Buying a top-of-the-line table saw does not make you a carpenter; but a good carpenter is more likely to envy your expensive table saw than he would an inferior model

The power of any tool is that it gives the craftsman an advantage (speed, precision, power, flexibility) that he would not have without the tool. Tools don't provide expertise, but a good tool DOES provide the ability to use expertise more efficiently.

Although music making software enables you to quickly assemble components of a song, a person who knows something about music, computers, equipment, interfaces, MIDI, Continuous controllers, soft synths, hard synths, chords etc etc, it is going to get different results than somebody who doesn't.

Observation #4
when bad results come from a good tool, it speaks more of the person using the tool than it does of the tool.