Tony:

I sympathize with your plight.
Probably like everyone, I started out with a small binder, kept adding pages and getting bigger binders until my 3-1/2 inch D-ring was full, songs printed on both sides of the page.

Some time ago I had had enough and decided to go digital.
I took each song and re-did it to fit a Windows tablet format (portrait mode, touch screen).

I set it all up with hyper links to an alphabetized index and I can now get to any of my 800 plus songs with a few finger pokes.

No more binders!
Yay!

Good luck.
LLOYD