PG Music Home Forums PG Music Wishlists Band-in-a-Box Wishlist DAW Features In BiaB - Yes/No Why/Why Not

Hopefully you can resolve someone telling you how BIAB can do a process you've just discovered isn't a negative. If nothing else, it should help you to better develop your wish proposal. If I know BIAB can already do what you're proposing in the Wishlist, rest assured that PG Music staff also know it.

You are right to think that generations and regenerations of the midi data and RealTrack data generate simultaneously. The RT is a layer and the underlying midi data is a layer. Your proposal is to disable the RealTrack and toggle it back on so more editing can be done.
As you formulate your idea and refine how it can be done elegantly, you have figure how the disabled RealTrack can simultaneously generate along with the midi you edited. To work, both layers must be active.

As it is now, Tracks View is active full time. Piano Roll is active full time. Both are visible. Editing, generation and regenerations can be done from either window. Edits and regenerations update simultaneously.

The same as you, I have no idea if single track toggles can be done. I also have no idea why they would do it.

I hope you can see how someone sharing how BIAB already works can help you formulate better proposals rather than as something negative. I wasn't joking that I was unaware you've considered us in a six year dispute.

That you were unaware of underlying midi and its potential until recently when it's been there for decades should help you set negativity aside and not be so focused on what seems to be restrictive and limiting thinking to knowing and understanding advanced BIAB processes. There are many of them and all are as exciting and beneficial as underlying midi and audio on the same track.

A quick example is the benefit of using RT1152 for muting a RealTrack rather than (F5) Bar Settings to mute that same region.

Which do you think creates smoother transition? Which do you think will continue to create smooth transitions if the track is regenerated multiple times?

< Also, I am not sure why you mentioned Cakewalk. I just showed that you can drag BIAB's MIDI directly from track header to DAW, that was the purpose of demonstration. >

Which is exactly why I mentioned RealBand. It was a demonstration that it can do that exact same thing or you can actually do the entire process in RealBand. So I'm not sure why you saw it as a negative thing. I didn't consider your mention of Cakewalk as negative but rather went to YouTube and watched some videos about it.