Originally Posted By: jannesan
I prefer indie movies over blockbusters with massive effects and the almost nonexistent story told too many times. Your music is like an indie movie, maybe bit uncomfortable at first, but on a closer look, an new adventure opens in another world with simple but intriguing textures of life.

This is the best I have heard from you, beautiful melody and very interesting chording, especially the chorus is something angel-like. This should be on the top of all charts, but at least it is now the on my chart smile

and the selection of instruments is great, the piano and pedal steel are used pefectly to create interest in the sparse arrangement. Are those listed RTs all you have used, I can hear at least some vocal aahs. Your voice and harmonies are very emotional.

The lyrics are very descriptive, haunting, mysterious and touching at the same time, "making hard truth and lies easier to bear" - very strong poetry.

Thank you Robert for this musical journey!

Janne



Janne,
Your comments about the "Indie" quality of my music is one to treasure- the unblockbuster genre I`m in never felt so well supported!
I appreciate your comments on the chorus chords too- the last and most difficult part of the song to get sorted.
Yes, there are some oohs/aahs in there & missed on the RT list.
A most gracious and thoughtful review-thank you.





Originally Posted By: PeterF
Robert

A lovely ballad and one of your best vocals - really liked the harmony. Nice backing and evocative lyrics.

Really well done.

Peter


Thank you, Peter!


Originally Posted By: animarorecords
Robert,

Another fragile beauty, as rayc said.
And I agree with Peter.
A lovely ballad and one of your best vocals - really liked the harmony. Nice backing and evocative lyrics.
It starts with a melody resembling Bob Dylan's “Blowin' in the Wind”, but the subsequent developments are completely different, and it has a very sophisticated finish.
Enjoyed my listen a lot.

Best regards.

Shigeki Adachi



Shigeki,
That`s interesting -I guess you`re right about the opening bars of the melody.
This `ol folkie will take a comment of "sophisticated" from one of the most musically subtle contributors to this forum anyday!
Thank you for listening and commenting.

Originally Posted By: Rob4580
Hi Rob. I found this to work very well.Its typical of your whimsical style.
As usual your eclectic lyrics draw the listener in.
Great tune thanks for posting. Rob4580


Thanks for that, Rob.

Originally Posted By: floyd jane
Robert,

A beautiful song.

A wonderful production. A very intimate sound and a vocal to match.

So nice.

fj


Floyd,
I appreciate those positive comments.

Robert