Joe V's recent post re: ear protection brought this age old (for me anyway) question to mind. In fact lets just say, for some anyway, why does any musician feel any music has to be performed "loud" to be good?

I could never understand why a musician and/or band feels they have to "crank it up" to eardrum shattering volumes for it to be "good". After all when I play it back, no matter what genre I am listening to I set my volume slider on my home stereo to the same comfortable level.

Just FYI don't tell me it's an age thing as even when I was a pup I felt I could not enjoy music at high volumes. I am just thinking some of you loud rockers out there might be able to help me understand the "man it's rock it has to be loud" syndrome?

PS: Rharv, sit tight I'll be getting off of your lawn as soon as I get some feedback! :>

Thanks,