Quote:
I do read and listen to some of the songs. Usually I feel as its the same people who post songs that they have got so familiar with each other, that they are afraid to give an honest assessment, and words like, Wow what a performance, a keeper for sure, professional all round, another masterpiece, You have surpassed yourself this time, constantly patting each other on the back.

Nothing wrong in that, we all like to get our ego boosted, and to be encouraged, but maybe not the best way to get a true assessment of a song.


this is a true observation, but it's worth pointing out that the user showcase is first and foremost a showcase for the products made by PGMusic, and its function is to make visitors want what the people posting songs have.

If criticism abounded here (as it does on many song writing forums) then it would create a negative impression in the minds of many potential customers, and that would do a disservice to the good people at PGMusic, and to their products.


There are plenty of song writing forums where people who want honest critique can get it. Many of the people who post songs here also post in those forums, so they aren't looking for pats on the back.. they love to write songs and share them

Plus, over time, people who share a passion and an involvement in any community (even online forums) tend to become friends. Therefore, they respond as to friends.

Having talked about this very thing with many of the people who post on the showcase, it is my belief that people only say what they truly believe. They may filter out the negative stuff for the sake of kindness... but whatever they DO say is sincere.

https://www.dropbox.com/sh/ey71h8ep047758h/AAC12jNM0Hz9Q8zsh5iDeqNHa?dl=0