This is an intriguing thread. It is possible in Suno Studio to take our BIAB tracks into the program and have Suno add parts, or even vocals. Which makes me speculate that Peter Gannon and company will have to figure out how much further BIAB can progress. For example, the stem splitter is helpful and very good quality but not a core tool for the majority of users.

The RT and RD concept was groundbreaking 20 years ago and it still astounds friends and musicians who watch me generate a song arrangement with just a few clicks. Who knows, perhaps PGMusic will license access to some AI music tool to "assist" us in creating a song AND then an arrangement. (I know, there has been a way to do that in BIAB for decades.) With AI in BIAB, we could type a prompt describing all that we want in an arrangement in much more detail than Suno, in terms of time signature, key, tempo, feel, genre, style, instruments we want, RT musicians we could request, and then have BIAB generate several versions. If you wanted to have it generate a song first, so be it. If it truly assists songwriting and arranging, you wouldn't have to scroll through 200 styles to find what you like.

Last edited by fgrittner; Yesterday at 12:35 PM.
Fred Grittner
2020 iMac, Sequoia 15.5, Logic Pro
https://fredgrittner.bandcamp.com