@Noel and Matt. Thanks for suggestions and looking into it.

The Cb and E# thing makes sense to me, too. Even if, for the sake of using chord scales, Cb or E# would make sense. I know really good readers, like those working professional classical orchestras have no trouble reading double flats or sharps on top of -say- a key signature of Ab, but, for the ordinary musician, reading is already hard. And an F is an F and E# is is F. So, I dig that feature. Professional classical players will turn to Finale and Sibelius anyway.

To look up the history of it is a clever idea. Since 2022 has a lot of issues with midi style making or editing, I still use 2018 a lot. So, to my surprise, the Bb was written as a Bb and not A#. The wrong note in the example above (C# instead of Db, since we’re in a F, a key with one flat) was still there.

When I corrected it in editable notation in BB2018, it survived hitting play AND even closing Biab2018 and reopening it.. BB2018 has other issues, so I am not using it for practice let alone performance, but it handles forcing accidentals just fine.

So, there must be a mistake in saving forced accidentals that crept in after version 2018.


Biab, Kontakt, Sampletank and lots of nice libraries, from Fluffy audio to Abbey Road drums.
Check out these great contemporary Jazz Styles: www.jazzstylezz.com