I put in this request before but I thought I would do it again to make sure someone at PG Music sees it, I hope.

The issue is with transposing instrments. Today, I wanted to enter a simple blues pattern. I went to Options>Preferences>Notatiomn amd in tnhe transpose square I selected Tenor Sax.

The C chord on the screen, the one that a new song starts with changed to a D. When I started BiaB and played a D on my Sax it matched the D on the screen and all was well. So now I want gto enter the 4th chord in my progression, a G, but it shows up as an A chord on the screen. So now I see that I cannot write a progression without transposing.

It seems to me that BiaB could do a better job of making this problem easier.

The idea would be to keep transposing the actual pitches, i.e. the true frequency of the notes, seperate from what is displayed on the screen. There should be a frequency transpose option, as well as a display transpose option.

Lets start with me being a piano player and I entered a blues progression C,F,G in a new song window. If I played the song, it would match a regular piano playing C,F, and G. Now, If I selected a "display transpose" of 2 semitones, then the display would show D,G,A. Now if I played D,G,A on my Sax, a Bb insttrument, it would be in tune with the piano playing C,F,G.

Now, if I entered a Em on my screen, it should show Em, and if I played a Em on my Sax, all would be well. If I then changed the "display transpose" back to 0 semitones, the display would show C,F,G,D as expected.

Now, If I wanted to do a frequency or tone transpose, by say 4 semitones, the piano part would show E,A,B,F# and the pitch would change. Now if I went and selected "display transpose" to 2 semitones, the display would now show F#,B,C#,G# and I could then play my Sax to the music.

It seems to me that this wojuld be a relatively easy thing to do and it would certainly make us plauyers with transposing instruments happier. I also play an Alto Sax (Eb instrument) so haveing better transposing and disp;laying options would be great.

Also, as an aside, I have never used the two piano keyboard displays and wonder what their value really is.

I will be looking for a response.

hamilc