Originally Posted by Bass Thumper
[quote=Cerio]
However, I encourage you to personally perform the very comparison work that you propose. I’ve given you a head start on this with a list of programs at the top of this thread. I’ve even given you a good “tuba test case” that you can use for part of your comparison work. I also encourage you to share your results and conclusions here on the forum. And if at the end of your study you find that your conclusions differ from mine, great. Learning something new is good.

My instincts rarely fail me and they are telling me that you will decline to do this work.
My hope is that you can prove my instincts wrong.

Yes you're right, I won't do that job, mainly because I don't really have time / need to, but also because my instincts (which rarely fail me either) are telling me the result of such an experiment wouldn't be too far from what I've just described above, for the reasons given above.

Having said that, I've also made some tests in the past comparing these kind of tools, here's just an example:


IMO, you can hear some differences between those three programs in that particular case, but as I said before, a test based in a single use case, while interesting and useful, is simply not enough to draw any serious conclusion about the quality in general of these tools.

Last edited by Cerio; 10/13/24 08:27 PM.
Latest BIAB version, latest build.