Quote:

Some new tunes my laptop did



Quote:

Dude, you vox are missing in these songs. All I hear is the Band-in-a-Box backing tracks.



I’m gonna take a WAG, (wild a**ed guess), at this one regarding the topic and the “songs” posted.

Anyone with a computer with BIAB on it can plug in a chord progression, pick a style and tempo, stick a name on it, and click “play” and call it a “song”.

But is it a “song”? Or is it just a computer generated response to a non-musical manual input?

If the original poster, (aka, author), doesn’t play any instrumental solos on the “song”, haven't written a melody to the "song", and they haven’t written any lyrics to the “song”, have they actually “written” anything? The simple answer is “No”. A chord progression typed in to produce a computer generated response isn’t a “song”.

You could just as easily say BIAB wrote it, or that the “laptop did”. Either one would be more correct than saying you wrote it.

Is that the point of the post?

Bob
................................
http://soundcloud.com/bobcflatpicke/music-in-the-mountains