Originally Posted by Bass Thumper
The chart I shared is just my stab at trying to define "Edge" in a musical and actionable way such that if PGMusic so chooses they would have a starting point to implement an Edge Adjustment to their styles. I was thinking an Edge knob and Matt suggested a slider; same concept. As stated earlier, PGMusic would ultimately define what edge is within the context of BiaB style customization.

The point is that "edge" is a song attribute that is on a spectrum; it's not Boolean. Per my definition it ranges from 0 to 10. I don't necessarily call my edge definition "universal" but if that's how you interpret that chart, no problem, even though the intent was to have it apply only to a BiaB improvement.

That said, I'd be very interested in seeing your, and others charts that define "edge".

I agree that "edge" is a spectrum and definitely not Boolean. Yes, I do take your chart as universal.
From my experience I can not define "edge" in music. Is "edge" in jazz the same as "edge" in country? Or ambient? Or rock? ETC. I think not. Thus in my mind PGM would have to categorize "edge" in each and every genre. Plus "edge" can be a personal call. I would much prefer that PGM use it resources improving the search functions, make all tracks have identical functions, maybe add generic chord progressions like IIm-V7-C, and things like that than trying to define "edge". BUT that is only my opinion. I know that is different than yours but that is OK.


It takes courage for a man to admit his wife was wrong.

64 bit Win 10 Pro, the latest BiaB/RB, Roland Octa-Capture audio interface, a ton of software/hardware