It depends on who's listening, and what the context is. If you've got vocals, that's really what your listener is going to pay attention to.

In terms of feel, MIDI tracks works better here. For bass, drums and strings, the MIDI instruments are fine. But the MIDI guitar sounds cheesy to my ears. I'd be really tempted to replace it with another instrument, like an electric piano (as in the RT version).

I've got some nice sampled MIDI guitars. If you're interested, you could send me the MIDI file and I could render it using those so you could decide if there's a real difference. (I'll send you a PM of my email address).


-- David Cuny
My virtual singer development blog

Vocal control, you say. Never heard of it. Is that some kind of ProTools thing?