Originally Posted by Cerio
I can only hear plastic music. Technically impressive, yes, but even a mediocre karaoke midi file from the 90s has more soul than that.

If you take the soul out of the music, there's nothing left.To me, this is just disrespectful to real music and real musicians, it's just sad.

It's only plastic if you use it and are inexperienced with music structure. Just inputing a few prompts and pressing a button is certainly going to produce something of lesser quality at least to some of our ears.But for others it can be a means of expressing something locked away in their minds that they otherwise couldn't release. I think we've lost touch about what creativity and expression are. We, also, often confuse creativity and expression with performance. Both sometimes require talent, especially the performance part. However a performer doesn't necessarily mean they are creative... they have maybe never written a song/score in their lives.

Expression on the other hand isn't about talent, it's about getting out what we are feeling and using whatever tools we have available to us to accomplish that. As a musician I understand this fundamental aspect.

I'm a musician (guitarist)/songwriter/producer and have played around with SUNO. It can be an impressive tool for musicians/songwriters if there were finer controls. However, it continues to evolve and every couple of weeks or so, they are adding tighter controls for users. What I like to do is record some riffs/melody, on guitar, upload it to SUNO and have it re-interpret my audio sample, then begin fleshing out a score around it. I then save as a WAV file and use OpenVINO (in Audacity) to seperate the stems. I can then bring the drum stem into Reaper and use Groove Agent to rebuild the drums (manually), then the bass lines and add any other instruments I want. Then I can record any guitars myself. I see AI, in the future, simply becoming like a word processor (as it is to writers), but for songwriters. Take a look at Ace Studio, it is impressive for AI vocals, giving very minute control to the producer and it is trained ethicly. Once those fine tuned controls are in place, songwriters (in the near future) will laugh at those of us who worked 2yrs on a song, never to get it the way we envisioned it, but they can produce the ideas locked away in their heads with absolute precision in a few hours or days!