Quote
Chad,

I enjoyed listening to the first two songs, will have a listen to the rest later.

As Dcuny says could easily pass for well done pop music, and adds

Thanks. I had fun doing them...also frustration though. smile

Quote
"I think people who think these programs are "creative" fail to realize the massive amount of data that is used to train these programs"

I suppose in a sense songwriters are trained by listening to the songs that have gone before, so in a sense no big deal in that regard.

The copyright issue is a big thing though I agree.

Totally agree. Something will need to be figured out. Obviously not the same, but the whole "sampling" thing that went down had some similar issues that had to be sorted out. But those were directly using the artists work as it is.

Quote
I think what it will boil down to eventually is the general public will not care one iota, if its a good song, whether AI wrote it or a songwriter, and neither would I
.

I tend to be more in this camp as well. If I can hear great music or a great song, that's really what matters to me. I do understand where people would have issue though as well.

Quote
To be honest I just love this Technology, and I think the traditional way of putting a song together can happily co-exist with the AI way.

Completely agree. I'm excited for certain aspects of it, and wonder how certain questionable things will be addressed.

Quote
Anyway though biab is not AI (though at times it may seem it is employing some sort of basic AI) I think we shouldn't be complaining as users of biab that modern AI is going beyond our comfort zone.

As others have pointed out, these tools also are not true AI either. I personally believe that it's similar in concept to what people have been trying to accomplish with BIAB. Not in every case with every person obviously, but (just my take) if you can't play an instrument, or can't play it well enough that you are giving a program instructions on how to do it, then possibly generating multiple takes to get what you want...at the heart of it it seems similar not matter the method or program. I hope that made sense?

I appreciate the reply smile

Chad (Hope that makes it easier)

TEMPO TANTRUM: What a lead singer has when they can't stay in time.