Without turning this into a philosophical or Religious discussion I just do not believe that anyone can do anything if they put the time and effort.There are other factors involved.JMHO
Good point, like having talent and more often than not the people with the talent will make it. For the record I don't believe I have any great talent, just some creative thinking now and again.
Though I find biab great software and I can make a passable recording with it, it is no substitution for good musicians.
Its the question and answer concept I believe that is missing for example a vocalist may sing a line (the question) and it is answered by a lead guitar riff (answer) more often than not missing in software like biab, or else you work for hours trying to get something that fits the part reasonably well, but it sure drains your emotions doing so.
I believe even in the rhytm sections this concept still applies.
musiclover