Interesting thread.
A long time ago when I first posted a song here, under a different user name, I got these comments. One person still comments on this site. But I will never say who it was and I can't remember the song

"By all means. It's poorly played, out of time, and sounds like someone cutting down trees in a windtunnel. If you like it, keep it. That way you'll never learn the right way. Great."

"Is there construction going on behind you when you sang this? The percussion sound is odd. I thought I made out a nail gun and someone falling off a scaffold in the background."

I kept these comments just to remind me of the nice people on here. One of whom posted this:

"Has an Imagine-era John Lennon flavor to it. The part-time voice doubling is a nice touch, too. Smooth out the production and work on a couple of notes, otherwise very nice. Good song." NOW that is good advice and something to work on, which I did and still do.

Anyway,

Alyn

My showcase songs

My story