Originally Posted By: Mark Hayes
Originally Posted By: Henry Clarke
Originally Posted By: jptjptjpt
I have no idea about music theory other than the basics.


Me either !! I do know one thing. Most music is not science. It's feel. You can study all the courses, theory, and all that stuff and still struggle if you don't feel it. I always relate a lot of music to the gospel an baptist church people. They don't know crap about structure and have the best keyboardist/organist, drummer and man the vocalists are unreal. They go with the flow :-)


Not knowing theory is fine, if that's the way you make music. Others make music in a more theory-based way, and that's fine, too. Not using theoretical principles does not make your music more authentic, or organic, or whatever. A prison work song is a prison work song, and a Baroque fugue is a Baroque fugue.

PS – I doubt most Baptist church music directors would agree that they "don't know crap about structure".


First of all I'm not anti music structure.. 2nd. I did not say "music Directors. I said musicians and vocalists. I'll just leave this right here. No need to go any further. Of course you can have the last word if you wish.