FWIW in certain situations I think the string squeaks are important, but some people say I think a lot of weird things smile

Example:
I have added samples of finger squeaks to a track that was *too clean* to make it sound more 'live', real, intimate, whatever your term is.
Done sparingly, the response from clients was usually positive.

"How'd you do that??" type comments
some trade secrets are better kept secrets, but I just gave one away I think

and yes, accepting/analyzing criticism is important for many reasons
especially when the criticisms are suggestions, not really criticizing. Much easier for the recipient to accept

this thread is a good example

I do not work here, but the benefits are still awesome
Make your sound your own!