- In Options | Preferences | Record Filter if you uncheck everything except for Notes does the error happen?
One of the things Andrew suggested was to filter out unneeded MIDI data. Your new keyboard might be sending a ton of system exclusive MIDI data that's not required.
You can find out just by recording the notes and then working your way back.
You can also use the midi monitor (Windows MIDI monitor) and see what data is showing up.
You can also change the midi configuration that's being outputted by your keyboard.