rayc,

fair comment but, to be sure, many (I have not heard them all) of those other folk have not posted anything musically that asks me, "which tracks are BIAB, which are not?" as this one did. If a post here contains no trace of BIAB and was intentional, then it may be considered insincere.

I think the minimum "rule" hurdle here is that a song possess something from BIAB (we certainly don't want to micro-manage out those that don't follow every scintilla of the rules - it's uncreative, a waste of time, and could exclude many gems unfairly). Still, if one were to poll the more (than me) erudite members of the forum on which parts of this tune are BIAB, and which are not, then be would get many varied answers. Assuming this conclusion to be correct, then this may speak to how this song may stand apart from the other folks'. Or not.

My first submission contained several positive, negative (maybe harsh) and mixed comments, but I appreciated them all, certainly more than no feedback at all.

And I appreciate your feedback on my own comments to this, too. It allowed me to clarify some potential misunderstandings. Thank you, rayc.

Tom Marvan
dunbar7376

dunbar7376. [/quote]
I think that's a little harsh.
Several regular regular posters give minimal detail on their BIAB components. Occasionally folk give none. As this seems to be the 1st post from this person a little latitude might be considered an act of sincerity regarding an interest in posters abiding by "the rules".
I posted a song that I'd written with BIAB but the end result contained no RT/Midi etc.
If your interest/ negative attention was secured by way of the narrative of the song then your response might even be hypocritical or very selective at least. [/quote]

Tom Marvan
Dunbar7376
San Diego, CA

Band in A Box Audiophile 2025

MSI GE66 10SFS 15.6" Laptop (Model GE66048)
Intel Core i7 10th Gen i7-10750H 2.6ghz
32GB DDR4 RAM 2666mhz
8GB GDDR6 NVIDIA GeForce RTX 2070 SUPER
1920x1080 Full HD LED
2x1TB NVMe SSD PCI