toucher and John, I managed to get it to work. I tried the tech chat and couldn't figured it out. They told me to reinstall it, which I had already done. Turns out, I should have done it then.

Here's what I did: After installing, reinstalling, uninstalling, and reinstalling again, I then looked for a BIAB update. Turns out, there was a build 265 (the last one for 2008.5). I did that, but it still didn't work. Called tech support. Then, I tried installing it again and...IT WORKED!!!!

Of course, now I'm wondering if buying another set will cause the same problem. I'm awfully curious, so I guess I'll just have to buy another and find out!