Quote:

There are 2 issues as I see it:

1. Some people are saying that embellishments are OK, but not when they are musicially incorrect (such as a natural 13th on the V7 in a minor key, or a #4 on a major 1 chord).
This I agree with, and we will work on improving that. So that's like a bug in the program.

2. Others are saying that the chords should never be embellished, if it says C7, then the players should only play chord tones C,E,G, Bb. I don't agree there, since that's not how musicians play. For that, we can make "simple variations" that will play close to what is wanted, but it helps if you can identify styles (realTracks) that are in need of simple variations.



Peter, agreed about (1) above.

About (2), there's a contradiction. Why would I want to type in C7 and have BB playing back anything else other than C,E,G,Bb ? I want C7, I don't want anything else in there. The only unobtrusive embellishments that would work, would be passing notes in between the chord tones, but really, it doesn't even make musical sense. If the BB plays all these options, then what's left for the melody to play? If more than one instrument plays passing notes, the effect of these notes will diminish, unless the user is Bach. If one instrument plays passing notes, another instrument should have longer notes....these are basic arranging guidelines. So the options played back will limit, not enhance, my choices.

But the main problem with BB is that it either plays some unwanted altered notes (sharp 4ths on maj7 chords with all options ticked off etc), or it will play some notes that are not in the key. These are the two main problems as I have experienced them.

But these aren't the only problem. A few days ago I was using a rock realtrack and the guitar arpeggios had an add9 that I could not get rid of. I wanted a minor chord, not an minor chord with a 9th on top, because that note only changed the whole mood of what I wanted to write.

BB it's a great program and I have used it for at least 5 years, but I really hope that we as users will have a lot more control on how BB plays back the chords.

PS. I think that a video tutorial of the Stylemaker and how to edit the style to root out these weird notes, should be available.