Noel96: Sure... but I don't want to get this into a "philosophical discussion". Lets stick to the practical.

Fact: Right now playing melody's and other "written parts" in BIAB, *MUST* be done by MIDI - so... do you want to do this with a sample that came from the instrument used in the Real Tracks phrases - recorded through the same mic, EQ, room ambience, etc. - OR - do you want it from some completely unrelated sample instrument? I don't want to spend hours searching for a match of nylon string guitar that sounds "close" - when I can have the exact same instrument. I don't understand what the argument against this could be...

And listen ...philosophical discussion aside: there is plenty of power in MIDI (controllers, polyphonic expression, etc.) in the hands of a good player OR programmer... I have fooled plenty of *professional* musicians into thinking a MIDI part was played by a human. And this on a recording that can be played over and over. For a live gig, its no problem...

Last edited by rap; 11/28/11 09:27 AM.