GB (maybe 16 GB if this computer which is extra flat does not heat up too much). Indeed, I quickly thought that Band in a Box 2025 might require a lot more capacity than Band in a Box 2020. However, the requirements indicated by PG Music are much lower: https://www.pgmusic.com/bbwin.requirements.htm

2. In general, when I run Band in a Box, I don't have any other foreground applications open (except sometimes Google Chrome with Youtube and MuseScore). But if you're talking about background applications, there are dozens that appear on the task manager! Unfortunately, I don't have the skills to analyze them.

LB...

i use 2 pc's ...one for music creation and another cheapy for the net.
i will NEVER use a music production pc for the net as such net tasks can interrupt the production process. (see my tips in pg tips forum to save me typing 10 pages of tips please.)

and i dont want to get into a debate on this with other users who might have other views. in summary ive seen too many issues over the years with pc's
that are running loads of apps like the net that are always active while music creation tasks are occurring...thus leading to stutters and glitches.

LB...if your music pc has never been optimised for music activities see my tips on such in pg tips forum....and particularly first step RUN LATENCY MON which will assess whether a pc is suitable for music activities.
(report back what LMon says...all in green ? etc etc.)
the biggest problem ive seen over the years resolving peoples pc probs re music is useing a pc not properly optimised for music activities and thats running loads of apps other than music apps.

have you tried other daws ?? eg bandlab ? or pg;'s own realband thats included with bb ?? do you get midi problems in those ?
just an idea.

PS...here is the review of your i3 processor.

https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu.php?cpu=Intel+Core+i3-8130U+%40+2.20GHz

its single thread score is under what i would recommend.

hth....and happiness.

om

FYI - My off-line music computer is 14 years old. The only time it is on-line is for updates and/or registration. When I record in my DAW I disable my Ethernet card and everything running in the background like anti-virus, anti-malware, VPN, etc. I have no problem recording.

You're right, Old Muso: that's why I have a computer dedicated to music, a Dell XPS 18 (1820) with an i7 processor and a desktop computer, an HP 22 c0020nf with an i3 processor.

But, as I told Keith, if I'm currently using my HP to test Band in a Box 2025, it's because my Dell is at a professional to upgrade its RAM from 8 to 12 GB (maybe 16 GB, if it doesn't heat up too much) and install a faster SSD.

That being said, it's on my Dell with the i7 processor that I started running and discovered the stuttering problem of Band in a Box 2025. So it's not because of the i3 that Band in a box doesn't work properly.

I will know in a few days if the improvement of the specifications of my Dell makes disappear the problem that I am currently having with Band in box 2025.

If it works, it will be very good, but I will then suggest to PG Music to substantially modify their system requirements page :-) !

If it does not work, I will continue to look for the problem in the 2025 version of Band in a Box.

Because for 10 years, Band in a Box 2010, 2015 and 2020 have run without problem on my Dell, and today it is only Band in a Box 2025 that does not run correctly on this computer.

And I do not really want to drastically change my installation and/or my work habits just for a new version of software ...