They both are very good but we opt for version 2 as we are suckers for harmonies.

And we like those subtle harmonies also. Nothing wrong with the bit of texture they offer.
FWIW we enjoy harmony at duet/trio levels, BGV levels and hints hereof.
The guitar panning on the intro was cool as were all the guitar bits throughout.
And course your bass lines well carried the bottom end resting very nicely in the mix with the drums.
It's an evocative lyric and sadly we know folks who would fit right in.
Like fj we thought the mix sounded fine as is.
Enjoyed them!
J&B